係咪有錢才可成材

jackjackmom

原文章由 曲曲 於 07-11-29 11:51 發表
最重要係家長與小孩都盡力
有好多地方出名小學
家長將全數責任交給老師
家長及小孩都以為入來就會變叻
唔盡力都係徒然

Agreed. I think the parents play a major role in deciding whether your child will be successful or not.

Cartier

原文章由 CHTmami 於 07-11-29 17:10 發表


Aiya, 有件真人真事你可能未聽過.  上年有個有米家庭考Dxxxx, 有日有人打電話同佢講:"你個仔ok架, 拿, 預你30萬 ..."  真係好serious呀 .... 唔洗再screen once admitted ... ...

並非奇聞, 我朋友的老板每年捐好多錢比Dxxxx, 佢每年都幫好幾個生意上朋友的囝囝入到Dxxxx, 我朋友是其老板的左右手, 當然亦受惠.  但要指出一點, 朋友的囝囝有輕度自閉, 平日見人係彎下頭數小時唔出聲的.

THRIFT

原文章由 christf 於 07-11-29 17:19 發表
All ESF schools do not choose the best before admitting!!!

How many people can pay HK$54,000 for Primary and HK$85,000 for Secondary each year.  This is only minimum charge exclude extra-curricular activities!

[ 本文章最後由 THRIFT 於 07-11-29 17:34 編輯 ]

charwes

They are very "normal" families indeed - having difficulties in paying the $5xxx tuition fee by sacrificing some extra-curicular activities. I bet there might be some who are trying to eat less for the sake of paying the school fees as well.

原文章由 christf 於 07-11-29 17:26 發表
No, there are many normal families that you cannot called them wealthy or rich sending their kids to ESF schools. Of course, they can at least to afford the HK$5XXX school fee per month.  

I know tha ...

kyliema2006

原文章由 christf 於 07-11-29 17:19 發表
All ESF schools do not choose the best before admitting!!!

真的嗎?！我都認識有些小朋友面試ESF後不被接納的，那ESF以何基準收生呢?

kyliema2006

原文章由 christf 於 07-11-29 17:43 發表
Except ESF, all other IS will arrange interview for all the applicants and select the best performers.  

For ESF schools, say if there are 120 vacancies, they will only invite the first 120 applicant ...

明白！ESF即係會考慮學生的英語水平才決定錄取與否，換句說話，英語不達標就唔收。我認識的孩子英語是没有問題的，祇不過他面試時不說話。與其它小學的面試一樣，害羞的小朋友考ESF是没有優勢。

matthewdad

ESF only check the english standard of the kids. The requirement for different age group is in their web site www.esf.gov.hk

charwes

Not true. ESF is smart enough to preset minimum requirements for the applicants: setting the par of tuition fee at over $5,000 per month and made it an unofficial requirement that the kids have to be good English speakers.

And you consider that 有教無類? Maybe those who can't afford the $5k tuition fee and/or with lesser English skills should not even be classified.

原文章由 christf 於 07-11-29 17:43 發表
Except ESF, all other IS will arrange interview for all the applicants and select the best performers.  

For ESF schools, say if there are 120 vacancies, they will only invite the first 120 applicant ...

matthewdad

In the web site, there is official requirement on English and depends on age. HK Government only susidize for a portion and they need to response for P&L. 5-8K per month is the cheapest international school in HK

wacha

agree, 有d人派到d學校成日比人打就唔好啦!

wacha

原文章由 adhd 於 07-11-29 12:08 發表

我好認同以上呢句: 要 keep 住學校 / 學生 & 家長質素, 就唯有轉直資自己揀學生
學校至少見過個學生先收，係保證唔會有一些「破壞份子」或是「有病」的兒童。保障自己兒女唔同一些有「危險動作」既人一齊，保障自己兒女 ...

agree, 有d人派到d學校成日比人打就唔好啦!

wacha

原文章由 overview 於 07-11-29 14:37 發表
有時真係好佩服"喇沙",
在沒有揀學生同時,
學術都仍可keep到咁好,
校外校內都仍可獲獎無數,
睇呢幾個星期校際朗誦,
頭幾名緊有喇沙份,
靠乜?...喇沙精神..永不言敗囉..
老師們用好多心機,時間去栽培小朋友..
唔係好 ...

我估唔點一早go, went, gone.. 下年自動流失....

THRIFT

原文章由 Cartier 於 07-11-29 17:30 發表


並非奇聞, 我朋友的老板每年捐好多錢比Dxxxx, 佢每年都幫好幾個生意上朋友的囝囝入到Dxxxx, 我朋友是其老板的左右手, 當然亦受惠.  但要指出一點, 朋友的囝囝有輕度自閉, 平日見人係彎下頭數小時唔出聲的. ...

入到d學校成日比人X就唔好啦!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XAlie9LAy0g

Yau_Cheung

原文章由 matthewdad 於 07-11-29 21:04 發表
In the web site, there is official requirement on English and depends on age. HK Government only susidize for a portion and they need to response for P&L. 5-8K per month is the cheapest international  ...

Besides, ESF offer financial aid to students who have financial difficulties.

lalasweetie

BASICALLY YES.

BUT THERE IS ALWAYS MING AWE
AND SOCIAL FACILITIES FOR 社區康樂會 SO DON'T WORRY.
THERE'S ALWAYS COVER BY THE GOVERNMENT NET.

[ 本文章最後由 lalasweetie 於 07-11-29 23:26 編輯 ]