HKU Mbbs

PoohsBaby

回覆 vee 的帖子

CU discriminate A-Level gah. Must have 4 or 5 A* AND all subjects must be 95% percentile or above. They hate A-Level students. Even if you are top student of your school, if any subject is below 95% percentile, REJECT.
For IB, they demand exceptional score i.e. 44-45.

That's why majority students you see at CU are DSE and their ratio of DSE is above 80%, unlike HKU who takes a more balance approach

poonseelai

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-29 12:40
回覆 vee 的帖子

CU discriminate A-Level gah. Must have 4 or 5 A* AND all subjects must be 95% perce ...

無須用 discrimate /hate這些字, cu一直收ib多過A level, hku就收多D a level

這幾年香港出生人數（包括雙非）倍增, 加上dependent visa, 咁多dse local students 比兩大選擇, 比non jupas local 嘅位自然少咗

政府一直無増加比 local students 15,000個資助學位, 只增加 non local 比例, 推動埋學生宿舍需求

KikiDaddy

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-29 12:40
回覆 vee 的帖子

CU discriminate A-Level gah. Must have 4 or 5 A* AND all subjects must be 95% perce ...

The reason may be just the other way round - many of the DSE top scorers prefer CU to HKU so that CU can get sufficient quality students from DSE. Hence, less vacancies are left for IB / IAL.

In fact, both medical schools committed to accept 70% of intake coming via JUPAS. HKU breaks the promise as they don't want to accept DSE students with lower scores.

PoohsBaby

回覆 poonseelai 的帖子


This is exactly the problem "cu一直收ib多過A level, hku就收多D a level"!

Why CU favor IB student? Very discriminating strategy. I am sure those IB students are not smarter than A-Level students. CU set the bar at >95% for all A Level subjects is unreasonable and discriminating. Why no bar for IB students? Only the IB score!


I think HKU realized that IB level students should not be favored and many are very capable, so they are happy to accept these smart A Level students. EDBs requirement to take more DSE students, like 70% doesn't make sense. Why do they allow many local Secondary schools to provide A-levels and IB, even the very famous 神校.

poonseelai

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-30 22:02
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

每間大學自主收生, 各自有自己選擇傾向有什麼問題？我都可以話hku discrimate/hate ib students, and this is not fair.

政府無設定任何收生比例, 港大醫那個70/75% dse 生目標係前醫學院院長定, 但佢之後走咗, 至於中大, 我無印象有講過收dse生目標比例

ckmammy

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-30 22:02
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

我相信其中一個原因係 IB 學生係 all rounded，文理科必修。A level 可以避弱科，亦唔需要做論文，CAS ，攞 4A*  易過 IB 43分。 我小朋友學校有啲同學 IB PG 得三十頭， 即刻轉去考 A level 已經 predict 4A*。HKU 比較 open to 所有學制，不過今年 MBBS IB conditional offer 44分， 其實係非常難 achieved, 而 A level still remain 4A*。

至於 EDBs requirement to take more DSE students, like 70% doesn't make sense. 我都同意呢個係好唔合理嘅做法，不過教育局要保障本地 DSE 生, 留多啲位畀佢哋, 因為有好多可能喺基層, 根本冇辦法去外國讀書。

nhi

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-29 12:40
回覆 vee 的帖子

CU discriminate A-Level gah. Must have 4 or 5 A* AND all subjects must be 95% perce ...

CU admitted only 70% jupas students every year, please don't be misleading. It is ridiculously easy to get an A*in AL science subjects for students of Chinese origin. That is why CU sets the threshold for admission at an average of 95 percentile for 4 subjects, and not for every single subject, again not to be misleading please.

poonseelai

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-30 22:02
回覆 poonseelai 的帖子

CU 要求除了看ib total points （最低42）, 仲要求3科high level subjects 要 6,7,7

"The minimum requirement is a final score ≥42/45, with grades of at least 6,7,7 in the Higher Level subjects."

https://www.med.cuhk.edu.hk/study/prospective-students/undergraduate-study/programme-and-admission/mbchb-and-gps/admissions/non-jupas#IB

即總分看似有最多3分buffer, 實質其中一科 high level subject 取不到6 or 7分已經無機會

睇返2025年5月考試的ibo statistics, 取40-45分的考生只得9.8%, 取42-45的應該無5%

加菲

唔好意思，題外話，我小朋友係考DSE，想請問5月中大醫科的面試，大約幾時會通知？我知應該唔係all in，謝謝

ckmammy

回覆 加菲 的帖子

呢方面我就唔清楚， 最好直接問返大學

Poyau

poonseelai 發表於 26-3-29 13:38
本帖最後由 poonseelai 於 26-3-29 13:41 編輯

無須用 discrimate /hate這些字, cu一直收ib多過A level ...

DSE 報考人數
--------------------------------------------------------
年份 學校考生 + 自修生 = 總數
--------------------------------------------------------
2026 46,390 + 12,186 = 58,576
2025 45,478 + 10,303 = 55,781
2024 43,295 + 7,508 = 50,803
2023 43,117 + 7,706 = 50,823
2022 43,032 + 7,032 = 50,064

2021 43,994 + 8,137 = 52,131
2020 45,931 + 6,756 = 52,687
2019 48,403 + 7,902 = 56,305
2018 51,675 + 7,364 = 59,039
2017 52,088 + 9,581 = 61,669

2016 57,162 + 11,005 = 68,167
2015 62,237 + 11,933 = 74,170
2014 66,613 + 13,002 = 79,615
2013 71,222 + 11,128 = 82,350
2012 71,762 + 1,114 = 72,876

https://www.hkeaa.edu.hk/tc/Media/facts/facts.html

https://www.hkeaa.edu.hk/en/Media/facts/facts.html

poonseelai

Poyau 發表於 26-3-31 13:33
DSE 報考人數
--------------------------------------------------------
年份 學校考生 + 自修生 = 總數 ...

你想表達什麼？

PoohsBaby

回覆 nhi 的帖子

Absolutely wrong to say "it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in AL in Science Subjects". A level results are still predominantly used in top universities in the UK, Oxbridge, Russell Group, etc. Are you saying these unis are rubbish?
I can also say it is easy to get a 44 or 45 in IB cause there are many subject options to select from (some are vary easy and with SL) and many Chinese students also get 7s in Sciences and Maths.
My point is why CU put the bar so high for A Levels at >95% and while IB doesn't have such requirement. This is discrimination in all ways. Many high caliber students cannot get an offer because of this practice. Also note many of these Professors and Admissions officer had probably taken HKAL or equivalent before, why they think they can treat AL applications so harsh.


Well CUs loss is HKUs gain I guess.

poonseelai

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-31 15:23
回覆 nhi 的帖子

Absolutely wrong to say "it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in AL in Science Subje ...

你好有趣, 你話英國top大學仍然主要收A level學生, 咁點解？ 正正咪英國大學當然比多D位考當地試嘅學生, 但你之前又話香港比大部份位dse生唔make sense???

ib要求3科high level 3科standard level, 但大學有subject requirements, 例如醫科Chem and bio 必須考HL, 你考Chem/bio SL 7分都無用

Poyau

poonseelai 發表於 26-3-31 13:49
你想表達什麼？

DSE 報考人數隨出生數目重拾升軌
出生數目到雙非落閘後2013年才回落

香港出生數目 #46
https://www.edu-kingdom.com/forum.php?mod=redirect&goto=findpost&ptid=3880117&pid=49416169

Poyau

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-31 15:23
回覆 nhi 的帖子

Absolutely wrong to say "it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in AL in Science Subje ...

England A level Summer 2025
18-year-old candidates ≥4A* 0.7%

England A level
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/qualification-results-in-england-summer-2025

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/qualification-results-in-england-summer-2025/qualification-results-in-england-summer-2025-accessible

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/68ca9a4dc6df905ce77084ba/Qualification_results_in_England_summer_2025.ods

ckmammy

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-31 15:23
回覆 nhi 的帖子

Absolutely wrong to say "it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in AL in Science Subje ...

IB 限制 science 只可以 take 2 科。 對於一個理科超強但文科弱嘅學生嚟講，A level 佢可以讀 phy chem bio math 攞 4A*, 如果你叫佢考 ib, 佢 bio, chem, math 都係3科 7分， 畀埋個7 中文 BSL， 攞盡都係四科7。但英文，humanities subject 或 EE/TOK 衰咗好容易就冇咗三, 四分, Medic 已經唔使諗。 咁呢個情況之下你係咪仲認為 IB 44, 45 易過 AL 4A*?

Poyau

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-31 15:23
回覆 nhi 的帖子

Absolutely wrong to say "it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in AL in Science Subje ...

England AL 18yo candidates
c.45% of GCSE two years ago
e.g. AL 2025 282k GCSE 2023 643k
If using GCSE as bsse, ≥4A* 0.3%

https://analytics.ofqual.gov.uk/apps/GCSEandGCE/SummaryStats/

猴子爸

PoohsBaby 發表於 26-3-31 15:23
回覆 nhi 的帖子

Absolutely wrong to say "it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in AL in Science Subje ...

问AI
”it's ridiculously easy to get an A* in international a-level in Science Subjects“ is this statement true?


相較於本土版（UK A-Level），
International A-Level (IAL)在理科拿A* 的邏輯確實更清晰，但說「極為容易」通常是針對有備而來的學生。

以下是支撐這個觀點的幾個核心事實：

• 模組化考試(Modular System)：
  這是IAL 最大的優勢。你可以把課程拆成Unit 1 到Unit 6 分開考。如果某一單元考砸了，你可以只重考那一部分，而不必像英國本土版那樣必須一次性考全卷。這種**「分段通關」*大大降低了拿A的心理壓力和難度。
• 考試機會多：
  IAL（如Edexcel）通常一年有三次考試機會（1月、5/6月、10月）。這種高頻率意味著你永遠有「補救」的機會，更容易透過刷分刷出A*。
• Grade Boundaries 的槓桿作用：
  IAL 使用UMS (Uniform Mark Scale)計分。只要你幾個單元的總分達到A* 的閾值，即便其中一張卷子沒發揮好，也可以靠其他單元的高分拉回來。
• 實驗考試的「紙筆化」：
  IAL 的實驗課（Unit 3 & 6）通常是筆試形式，考察的是實驗設計和數據分析，而不是現場實操。對中國學生來說，這比真正的上手實驗要好拿分得多。
• 資源外溢：
  理科的考綱非常穩定，市面上累積了極度海量的真題、分類題集和影片教學。只要智力正常且願意投入時間刷題，拿A* 確實是高機率事件。
  
  

我只是being curious.  你们可以继续。

poonseelai

Poyau 發表於 26-3-31 16:08
England A level Summer 2025
18-year-old candidates ≥4A* 0.7%

如我無理解錯, 一般大學3科AL已足夠, 考4科的相信都係target神校神科, 同時學生都有能力應付, 有幾多%考4科？

ib diploma就必須考6科+core

單純比較4A* % 就有局限