代友問：宣小 vs 灣仔 St Jo

retriever

回覆 mcl203 的帖子

係指做人做事, 唔係單指昇學.

mcl203

做人做事....St Joe 仔唔掂...??....咁似乎違晒一般人睇法

retriever

mcl203 發表於 16-6-24 14:19
做人做事....St Joe 仔唔掂...??....咁似乎違晒一般人睇法

你睇野太過簡單化, 有D 野唔係非黑即白. 唔係昇中, 入U 率... 唔係數字化.

譬如: COED 仔同 喇叭仔.


好明顯普遍CHARACTER 唔同...

你話佢地做人掂定唔掂?!

唔通只睇業績, 定幾多個5**, 所以打成平手?

mcl203

retriever 發表於 16-6-24 14:36
你睇野太過簡單化, 有D 野唔係非黑即白. 唔係昇中, 入U 率... 唔你數字化.

譬如: COED 仔同 喇叭仔.

又番去講成績

小學 > 做野 > 中學......跳跳跳

KikiDaddy

回覆 retriever 的帖子

My son transferred from SFA to SJPS two years ago. The main reason for the transfer is to reduce the secondary school place allocation pressure, so that he can enjoy his primary school life better. Since then, my son has spent more time to participate in differenct extra-curricular activities and in reading but less in exam revision.

In fact, my son might have a good chance to enter a secondary school better than SJC if he stayed with SFA. However, he would need to do many supplementary exercises to keep his ranking but this is not good for his personal development.

hkpapa852

mcl203 發表於 16-6-24 14:19
做人做事....St Joe 仔唔掂...??....咁似乎違晒一般人睇法

我相信:

如果父母做得不好, 小朋友無論去邊一間學校, 都唔會走得遠.

beagoodman

原帖由 retriever 於 16-06-24 發表
本帖最後由 retriever 於 16-6-24 13:10 編輯

有d反轉左對宣小的睇法喎，入宣小唔係主要睇升中去一缐比率嗎？學費十樂器唔平，校園又細，最最最值錢就係佢份升中成績表喎，如果佢升中比率同黃埔宣道一様，其他不變，我真係想知人地點揀？

retriever

KikiDaddy 發表於 16-6-24 15:20
回覆 retriever 的帖子

My son transferred from SFA to SJPS two years ago. The main reason for the tr ...

good to hear your son transferred to sjc. from the sspa stats there are not many schools that sfa boy graduates could go better than sjc.

i would consider sfa and sjps are in the same dept, very academically competitive catholic schools.


aps is of diff flavor.

mcl203

原帖由 beagoodman 於 16-06-24 發表
有d反轉左對宣小的睇法喎，入宣小唔係主要睇升中去一缐比率嗎？學費十樂器唔平，校園又細，最最最值錢就係 ...

所以我都有D奇怪 ~~~

retriever

回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

可能我地呢D外圍家長係咁睇..
但係圈內人未必人咁...

你可以問下D 宣小FANS, 好似MONKEY 媽媽, 金毛媽媽...

仲有FB 原來都有好多宣小畢業生掛著學校, 出POST 提起學校... 有興趣可以8 下...

佢地主要講唔係昇中成績...

你可以PM 佢地, 佢地好好人, 好樂意答人.

retriever

hkpapa852 發表於 16-6-24 15:22
我相信:

如果父母做得不好, 小朋友無論去邊一間學校, 都唔會走得遠.

同意.

但你所講既係反向邏輯.



有D 學校確係比較重孩子既人格發展, 有D 會少D...

mcl203

原帖由 retriever 於 16-06-24 發表
同意.

但佢所講既係反向邏輯.

我又幾時講過D乜邏輯呢?? 我係用晒??

我都未捕捉到你想講邊方面走得幾遠??

mcl203

原帖由 retriever 於 16-06-24 發表
本帖最後由 retriever 於 16-6-24 15:38 編輯

回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

你係边到見到SJ小學D家長講 好睇重成績?? 好緊張升中?? 又只顧住D成績?? 我就估揀SJ既家長係欣賞SJ有穩定成績表現，可以係12年內發展多D個人興趣，少D升中煩惱

kidder

My son is in SJPS P6.  The pressure and competition are not much when compared with other subsided schools that don't have connected secondary schools.  As long as the boy has an average academic performance (or say within 99 out of about 150 rank), you almost secure a place in SJC.  Free education for 12 years!
If you want to secure a good subsided secondary school with relatively less pressure, SJPS is good choice. There are mid-joiners in P5 from Ramondi and St Paul Boys in my son's year mainly for this reason.
If I were you, I will pick SJPS instead of APS for sure. Not mention the school fee, i do think there is less pressure in SJPS than APS.

retriever

kidder 發表於 16-6-24 17:27
My son is in SJPS P6.  The pressure and competition are not much when compared with other subsided s ...

what i was told is the competition to secure a place in sjc is very keen and stressful, for ppl want to be 100% sure their boy could secure a place, they have to be band one, that is to perform 60th or better out of 150 nos of boys. for the remaining 40 nos of places would be allocated to band two kids by luck, that is not the parents want to risk.


i have read  a nos of posts in forums and fb, and there are very rare no of -ve comment on aps. it sounds to me a warm and caring school that aims at nurturing kids by hearts and loves....and at lower grades the school try to get the kids right attitudes towards responsibilities and other ppl...  that s diff from the graduates simply being proud of their school, but show kind of affection to their school, that was shown in the fb posting by aps graduates.



sj appeals to me for boy only education and much less financial burden.

beagoodman

原帖由 retriever 於 16-06-24 發表
本帖最後由 retriever 於 16-6-24 15:58 編輯

回覆 beagoodman 的帖子

宣小是一間出色的小學，但難同St Jo比，就算佢唔洗錢，都係揀St Jo.

Yanamami

retriever 發表於 16-6-24 18:23
what i was told is the competition to secure a place in sjc is very keen and stressful, for ppl wan ...

禁其实LS GH Maryknoll HY.....要穩陣上中学部都－样係有压力~唔係新奇事~

mcl203

retriever 發表於 16-6-24 18:23
what i was told is the competition to secure a place in sjc is very keen and stressful, for ppl wan ...

你似乎將APS有既優點....去否定那些優點並不存在於St Joe

qooqoobaby2010

同st jo入面既人鬥好過同全香港既小6生鬥

marcuscyrus

原帖由 beagoodman 於 16-06-24 發表
宣小是一間出色的小學，但難同St Jo比，就算佢唔洗錢，都係揀St Jo.

我同意