跟本就唔係BAND1組別學生派晒學位先，然後先到BAND2組別學生派位！

judy

Thank you for your reply. But if band 2 can get in e.g. True Light 中中, I put it as 30th choice in my list, I still can get in. Do you agree with me?

絕對同意!

kabee

聽聞話以往band2學生把丘佐榮放在1st choice,都有機會入到,若果你女女是 band1 (sure 的)又喜歖讀英中的,把丘佐榮放在第30th choice 頂住,1-29 想填甚麽就甚麽,基本上就實有英中讀,唔存在運氣(入傳统名校例外),當然,那裹有30間學校填呢.

Yesmee

fatbabymother:

我絕對同意你的講法.

既然知道自己女兒是是band 1 學生, 又在 kowloon city 校網內有 1/3 是英中學校, 我都唔明白老師為何叫你(咁早)係第3志願填中中,       所以有時真係唔好盡信學校老師比的意見,  有時佢地實在太保守.

hhma

我覺得係佢地驚d學生派出(out of)頭三個志願lor
對學校個ｒａｔｉｎｇ唔好ｌｏｒ
好自私呀！！！

Yesmee 寫道:


fatbabymother:

我絕對同意你的講法.

既然知道自己女兒是是band 1 學生, 又在 kowloon city 校網內有 1/3 是英中學校, 我都唔明白老師為何叫你(咁早)係第3志願填中中,       所以有時真係唔好盡信學校老師比的意見,  有時佢地實在太保守.

fatbabymother

Thank you for your support.  I think it is the policy of the school.  The shcool wants the percentage of getting into 1st 3 choices higher, so its reputation will be better.  Because it will not publish which schools the students get in, it only reports the percentage of getting into 1st 3 choices.  So after this, I dislike the school.  The school did not really help the students to get what they want and deserve.

uncleedward

Sorry. fatbabymother. You're right if you put True Light as the 30th choice and your kid is clearly a band one student, she will get into True Light if she failed to get into any of the first 29 schools.

The teacher is too conservative. However, we should not be mistaken that all band 1 students can get into English schools even if all his/her choices are English schools and the ratio of English school places to band 1 students is 1:1 in the school net. Let's not forget the feeder school, all band 2 students of the feeder schools to the English schools are guaranteed a place even the associated English school is put down as the first choice. This will take up some Englsih school places.

fatbabymother

So I also put some good Chinese schools at the end of the list.  But should not follow the teacher's advice to put it on 3rd choice. I think this is the technique for choosing if you are sure band 1 student.

DoReMi媽媽

kabee 寫道:
聽聞話以往band2學生把放在1st choice,都有機會入到,若果你女女是 band1 (sure 的)又喜歖讀英中的,把丘佐榮放在第30th choice 頂住,1-29 想填甚麽就甚麽,基本上就實有英中讀,唔存在運氣(入傳统名校例外),當然,那裹有30間學校填呢.

以往丘佐榮BAND 1收生比例約為75%, 另25%為BAND 2學生, 所以會有BAND 2學生派入丘佐榮.

fatbabymother

But our school teacher told band 1 students to choose 丘佐榮 as 2nd choice.  Is she crazy? And I know 2 students choose Wah Ying as 1st choice and fail, they 派 丘佐榮 (their 2nd choice).

DoReMi媽媽

fatbabymother
似乎你小朋友的老師過於保守, 照理在九龍城區網選校應可比其他校網更進取. 以我小朋友學校(九龍城網)為例, 舊年全級band 1生所選之1至6志願皆為英中,  但沒有聽到有band 1生派入中中, 而其中有個例子是雖然派不到第1志願, 但都派到第5志願英中( 丘佐榮).

fatbabymother

I think not 保守, but just as I mention before it is school politics, for the school reputation.

QUOTE  
Thank you for your support. I think it is the policy of the school. The shcool wants the percentage of getting into 1st 3 choices higher, so its reputation will be better. Because it will not publish which schools the students get in, it only reports the percentage of getting into 1st 3 choices. So after this, I dislike the school. The school did not really help the students to get what they want and deserve.

fatbabymother

Some mothers did not have much knowledge and follow the advice of the teacher.  Otherwise, I think their sons or daughters should 派到 better 英中.

DoReMi媽媽

如果真是為了學校的名聲, 而犧牲小朋友及家長的意願, 似乎有點兒那個~

freddy

May be some school think 丘佐榮 is better
thank Carmel or others. Because I know some schools really do.

fatbabymother

I dont think so because their teacher also know some band 2 students can get in 丘佐榮.

freddy

我朋友的女兒,成績很好, Band 1 頭, 她第一志願派了
丘佐榮. At that time, I was very surprised to ask why
she chose 丘佐榮 as first chose.  She also very surprised why I asked ?  
她充說:好她的女兒自行選了協恩,所以don't take a risk,
and the teacher advised her 丘佐榮 is better than
carmel. That's why she chose this one.  
Really don't understand ?

DoReMi媽媽

咁就真係R頭   舊年我小朋友學校全級頭30名o既學生冇人放丘佐榮做第1志願, 頭1-20名次嗰啲學生只係將丘佐榮放喺第5, 6志願, 20-30名次嗰啲就放喺2-3志願, 而介乎band1尾band2頭o既學生就擺丘佐榮做第1志願.

fatbabymother

So I think 教育統籌局 should give some briefing to schools and teachers on the ranking of secondary schools.  Otherwise they just guess or advise according to their own preference.

hhma

其實好多學校都係甘... :-x  :-x

DoReMi媽媽 寫道:
如果真是為了學校的名聲, 而犧牲小朋友及家長的意願, 似乎有點兒那個~

BillyM

fatbabymother 寫道:
So I think 教育統籌局 should give some briefing to schools and teachers on the ranking of secondary schools.  Otherwise they just guess or advise according to their own preference.

有好多老師是靠估的。派位好的小學很多時是因為學校在小六時幫家長做足準備，邊間BAND1頭中尾清楚列明，再依照小朋友的程度教家長們每個志願應填甚麼學校。

但某些求其的學校只會開一次家長會，派表，然後由每班老師自由發揮教家長填。所以我聽過有老師話銀禧是BAND1頭，Maryknoll是BAND1尾的笑話。