- 在線時間
- 31 小時
- 最後登錄
- 12-3-28
- 國民生產力
- 2
- 附加生產力
- 4
- 貢獻生產力
- 0
- 註冊時間
- 11-3-11
- 閱讀權限
- 10
- 帖子
- 211
- 主題
- 3
- 精華
- 0
- 積分
- 217
- UID
- 713414
|
回覆 cow, BookloverJ 的文章
What's wrong with you two? Why do you keep focusing on the absolute difficulty of the questions despite my repeated clarification what I mean by "easy"? Everyone knows maths is less complex and less advanced than additional maths, including dumb sheung yi. You don't need to repeat that, again and again. What I need from you both is some sort of statistical proof that it is more difficult to get a good grade in additional maths, given equal ability in maths and equal preparation for the exams. What I said "arguably", it means "it can be argued". Cow's 6% A in additional maths and 3.4% A in maths is prima facie the basis that maths can be argued as more difficult. But of course we all know we have to discount the % for additional maths as the average additional maths candidate is more maths capable. How much should we discount, I don't know. I'm simply not certain which paper is more difficult. Cow, work harder, prove for us. When you want to say other people are wrong, challenge their basis, challenge their deduction, but don't just keep saying they are wrong.
What I say here is actually from my daughter as I said my exam days are long gone. Her original words are more or less like this: 附加數多數係翻抄,勤力啲做past papers 就得;數學section B題目有啲創意,難準備啲,真係對數學要有啲感覺至得。
Girls at HKCEE level are generally more hardworking, although at the top end boys perform far better than girls in additional maths (we expect that, don't we?), girls have a higher passing rate than boys in additional maths (88.9% vs 86.8% in 2010 again) This supports what she says. Moreover, the A% in maths is comparable with other major science subjects like physics, chemistry and biology; are these subjects then all "very, very easy". Mind your logic, guys. Cow, work out the problem for us, please.
Cow, your statement that all your classmates passed additional maths does not support your assertion that additional maths is the more difficult paper, does it?
[ 本帖最後由 雙儿 於 11-8-1 17:52 編輯 ] |
|