In 完SPK

shirleyng5

我見解都是一樣，SPK應該一早決定了收哪些學生，例如：有關係人士，interview只是一場show。

原帖由 chloewong1211 於 10-2-8 17:13 發表
其實我都覺得SPK一早已決定左收邊d學生，老實講，面試得嗰2-3分鐘點可能決定到收邊個呢，好似我依d冇背景嘅家庭: 冇宗教、冇人事、冇姐姐喺SPK讀 + 超細B，實唔收喇，我諗只不過因為學校收左我嘅報名費，點都要俾我去面試做吓樣 ...

KK07

原帖由 shirleyng5 於 10-2-9 11:51 發表
我見解都是一樣，SPK應該一早決定了收哪些學生，例如：有關係人士，interview只是一場show。

每年都有人咁講,我覺得St Paul收生原則真係神秘D, 不過話要有關係才收我就不太同意,我大女無關係,無宗教,無背景-收了,細女同樣月份出生,有家姐關係-rejected. 所以只可說interview 一定不是一場show.

zuzu888

你的經驗再一次証明月份同 sibling 都唔可以影響收生...咁佢的收生真係好神秘啊....
你大女係邊月出生呀?>.

原帖由 KK07 於 10-2-9 13:13 發表


每年都有人咁講,我覺得St Paul收生原則真係神秘D, 不過話要有關係才收我就不太同意,我大女無關係,無宗教,無背景-收了,細女同樣月份出生,有家姐關係-rejected. 所以只可說interview 一定不是一場show. ...

bebelee

I think the number of applicants might also affect the interview result - e.g. the number of applicants in the year of application for your elder daugther might be less than the year of application for your younger sister...

原帖由 KK07 於 10-2-9 13:13 發表


每年都有人咁講,我覺得St Paul收生原則真係神秘D, 不過話要有關係才收我就不太同意,我大女無關係,無宗教,無背景-收了,細女同樣月份出生,有家姐關係-rejected. 所以只可說interview 一定不是一場show. ...

Yorkie

Better put it in the way, seats will probably be given partly to those with relationship and those without! Sounds fair, i think every school do have the same situation but we just don't know!

mosibaby

唔係喎，之前有位mami又係大女讀緊但係唔收細女, 佢問個校長點解, 個校長話如果有家姐讀緊就要收細妹既話, 咁當初你大女已經冇機會入讀, 所以我覺得spk收生真係幾fair~

prettywong

We arrived SPK 30 mins later than the interview time due to some unexpected affairs. Though my girl could attend the interview finally, do u think LATE already made my girl fail the interview?

Tabobo

請問 spk 會比 預訂時間 (19/3) 早發信通知家長嗎 ? 好心急呀 !

四隻貓

根據我幾位正有子女在spk讀書的朋友的結論，這學校要求學生獨立和自理能力強。所以往年有幾類學生不會考慮：
1面試時害羞更甚至哭的
2被動的
3只會說英文不會中文的
4八月以後出生的細仔
當然這只是往年的經驗，今年可能會有改變也說不定，所以我一早預左唔得，因我女是九月細女。

四隻貓

其中一位朋友表示，第一天k1開學時，他女兒那一班是沒有任何一位同學會哭的，全都乖乖地坐下聽老師說話。由此可看到此校確有自己的一套方法，揀選了某類自己想要的學生。

ctytang

They won't cry in the first day because they are accompanied by parents.  This is my pure guess.

happysin

no..for the 1st to 3rd school days, though parents are allowed to accompany their kids, they are standing outside the classroom...

原帖由 ctytang 於 10-2-9 20:28 發表
They won't cry in the first day because they are accompanied by parents.  This is my pure guess.

ToToPiggy

四隻貓,

Would you let your child repeat K1 next year?  If you fail SPK this year, would you apply again K1 next yeat?  My girl is also Sept small girl, not sure if I should let her try K1 again next year (and become a super big girl)?

Would you like to share your opinion?

Tks.

totopiggy

sweetmemory

原帖由 ToToPiggy 於 10-2-9 21:39 發表
四隻貓,

Would you let your child repeat K1 next year?  If you fail SPK this year, would you apply again K1 next yeat?  My girl is also Sept small girl, not sure if I should let her try K1 again next  ...

我仔仔都係十月,雖然無喊,唔怕羞,自理能力高,但係佢係十月細仔,而且仲要係男仔呢,一定無可能收佢啦,我姑媽兩個孫女都係呢度讀架,好好架,十月出世,又唔大又唔細,細又未到最細,大就一定唔係,都唔知REPEAT 好唔好~

四隻貓

我都考慮緊，出年多數會再考一次。

bear2233

都唔一定架, 我個女的同學都係九月出世, 所以細仔都有機會架

原帖由 四隻貓 於 10-2-9 19:58 發表
根據我幾位正有子女在spk讀書的朋友的結論，這學校要求學生獨立和自理能力強。所以往年有幾類學生不會考慮：
1面試時害羞更甚至哭的
2被動的
3只會說英文不會中文的
4八月以後出生的細仔
當然這只是往年的經驗，今年可能會 ...

car123

聽聞佢哋鐘意收全職媽媽.

zitaeric

亞女嗰班有八,九成媽咪都返工,
亦有超細仔,超大女...
但個個都好乖..........

原帖由 car123 於 10-2-10 10:27 發表
聽聞佢哋鐘意收全職媽媽.

hellou007

My girl is now in the primary section.  I remembered that the sister in the kindergarten had mentioned that acceptance of siblings was not a guarantee as the school wants to give chance to others that have no relationship at all.  I know a lot of cases that the siblings were rejected.

jezzyuen

其實我本人好鍾意好鍾意呢間學校, 但INTERVIEW真係好睇小朋友, 何況當日我都唔知個女入左去..做過D咩?? 哈哈...只知佢無喊....所以, 我相信SPK係公正!! 有無緣份讀呢間學校呢?? 其實一切已成定局, 期待19號!!

原帖由 hellou007 於 10-2-10 11:08 發表
My girl is now in the primary section.  I remembered that the sister in the kindergarten had mentioned that acceptance of siblings was not a guarantee as the school wants to give chance to others that ...