Zenith英藝點解唔受歡迎？

pure_carol

回復 simb 的帖子

睇完的post

simb, 如果醫生話可能係大人整，你有冇同差人講?  
如果係大人整，又係幼稚園發生，那比你pm的更可怕，但呢個可能細的。
如果係大人整，但唔係幼稚園發生，咁會否係親人或工人整? 咁就仲得人驚。

平時那個人接你個女返學放學? 案發那幾天返學放學有否異常? 誰幫你個囡沖涼，係咪工人? 那人有否發現傷? 有無人成日會湊你個囡，男定女?

希望查清楚，你個囡可以平平安安，祝早日康復。

baby023

回復 sig28 的帖子

其實好多人都討論,我諗多左人會衝上黎睇,所以突然間多左都唔出奇,因為睇過個家長d po,好似唔多似係打手,我講ge事實都唔係在於男童身上,我都係講睇po既人都只係憑受害人媽媽既文字上睇佢打既野,打字可以寫到天花龍鳳,要幾心痛有幾心痛,學校有幾衰就幾衰,同樣地,學校點諗,佢都可以寫到自己做好本份一樣,呢d都只係雙方自己知,我唔係話緊媽媽亂講,因為我都撐媽媽,不過,以事論事,我係覺得d人係咁諗

Ccalmch

原帖由 pure_carol 於 13-05-15 發表
回復 simb 的帖子

睇完的post

我諗法係一樣，終於有人提出會唔會有機會係親人或工人而唔關學校或男童事！我有同事個囡囡之前大脾內側有瘀痕及下體痛楚因突然有一日佢幫囡囡沖涼発現，問工人，工人話佢囡囡 自己整親，回佢囡囡，佢話自己整親，但後來佢覺得可疑，不斷問佢囡囡點整到，佢囡囡先話係工人姐姐做㗎，仲恐嚇佢囡唔可以講出嚟！幸好佢囡囡當時大概四歳，可以講出真相！之後同事報警！拘捕咗工人，呢件事發生在2011年，當時亦有上咗蘋果！從我同事嘅個案睇，好多嘢唔可以睇表面！希望Simb快啲查過水落石出，囡囡快啲好返！忘記傷痛，重新開始！

rainbowcov

Ccalmch 發表於 13-5-16 03:37
我諗法係一樣，終於有人提出會唔會有機會係親人或工人而唔關學校或男童事！我有同事個囡囡之前大脾內側有瘀 ...

但唔只一個受害者喎。

rainbowcov

rainbowcov 發表於 13-5-16 07:01
但唔只一個受害者喎。

另外，個男童真係退左學。

lingyan828

Totally agree. Better than spread the case in bk.

lingyan828

Total agree with Kat_fong. The victim family should report to police asap better than spread the case in bk.

minirat

原帖由 lingyan828 於 13-05-16 發表
Total agree with Kat_fong. The victim family should report to police asap better than spread the cas ...

If I am not wrong, simb already made a police report.

edithseto

I understand that no victim family reported to the police thus police cant do anything.  (only victim family can clarify with it).
Having considered the serious of the case and "may be" there is another 案中案，its better for the police to investigate the case.

minirat

edithseto 發表於 13-5-16 09:18
I understand that no victim family reported to the police thus police cant do anything.  (only victi ...

This is not in line with the information I got from simb.  Even though I share your views completely that a police report is important in this case considering its seriousness, we are not in a position to judge.

Kat_Fong

i just feel strange no action taken by police and education authority up to now. it may because there was victim report to them. i don't think they will ignore this serious case as mentioned by the victim's parent because we are in HK.
Above is just my opinion, if you dislike, pls ignore. thanks

Ccalmch

但為何其他受害者從無出現過，男童退學有可能男童媽媽受到太大壓力所以要退學！我只是理性分析，不喜勿插！而家已交由警方處理，希望早日查出真相！

minirat

Kat_Fong 發表於 13-5-16 09:58
i just feel strange no action taken by police and education authority up to now. it may because ther ...

I don't know what is the procedure after making a police report.  Maybe the polices are working on it already?  Just a wild guess...

minirat

Ccalmch 發表於 13-5-16 10:06
但為何其他受害者從無出現過，男童退學有可能男童媽媽受到太大壓力所以要退學！我只是理性分析，不喜勿插！ ...

你話“從無出現過”是咩意思，出現系邊度？  就算有其他家長一起去了學校吵，甚至報案，我地都唔會知。 我只是理性討論，不是懷疑你的論點。

minirat

TaiLoBo 發表於 13-5-15 20:09
I have read it.  Thanks.

I don't believe the victim's mother would risk being sued for defamation  ...

I share with your views.  The reason why I chose to believe victim's mother is simply because I have been talking to her since few months ago (way before this incident) and she always gave me positive and objective feedbacks about Zenith.  I can tell that she is a reasonable and sensible person.  I do not see why she needs to "make use" of her daughter and at the risk of hurting her, to go to this extent to inflame and ruin the school's reputation, except for the obvious reason that it is a fact.  If the school has managed it well, there is no reason why she needs to go this far, coz she will gain nothing out of these, except the risk of being questioned by minority who does not believe her.  Simple as that.  I am not siding anyone but just my rationale towards this whole incident.

Ccalmch

Mini rat , 我誤會咗我嘅意思，呢個係我問嘅問題！（只想知道有冇其他受害人真的出過聲或向學校投訴過）而唔係我嘅想法！如真的有其他受害人，相信家長們唔會保持沈默！我是理性分析而已，我只站在一個笫三者立場去睇，我亦唔係偏幫學校，當時情況亦只有simb囡囡至知！

pure_carol

首先，我相信simb, 但我係度諗，如果換轉係我，我會不會太心亂而miss左一些point.

first, 個k1男仔“非禮”左simb個囡，就一定, 呢樣both simb 同學校都係咁講，只係程度唔同。
but, 個k1男仔“非禮”左simb個囡，唔代表唔會係差不多時間有大人傷害過simb個囡。因為如果醫生講得可能係大人整，我覺得可信性幾高。

second, 如果受害女童唔止一個，先唔好理有沒有其他受害家長企出來講。the point is 其他受害女童，所受的肉體傷害有沒有好似simb個囡咁嚴重?  

明白simb好傷心，但都要振作，把真正傷害囡囡的那個大人抽出 avoid更多的傷害。

minirat

Ccalmch 發表於 13-5-16 10:42
Mini rat , 我誤會咗我嘅意思，呢個係我問嘅問題！（只想知道有冇其他受害人真的出過聲或向學校投訴過）而 ...

明白！ 我贊成只有當事人先知。

faipy

回復 mable0901 的帖子

好恐怖!

Mqchris

回復 pure_carol 的帖子

我個人認為，若果真的只是那男童做，學校則不應只讓他退學就了事！試想一個三四歲男孩，專家沒錯，當然沒非禮的念頭，但何解懂得觸摸異性敏感部位？男孩如何會感好奇得要出手？
好大機會是看過，甚至試過才懂得！男孩對性器官敏感不出奇，尤其男仔自己的更常見，但會出手的，他一定某程度上有一些背後的可能，我指行為問題或家庭問題！他就咁就轉校，對他沒解決過問題亦無處理過！去到第二到，就唔會咁咩？希望男童家長如看到，都正視一下！
我不是想誇大事情，只是以事論事。
亦只感到學校真的處理失當，對事主女兒感到難過！盼望你們可以盡快處理好！繼續開心生活！