跟本就唔係BAND1組別學生派晒學位先，然後先到BAND2組別學生派位！

大媽

正一靠估無辛苦

BillyM 寫道:
[quote]
fatbabymother 寫道:
So I think 教育統籌局 should give some briefing to schools and teachers on the ranking of secondary schools.  Otherwise they just guess or advise according to their own preference.

有好多老師是靠估的。派位好的小學很多時是因為學校在小六時幫家長做足準備，邊間BAND1頭中尾清楚列明，再依照小朋友的程度教家長們每個志願應填甚麼學校。

但某些求其的學校只會開一次家長會，派表，然後由每班老師自由發揮教家長填。所以我聽過有老師話銀禧是BAND1頭，Maryknoll是BAND1尾的笑話。[/quote]

菠蘿冰

Billy M,

我個女既班主任都話銀禧同黃笏南係BAND1頭, 而迦密係band 1 中,  你點睇???

fatbabymother

I think 銀禧同黃笏南 are better than 迦密 in the past.  But now may be Wah Ying, Hoi Ping and 迦密 are more progressive and have higher ranking.

So if the teachers did not have updated info, they will still hold the old ideas.

But I choose 銀禧 as 1st choice becasue the location and transportation is more convenient for me than Wah Ying, Hoi Ping and 迦密.  There is no direct bus transportation from my home to the other three.  It will take more than an hour to go to these schools.

Fatherno1

I agree. Hoi ping is good at sports too.

youma

我所認識的幾個銀禧友現今都是年入百萬以上的[打工仔]

所以我聽過有老師話銀禧是BAND1頭，Maryknoll是BAND1尾的笑話。

fatbabymother

Hurray! Hurray!  I hope my daughter can be one of them in future.

BillyM

菠蘿冰 寫道:
Billy M,

我個女既班主任都話銀禧同黃笏南係BAND1頭, 而迦密係band 1 中,  你點睇???

如果銀禧同黃笏南係BAND1頭，喇沙、Maryknoll係邊度？但撇除這一點，你女女班主任所講的都正路（起碼唔會話銀禧勁過Maryknoll；體藝係實用中學，BAND3讀唔到書先入…等垃圾高見）。

我覺得銀禧、黃笏南同迦密都係差不多級數的學校，收生上可能銀禧贏少少，但我對銀禧教學的評價麻麻，可search下我以前的posting。如果俾我排，我就會排迦密、黃笏南、銀禧。

BillyM

Fatherno1 寫道:
I agree. Hoi ping is good at sports too.

係呀男子田徑第四，緊次於DBS、喇沙及張振興！

菠蘿冰

FYI, 今年黃笏南在自行收生時要求學生中、英、數 同操行都要A 喎。     至於其他在統一派位時被派入去的學生質素係點就要在一兩次考試後才可以有結論。   不過其實佢係唔係band 1 頭都再無意思(係 lei 個階段) ，返正都派左入去，讀一年，唔對路先想法子轉校la!

freddy

菠蘿冰,
你的小朋友是否第一志願入黃笏南,有沒有其他同學第
二志願入了旅港,唔該!

菠蘿冰

freddy,

1) 第二志願;
2) 據我所知無。 (第二志願入到黃笏南既就有四個)
如果真係好想入旅港，應該將佢放第一位，否則機會好微。

fatbabymother

有沒有其他同學第二志願入了銀禧,唔該!

fatbabymother

Billy M 說:

如果銀禧同黃笏南係BAND1頭，喇沙、Maryknoll係邊度？但撇除這一點，你女女班主任所講的都正路（起碼唔會話銀禧勁過Maryknoll；體藝係實用中學，BAND3讀唔到書先入…等垃圾高見）。

我覺得銀禧、黃笏南同迦密都係差不多級數的學校，收生上可能銀禧贏少少，但我對銀禧教學的評價麻麻，可search下我以前的posting。如果俾我排，我就會排迦密、黃笏南、銀禧。

"收生上可能銀禧贏少少" 是何解?

菠蘿冰

銀禧就唔係好清楚，睇睇有無其他人有 lei 方面既資料!

BillyM

fatbabymother 寫道:

"收生上可能銀禧贏少少" 是何解?

一向銀禧都公佈自己收100%BAND1生，而迦密早兩年就話係9成幾BAND1，幾%BAND2，所以我話銀禧收生贏少少。沒有黃笏南的資料，但從大部份學生的選校策略中推斷，黃笏南通常都不是首選，通常都係稔左華英開平先到佢。

雖然話銀禧收生贏少少，但這數個%BAND1的分別沒有甚麼意義，最重要係睇下邊間學校適合自己的子女。

fatbabymother

Thank you.

I think 銀禧 is more 適合 my daughter because she does not like sports.  But from yesterday's school seminar,  銀禧 starts to promote their sports acitvities.

BillyM

fatbabymother 寫道:
Thank you.

I think 銀禧 is more 適合 my daughter because she does not like sports.  But from yesterday's school seminar,  銀禧 starts to promote their sports acitvities.

所有學校都會話自己注重紀律、鼓勵課外活動等，要作多方面資料搜集才可知到真係有幾「注重」、有幾「鼓勵」。