St Joseph VS ST Paul Boys, 高主教, ST Stephen

麟媽媽

哦…. 跌緊，咁唔算前境不明朗。
不過，係咪指成績，同邊個比？
只同St. Jo 比？定全港比？
還是比德行？同以往既師兄比？
我覺得華仁成績….比上不足，總比好多人好，
但老實，華仁德行都真係捉得好緊既，
細路成績唔好咩，老師唔會打比家長既，
但如果操行犯事，老師一定電話到既！
琴日我先收到老師來電，亞仔同人爭鼓油，
整烏糟第三者件恤衫，老師教訓一輪，
再打比我，叫家長要再教不可再犯。
朋友都話老師咪好唔得閒？係架，我好感激架。
半日制一堂只得35 分鐘，
為學生操行不良，老師花了20分鐘說教，
有家長會投訴老師唔教書，只鬧人，
但眼見小六生，真的個個小小君子。
所以，每個家長要求唔同，
將來要打做一個咩既成年人，
就睇家長要求咩囉，根本無得比較，係咪？
我覺得好滿意，亦懶理咩跌成點，
一個人唔鐘意，大把人排隊想入讀。

FUNG12345 寫道:
可能前境不明朗

[/quote]
我只係覺得兩間華仁都係跌緊[/quote]

cman_li

Is it easier to get a place in Wah Yan Primary School now?

麟媽媽

原來你係學生，
你咁講野已經影響緊你學校了。
我仔只是小三生，但只要著住校服，
便說不可亂來，免得令校名譽有損，
小朋友，你看到當中分別嗎？
我看你都唔好再係度嘈，失禮學校吖。

FUNG12345 寫道:
第1, 我係學生
第2, 我發表我自己意見關你咩事
第3, 我唔會回應你, 我唔會同d文化水平極低o既癡線佬理論
第4, 我唔知我唔知英華有咩得罪你, 但你話佢廢, 唔該你講下有咩廢
第5, 你成日走出黎嘈, 但我相信冇咩人會理會你, 你不如做多d有意義o既野啦, 好幼稚呀你

Charlotte_mom

唔駛勞氣wor! 每個人對"教育"definition唔同, 好似我, 就唔會揀st jo, 唔係話佢唔好, 係我唔想我既小朋友, 童年回憶就係默書測驗考試
人生一定需要學習, 不過我覺得, 除左讀書, 仲有好多方面都應該去試應該去做, st jo無疑係一間academic standard好高既學校(唔好用"好/唔好"呢個term喇, 太subjective), 成功非僥倖, 背後要付出幾多時間心機, 就真係要睇下家長覺得係咪justify喇
倒轉黎講, st stephen, st paul, 一般評語都係比較開心, 不過有人就會話--嘩, 俾咁貴學貴, 得到d咁既return, 唔值........(我就覺得好值), 總之甲之熊掌, 乙之砒霜啦! 自己鐘意ok咪得lor!

FUNG12345

麟媽媽 寫道:
哦…. 跌緊，咁唔算前境不明朗。
不過，係咪指成績，同邊個比？
只同St. Jo 比？定全港比？
還是比德行？同以往既師兄比？
我覺得華仁成績….比上不足，總比好多人好，
但老實，華仁德行都真係捉得好緊既，
細路成績唔好咩，老師唔會打比家長既，
但如果操行犯事，老師一定電話到既！
琴日我先收到老師來電，亞仔同人爭鼓油，
整烏糟第三者件恤衫，老師教訓一輪，
再打比我，叫家長要再教不可再犯。
朋友都話老師咪好唔得閒？係架，我好感激架。
半日制一堂只得35 分鐘，
為學生操行不良，老師花了20分鐘說教，
有家長會投訴老師唔教書，只鬧人，
但眼見小六生，真的個個小小君子。
所以，每個家長要求唔同，
將來要打做一個咩既成年人，
就睇家長要求咩囉，根本無得比較，係咪？
我覺得好滿意，亦懶理咩跌成點，
一個人唔鐘意，大把人排隊想入讀。


[quote]
FUNG12345 寫道:
可能前境不明朗

[/quote]
我只係覺得兩間華仁都係跌緊[/quote][/quote]
華仁可能小學捉得緊, 但中學就一d都唔緊
我唔係話佢地唔好, 同全港比就梗係好果d啦

FUNG12345

麟媽媽 寫道:
原來你係學生，
你咁講野已經影響緊你學校了。
我仔只是小三生，但只要著住校服，
便說不可亂來，免得令校名譽有損，
小朋友，你看到當中分別嗎？
我看你都唔好再係度嘈，失禮學校吖。


[quote]
FUNG12345 寫道:
第1, 我係學生
第2, 我發表我自己意見關你咩事
第3, 我唔會回應你, 我唔會同d文化水平極低o既癡線佬理論
第4, 我唔知我唔知英華有咩得罪你, 但你話佢廢, 唔該你講下有咩廢
第5, 你成日走出黎嘈, 但我相信冇咩人會理會你, 你不如做多d有意義o既野啦, 好幼稚呀你

[/quote]
我咁都叫係度嘈?
佢唔係第1次針對我同我學校
唔知你認為我應該點回應呢? 應該點講先岩呢?
我覺得我除左第3點比較粗鄙少少外, 應該都冇咩問題

麟媽媽

你對學校有Sense of belonging，
係好事黎既，當然係你心中學校係最好，
如果唔開心，你都唔會咁維護學校。
不過，做人應該客觀D 分析，
亦應該嘗試開對耳仔聽吓唔同既聲音，
人家既讚賞或批評都應接受，
從中再自己分析有幾多地方可以再改進咁，
網上世界係咁架喇，唔使咁上心，
呢度大多係父母，講野好客氣了。

FUNG12345 寫道:

我咁都叫係度嘈?
佢唔係第1次針對我同我學校
唔知你認為我應該點回應呢? 應該點講先岩呢?
我覺得我除左第3點比較粗鄙少少外, 應該都冇咩問題

LLT

BoBoCute 寫道:
而家lucky draw！

True as it may when one is talking about primary school admission, it is not entirly correct in so far as admission to secondary school is concerned.

The admission to govt. or subsidized SECONDARY school is comparable to a happy marriage between two consensus adults – the school and the students.   The school chooses the students and, likewise, the students choose the school.

The criterion of the  'lucky draw' in secondary schools is different from that of the primary, as Band 1 secondary schools are for Band 1 students (or now extended also to the upper sector of Band 2 students after the banding classification was reduced from 5 to 3 a couple of years ago).  It has nothing to do with the residence of the students.  Indeed, it is impossible for a Band 3 student to get into Band 1 govt. or subsidized secondary school under the prevailing policy.

Just by way of supplement, I don't see it a 'screening process' adopted by SJC.  The reality is: How can SJC take back all its primary students when its students' establishment is confined to 200 seats?

A further problem for SJC is being obliged by the government policy to make available a certain portion of the seats for the secondary school 'luck draw'.

So, what can one do under the circumstances, if he is the principal of SJC?

I fully understand the difficulties that SJC is facing, notwithstanding there is a real risk that my son may not, in future, manage to secure a seat there.

From my observation thus far, there is no pressure given to the pupils by SJP.  If there is such a pressure, it comes from the parents instead of the school.

FUNG12345

麟媽媽 寫道:
你對學校有Sense of belonging，
係好事黎既，當然係你心中學校係最好，
如果唔開心，你都唔會咁維護學校。
不過，做人應該客觀D 分析，
亦應該嘗試開對耳仔聽吓唔同既聲音，
人家既讚賞或批評都應接受，
從中再自己分析有幾多地方可以再改進咁，
網上世界係咁架喇，唔使咁上心，
呢度大多係父母，講野好客氣了。

[quote]
FUNG12345 寫道:

我咁都叫係度嘈?
佢唔係第1次針對我同我學校
唔知你認為我應該點回應呢? 應該點講先岩呢?
我覺得我除左第3點比較粗鄙少少外, 應該都冇咩問題

[/quote]
如果係善意批評就當然冇問題啦
但問題係佢係唔係都走黎話我講d野唔岩
跟住就係咁話我學校=.= 我真係唔知佢想做咩

gjmum

Delete

BoBoCute

FUNG12345 寫道:
如果係善意批評就當然冇問題啦
但問題係佢係唔係都走黎話我講d野唔岩
跟住就係咁話我學校=.= 我真係唔知佢想做咩

不要太介意網絡上嘅人。邊個有品,邊過冇品大家一看就知。

這4學校都算是popular,有貴有平,排名當然人人不同。
If all of them are free or if I am very very rich, I will definitely choose ST Stephen.  But given that St. Jo is free and St. Stephen is so expensive, St. Jo becomes quite attractive too.
DGS 又夠勁啦,但我都唔會想個女入，高攀唔起。
但人哋問我,我一定話DGS is the best girls' school for smart and hard working girls.
如果大把錢，我一定選名私校直資 instead of govt subs.  。但好多富豪後代都讀津校，就証明大家心裡條尺都唔同,冇特定答案,上嚟喺想大家交換資料/意見,免傷和氣。

Leechi

gjmum,

請問除了以上問題, 還有其他嗎? 英文是否Net teacher教?普通話教中文又如何? 數學是否全英, 有沒有難度, 你仔仔讀得開心嗎 如果再一次考小一, 你依然會選 St Stephen 嗎?  有無後悔入左呢間, 學費貴, 又不外如是感覺呢!

LLT

BoBoCute 寫道:
不要太介意網絡上嘅人。邊個有品,邊過冇品大家一看就知。

Fully agree.

FUNG12345,

Though you are still a student, you are welcomed to express your opinion in this forum.

I respect your freedom of speech and expression, and look forward to hearing your view and opinion again.

cfanny

heard from a friend, about 85% (4.5classes)F.1 students of St. Joseph's Secondary are from St.Jo Primary. They have 200+ (5 classes)students in F1. Don't know how many students in Primary section. The secondary school is willing to accept their own students from primary school. And the kids can also be happy in learning if their parents are not too demanding. The academic level is undoubtably very high esp. compare with schools in the same district.

St. Paul's Boy, it's more famous since it has become a DSS school and can select their own students. The moral edu is very gd in this school.

St. Stephen's College, many parents have many +ve comments here.Though the academic level may not be as high as St.Jo, it must be a very gd school and provide a gd learning atmosphere to students.

gjmum

Delete

Leechi

gjmum,

中學是否一定要寄宿, 知唔知中五畢業生出外留學多, 入左本地大學多唔多?  遲d 是否轉IB?

LLT

cfanny 寫道:
Don't know how many students in Primary section.

There are 300+ students in SJP at the moment (but it is expected that the no. will be reduced in a couple of years).  It has a total of 8 classes of P.1!

gjmum

Delete