在「名校小學」的日子

st.bintai

dichiu 寫道:
catcatmom,

I totally agreed with you. I posted my comments about my daughter's unpleasant experience at Logos before and "st.bintai" also criticize me very badly. "st.bintai" will never consider others' feelings and always goes against others that have different viewpoint. We better ignore any more of her comments since it's meaningless to keep struggling with a person like this. Right?

[quote]
catcatmom 寫道:
st.bintai

當然無興趣知道你既academic standard，因一睇你寫既野，已經知你無學識兼無腦啦！st.bintai wrote：��地區拉 curve，     �� ，個個３唔識７路過既ＢＫ網民媽媽都係度笑緊你。
我係嘲笑緊你，明無？你既academic standard有幾多，仲係疑問咩！你繼續癡人說夢話。人地當你係lee度   有問題庶 ?  

[/quote]


所以話冇興趣你既 Academic standard 有幾高   

乜野叫拉 curve      點樣將全港既 negative skewness curve 轉 positive skewness    會出現咩效果    我就係到笑緊你

Pansy21

我都聽過地區拉 curve , 係o米真ka??         

dory13b 寫道:
我記得我考會考個年代真係地區拉 curve wor, 不過, 近年就吾知, 移家係o米無拉 curve 呢?         

st.bintai

dory13b 寫道:
我記得我考會考個年代真係地區拉 curve wor, 不過, 近年就吾知, 移家係o米無拉 curve 呢?         

拉 curve 係一定要    用來交代個靚靚 result

catcatmom

Dear all
會考係全港拉curve，無地區拉curve這回事，100% rumor。
會考的成績是不會根據個別地區而計算該區考生的平均成績，是而根據全港考生成績去計算出該年度公開考成績的平均數。雖然考生可以選擇任何地區做佢既試場，但不會因為有人特登走去新界區報考，而upgrade了考生的成績，這點是肯定。如果BK既家長對此坊間傳聞抱有懷疑，可致電香港考評局查詢電話：2834 9922，有專人直接解答。
有腦既家長都識analyze到會考係公開考試，俱有公信力，公平，公正，統一。
但無腦既甘就難講啦！

st.bintai

catcatmom 寫道:
Dear all
會考係全港拉curve，無地區拉curve這回事，100% rumor。
會考的成績是不會根據個別地區而計算該區考生的平均成績，是而根據全港考生成績去計算出該年度公開考成績的平均數。雖然考生可以選擇任何地區做佢既試場，但不會因為有人特登走去新界區報考，而upgrade了考生的成績，這點是肯定。如果BK既家長對此坊間傳聞抱有懷疑，可致電香港考評局查詢電話：2834 9922，有專人直接解答。
有腦既家長都識analyze到會考係公開考試，俱有公信力，公平，公正，統一。
但無腦既甘就難講啦！

你真係信呀    幾千人計錯分 唔見左份卷都有分你都信呀   公平 ? 搵 F.6 既學生改會考卷    你信港考評局   
你都幾有腦   

st.bintai

Y2KChild 寫道:
It is true that there is "拉 curve" for normalization of the results but surely not based on the living zones or school zones.


[quote]
Pansy21 寫道:
我都聽過地區拉 curve , 係o米真ka??          [quote]
dory13b 寫道:
我記得我考會考個年代真係地區拉 curve wor, 不過, 近年就吾知, 移家係o米無拉 curve 呢?         

[/quote][/quote]

如果用 normalisation 只係透過 central limit theorem 去推段個 mean , 搵唔到 grading    要玩個 median

catcatmom

pwkw wrote:

什麼?? st.bintai? 聖變太?wrote："地區拉 curve"?,如果信左又搬去屯門住就慘啦...咁大整蠱


    

st.bintai

catcatmom 寫道:
pwkw wrote:

什麼?? st.bintai? 聖變太?wrote："地區拉 curve"?,如果信左又搬去屯門住就慘啦...咁大整蠱


    

為左阿仔考試而搬屋    你都算聰明囉    你咁聰明就抄多幾次啦       用下個腦啦

st.bintai

Y2KChild 寫道:
The system operated by HKEA is trying to eliminate unfairless. Although there were human errors and mistakes from years to years, it doesn't mean HKEA will be so stupid to "拉 curve " based on living zones or school zones. Please use your logical thinking, right?

If you don't have any facts or inside information to support your hypothesis, please don't give your non-sensible deduction or guess to mislead others.

Please study more "Apply Statistics" before discussing with me on "Normalization". Normalization is not only used to estimate the "mean".



[quote]
st.bintai 寫道:
[quote]
Y2KChild 寫道:
It is true that there is "拉 curve" for normalization of the results but surely not based on the living zones or school zones.


[quote]
Pansy21 寫道:
我都聽過地區拉 curve , 係o米真ka??          [quote]
dory13b 寫道:
我記得我考會考個年代真係地區拉 curve wor, 不過, 近年就吾知, 移家係o米無拉 curve 呢?         

[/quote][/quote]

如果用 normalisation 只係透過 central limit theorem 去推段個 mean , 搵唔到 grading    要玩個 median [/quote][/quote]

一講 theroy 就發老皮   你 normalise 出 d 乜野

Please study more "Apply Statistics" before discussing with me on "Normalization".    

st.bintai

Y2KChild 寫道:
You are not deserved for me to teach you "Apply Statistics" on how to use normalization for grading the results. If you want to know more details, please ask HKEA directly.

Why not directly answer my question on your logical thinking and just as your usual practice of trying to divert the attention to other point to avoid the challenge on the loop hole of your logic?


median

[/quote]

一講 theroy 就發老皮   你 normalise 出 d 乜野

Please study more "Apply Statistics" before discussing with me on "Normalization".     [/quote][/quote]

乜野 loop hole 呀哥哥仔　 　你連最　fundamental 既　data characteristic 都搞錯，　拉 curve 既目的又搞錯 　你用　D so call  apply statistics 想顯示你識，　一ｃｈｏｋ　就話要問 HKEA directly　   

個問題晨早就話左係　ｓｋｅｗｅｄ　左囉　 　　
statistics 　係唔理　ｌｏｇｉｃ　咖    　你連statistics 係乜都唔理　又話avoid the challenge 　

好似係你功力唔夠，　耍左去know more details, please ask HKEA directly　左喎

st.bintai

Y2KChild 寫道:

Please provide the fact before you comment on others.

I just give a simple example to challenge your logic. You wrote that "你真係信呀  幾千人計錯分  唔見左份卷都有分你都信呀  公平 ? 搵 F.6 既學生改會考卷  你信港考評局".  

Even HKEA had made mistakes and even if HKEA really found F.6 students to mark the exam paper. It is not related to the system used by HKEA in conducted public exam or prove HKEA adjust the curve based of living zone as you claimed. You have no evident or inside information that HKEA adjust the curve based on living location or zone. Your reply is not directly addressing the point of discussion.  

There are too many similar examples from what you wrote and there is not necessary to quote all of them.

Can you see your so call logic now?

It is irrelevant to disclose how much "Apply Statistics" I learnt and I also don't want to give details on the theory in BK forum because I believe that this is not the point of discussion and not the interest of other BK parents.

Stay to the point of discussion but not divert to the outer sky!



[quote]

你真係信呀  幾千人計錯分  唔見左份卷都有分你都信呀  公平 ? 搵 F.6 既學生改會考卷  你信港考評局   
你都幾有腦

  

你講完一大輪費話你有冇 STICK TO THE POINT HOW APPLIED STATISTICS 幫你解決到個問題　？　你答唔出呀

搵下書如果出現　DATA SET 出現 skew 左之後點 ADJUST 　啦　   

Stay to the point of discussion but not divert to the outer sky!
  

pwkw

st.bintai,姓變態,
拉curve就唔洗你講啦.. 講講下唔見左"地區"兩個字既?
以為你只係變態,原來轉軚都咁好野,點夠你講呀.
講到北區/屯門既人好似蠢d咁,你一入去就分分鐘考到十幾個Ａ同Ｂ,你唔係咁變態呀?

你d數據係邊度來架? 好一句"孤陋寡聞"..

st.bintai 寫道:
當然無興趣知道你既academic standard，因一睇你寫既野，已經知你無學識兼無腦啦！st.bintai wrote：��地區拉 curve，     �� ，個個３唔識７路過既ＢＫ網民媽媽都係度笑緊你。
我係嘲笑緊你，明無？你既academic standard有幾多，仲係疑問咩！你繼續癡人說夢話。人地當你係lee度   有問題庶 ?  

[/quote]


所以話冇興趣你既 Academic standard 有幾高   

乜野叫拉 curve      點樣將全港既 negative skewness curve 轉 positive skewness    會出現咩效果    我就係到笑緊你

pwkw

St.bintai, 姓變態..
睇你個名都知你既POST係笑話啦..
"地區拉 curve"
什麼Havard小學無乞衣.(可能有架)"孤陋寡聞"
不斷演繹CCF既說話,一不留神以為你係CCF呀..

st.bintai 寫道:
[quote]
catcatmom 寫道:
pwkw wrote:

什麼?? st.bintai? 聖變太?wrote："地區拉 curve"?,如果信左又搬去屯門住就慘啦...咁大整蠱


    

為左阿仔考試而搬屋    你都算聰明囉    你咁聰明就抄多幾次啦       用下個腦啦 [/quote]

pwkw

St.bintai, 姓變太..聖變態..x變態,好名字..

下次要加個PG家長指引

catcatmom 寫道:
pwkw wrote:

什麼?? st.bintai? 聖變太?wrote："地區拉 curve"?,如果信左又搬去屯門住就慘啦...咁大整蠱


    

VLP

ｙ２ｋchild

Sorry ！　我睇左好耐唔係好明　？　人地好似話去第二個市場考試，　冇話　living zone？