Someone told me, second choice can get 喇沙 ?

ChiChiPaPa

WIN2007

WIN2007

ChiChiPaPa

TWMa 寫道:
[quote]
唔奇！ 從來未聽過小學派位的程序或電腦程序有經過審核，所以電腦程序或輸入上出錯，唔出奇。

ChiChiPaPa, 唔好講笑啦.[/quote]

唔係講笑。我曾在四大會計師事務所之一做電腦審計。是我的經驗告訴我，未經獨立審核的電腦系統，未必可靠。

WIN2007

I have read many exampe here.

Like :
Second choice can get 九龍塘聖家 (Click here)

Does anyone cannot get 九龍塘聖家 in first choice ?

I have read the video for explaining the procedure from EMB thoughfully. It is impossible.

The computer system may have problem ?

hinhinmummy

mayc 寫道:
將喇沙放在第二志願 = 掉落鹹水海!
有無人"甘"傻呀?     

呢個先係main point, 係得果區抽, of course心中要讀名校都係填第一志願啦, 如果第二志願先填喇沙, 我真係好想知, 佢心中的名校係邊間, 拿黎填第一志願啦

如果第一志願都吾係超超級名校, 緊加吾會搵一間超超級名校放第二位啦, 明知c 硬, 我真係諗吾到有人會甘蠢/傻, 將喇沙填係第二位啦

除非............................佢岩岩移民黎香港, 不熟小學d 名, 以為喇沙係一間普通小學, 又多喇又多沙的小學黎啦

Sindy

第二志願聖家都合理架喎...好似mcs都係呢個網丫麻

WIN2007 寫道:
I have read many exampe here.

Like :
Second choice can get 九龍塘聖家 (Click here)

Does anyone cannot get 九龍塘聖家 in first choice ?

I have read the video for explaining the procedure from EMB thoughfully. It is impossible.

The computer system may have problem ?

Sindy

唔係掛..............我係港島都知協恩出名喎.......

Planet 寫道:
我有朋友睇見前面個女士張form,將協恩放係第11位都會抽中~~佢首選係聖羅撒因係其幼稚園學生

MiaoMommy

Have you call your friend? any news?

I have checked with EMB, they said it is impossible as the rule of the game will not allow this!

(Unless it is really computer bug or error!)

Miracle happens on those children!!!

MiaoMommy

Have you call your friend? any news?

I have checked with EMB, they said it is impossible as the rule of the game will not allow this!

(Unless it is really computer bug or error!)

Miracle happens on those children!!!

[quote]
WIN2007 寫道:
The First Choice is Diocesan Preparatory School (DPS) in Net 41.
I don't believe it also.

However, the friend is traceable. Let me find out the truth and tell all of you later.

WIN2007

I have confirmed with my friend.
It is trued that she can get  喇沙 in second choice not second round.

Is there anyone able to tell me how many seat in second round available in 喇沙? and anyone  first choice cannot get 喇沙 ?

After I get this information, I want to check with EMB formally and query about the fairness of the computer system.

MiaoMommy 寫道:
Have you call your friend? any news?

I have checked with EMB, they said it is impossible as the rule of the game will not allow this!

(Unless it is really computer bug or error!)

Miracle happens on those children!!!

[quote]
WIN2007 寫道:
The First Choice is Diocesan Preparatory School (DPS) in Net 41.
I don't believe it also.

However, the friend is traceable. Let me find out the truth and tell all of you later.

SAM43

is really 喇沙 or another "Chan sui Kei 喇沙 " ????

WIN2007

Net 41 喇沙.

If second choice can get 喇沙, only two possible reasons :

1. According to EMB, No. of  people taking 喇沙 in first choice is less than the place available. Then the second choice can get it.

2. The computer system is not according to the procedure claimed with EMB. It is a serious bug.


But for HK government, nothing is impossible, I think

SAM43 寫道:
is really 喇沙 or another "Chan sui Kei 喇沙 " ????

WIN2007

Therefore, I want to prove it.

Anyone cannot get 喇沙 in first choice ?

Clementmammy

I applied LS in both first and second section (I am living in net 41)

hijam

Please count me in !
I put LSC as 1st choice in both Part A and Part B !!!!!

WIN2007 寫道:
Therefore, I want to prove it.

Anyone cannot get 喇沙 in first choice ?

MiaoMommy

Do you put LS 'the only one' in Part A and LS the first choice in Part B? If you have 2nd and 3rd choices in Part A, the first choice in Part B will be your 4th choice!

Clementmammy 寫道:
I applied LS in both first and second section (I am living in net 41)

hijam

Hi MiaoMommy,

  I did so and I think most of the moms did the same too ! If someone could enter LSC by the 2nd choice, I think EMB surely made seriously mistake AGAIN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

MiaoMommy 寫道:
Do you put LS 'the only one' in Part A and LS the first choice in Part B? If you have 2nd and 3rd choices in Part A, the first choice in Part B will be your 4th choice!

MiaoMommy

Can parents request EMB to check the priority of all the boys admitted to LS in order to check out whether there is such the case? (get offer even put it as 2nd choice in Part B?)

It is so obvious that number of people put LS as the only choice in Part A and 1st choice in Part B more than the places available!