耀中真係咁差?

Mighty

対着他門、我一点也没有你説的「嫉妒，羡慕」心態啊！！　「仇恨」、我有、不過請注意是他門的行為、不是因為是「中国人」３個字就去仇恨呢！　両馬子事啊。　明白嗎？　

Mighty

你問KELLETT的資料、都只是問校舎是点様的、師資不是更重要嗎？　

Mrslot

其實我覺得比得小朋友讀yc既大陸家庭都唔會太差，應該大部份都係香港做野既公司高層／做生意既有錢人，都係見過世面同有d學識，始終文化唔同會有d令香港人唔鍾意既行動（e.g.講野大聲），但香港人係外國人眼中咪又係咁。我地未去orientation，9月會睇下係點情況。不過如果讀is係為英文好我覺得唔好入yc，大把其他可以英文好native既選擇。我地想比小朋友讀is只係想佢happy learning，考慮yc係想一條龍唔使煩，另外要英文ok但中文都要有咁上下。而且讀is會有另一個得著（可能咁講好功利，但係事實），就係connection，讀cis，gsis果d咪好多有頭有面既家庭，第日暑假搵份好既summer job有人介紹都易d, yc就可能好多大陸幹部同生意人，做生意好靠呢d人（默）。

gracedolly

mena 發表於 13-8-1 15:12
唉我唔明點解YC要收咁多強國人, 我眼見起碼都有六, 七成, 仲係越低年班越多 ...

真心請問有證據嗎？我是家長，女兒班上只有數名內地同學。

gracedolly

Mrslot 發表於 13-8-1 17:21
其實我覺得比得小朋友讀yc既大陸家庭都唔會太差，應該大部份都係香港做野既公司高層／做生意既有錢人，都係 ...

贊同。我接觸過的同班家長都是本地專業人士，耀中舊校友，內地的也文化水平不錯。

20062001

gracedolly 發表於 13-8-1 17:31
真心請問有證據嗎？我是家長，女兒班上只有數名內地同學。

今日老師都話大陸人多la，我囡學琴那裡都有幾個內地人讀yc。讀真我個囡讀is既話就希望佢多接觸外國人。如果真係想接觸內地人，去上水既公園都大把內地人同佢接觸。我fri個囡讀HKIS，班裏得五、六個中國人，其它都來自世界各地。

fanfanbb

vivicui 發表於 13-8-1 16:02
13亿人口，你在耀中见到几个？代表了什么？香港700万人口，素质都参差不齐，如果我说天水围的香港家庭素质 ...

Why you would say some parents here are "心存嫉妒，羡慕，仇恨"? Have you gone too far? This is a discussion topic and you have to appreciate what "freedom of speach" is.  You said other "有病", this is "仇恨"?

Don't take it too seriously, it is a discussion after all.

mena

我地香港人只希望讀IS可以接觸不同文化的人, 而非咁單一, 同時去簡介會真的見到七, 八成國內人, 而亦見到Ｄ國內人唔排隊, 係洗手盆小便亦係事實, 你可以去見識下, 我地無話全中國人都係咁, 不要扭曲衣Ｄ事實, 同輩影響小孩亦好重要, 重視師資亦要重視他們的同學行為!

21Ckid

I sincerely advise existing and prospective YC parents NOT to come to this forum, because it is just like say a "coloured" person going to watch a standup comedian show in the west. You know, their usual trick is to tease the coloured, the small eyes, the funny language etc. Of course, this time perhaps when lights are up, you are astounded to see the comedians are themselves chinese! How sad.

There are many good advices and useful info i gain from EK, but there are also some arising out of pure imagination or perhaps merely out of fun.

Say, there are lots of mainlanders in YC, but nowhere near half, perhaps 20% ball park. Also, sometimes the critics are like critising why no spaghetti served in a chinese restuarant, and if so, it cannot be called a restaurant. YC i heard is a very good school (at least Kinder + primary) in nurturing kids, but english is behind IS as there isn't an immersed environment (as the school does not promote it). I believe most if not all YC parents don't mind it at all (or they wouldn't have come or would leave very soon). If this i not a concern to them but a concern to critics here, is it really a "problem" per se. Simialry, if YC parents can live up to 20% mainlanders at school, it is not an issue.

Many other pure imaginations, e.g. very few mainlanders in Harrow, but Harrow oftened "critisied" as such (assume this is a negative) here. ISF's english standard for early primary actually very good (most of my canto speaking friends' kids at ISF speak with very nice accent) but criticized for such (while the real problems of ISF seldomly mentioned, or perhaps don't really know).

optus

Why  many HK parents are so crazy for their kids speaking native English?My english sucks but i m currently running a group of companies in which i have american and english people as my employee.If they do sth wrong i would scold them like dogs!They must try every mean to make themself understood when talking to me!

What i want to say here is that language has never been the key to success,needless to say Chinese can hardly speak native english when they are growing up in such a city where Chinese is the 1st language.Take it easy parents!

Mrslot

香港仍然有好多人好narrow minded，大陸人一定係poorly educated同行為差劣，外國人一定係有文化有禮貌，所以覺得間學校多大陸人一定差，多外國人一定好....我住既屋苑咩人都有，有好有禮貌既大陸人，有自私既外國人，有無禮貌既日本人，去clubhouse一轉已經可以見識到，如果仍然睇唔起chinese（唔好忘記自己都係），同唔發覺到大陸人各方面都迎頭趕上，只會限制左小朋友既發展。多外國學生既is又會多drugs abuse，粗口橫飛。

要英文好，不如一早去外國讀，我自己由細到大都係香港讀，到讀左幾個master，英文ok，雖然一d都唔native，對我既事業同生活一d影響都無。而且無論你英文係幾native，外國人眼中你永遠都只係一個會讀英文既chinese，同香港口音既chinese無分別。

optus

移過民的人應知道最大的問題係點樣融入主流社會，吾明白呢度的家長反而想仔女從細就同香港主流社會的人隔開，如果要我個仔係普通話同英文兩者之間選，我寧願他普通話流利過英文。

仲有，揀學校吾係應從老師質數考慮，點解而家首要考慮同學的質數？

nintendo

vivicui  你实在有病，病得不轻。  發表於 4 小時前


=========



Please respect other people!!!!!

shadeslayer

原帖由 optus 於 13-08-01 發表
移過民的人應知道最大的問題係點樣融入主流社會，吾明白呢度的家長反而想仔女從細就同香港主流社會的人隔開 ...

因為同學對學生的影響可不少，尤其是高小和中學。

Mighty

首先多謝以上幾位為我DEFEND的朋友、無所謂架、平常心面対、係NEE　D　FORUM予左。

VIVICUI、多謝関心、我食左薬LA.

説到口音問題、自己問心個句、其実無論英文、普通話、誰不想講是NATIVE口音？　５通想係香港口音？！　也不是笑人這、笑人那、対希望擁有NATIVE口音、是一種追求、我覚得無錯BOR.

shadeslayer

原帖由 Mrslot 於 13-08-01 發表
香港仍然有好多人好narrow minded，大陸人一定係poorly educated同行為差劣，外國人一定係有文化有禮貌，所 ...

而且無論你英文係幾native，外國人眼中你永遠都只係一個會讀英文既chinese，同香港口音既chinese無分別。

Cxxxx

如果你看見一個金髪碧眼的外國人，佢一開口是地道香港音，你會不會心裡暗叫好？我就會。

HKTHK

EK never stops to amaze me in terms of its "diversity".  Some parents are just so

optus

回復 shadeslayer 的帖子

問題你地講到大陸學生好似洪水猛獸，連band 3的學生都不如，是否有d太過偏激呢？

我未去過YC所以吾敢講你地對定錯，但我識好多大陸人知書識禮，質數之高非一般港人可比。