致某某小學既校長 !!!!

wutoa

hinyanma 寫道:
If not the name, at least I would like to know the school net of the lousy school. A school wiht poor management does not help any child in his develpoment.
Letting others know the school helps to avoid more become victims. The kids have future then.

By the way, the principle will not care unless the parents get away from the school.

take my advice telling others to save the parents and save teh kids

有冇咁嚴重呀？

家熹媽咪

0606 寫道:
[quote]
小小bb 寫道:
直資是用納稅人的錢, 不收非香港永久居民是對的, 但學校應該一早看清楚才收生

講開 "納稅人" 的錢, 我又不明白, 為何政府會用全港納稅人的錢, 去資助公務員的仔女讀直資

我不是有心針對公務員, (我都知呢個網站都有好多公務員), 我只是有感而發啫 [/quote]

呢個真係一個迷 ! 納稅人幸幸苦苦納既稅 , 用既竟然唔係自己身上 , 我都冇意思話針對公務員 , 只係唔明 , 點解公務員可享倒咁高既福利 , 但我地就..... 大家都打份工 , 只係唔同老細 (香港特區) , 哈 ~~~ 自我安慰既咪同自己講 , 同人唔同命囉 ! SORRY ! 希望唔會令其他公務員反感 , 我都係有感而發 !!!       

家熹媽咪

Alice :

嗚 ~~~ 終於等到你出來喇 ! 會唔會怪我地太多事呢 ? 雖然大家都唔可以為佢做d咩 , 但我真係有種唔講唔舒服既感覺 !

家熹媽咪

Beeruma 寫道:
It's just another example of poor school administration.......

I feel sorry for the "victum", 2.  Hope she finally got a good school for her son in HK.

Rgds,

p.s. Anyway 家熹媽咪 has chosen not to tell the school name so we could not  know which school is it.  But we have to respect her choice.  家熹媽咪, you are really so kind.

多謝你既體諒 ! 我別無他意 , 我亦唔夠資格去要求學校作出d咩回應 , 只係 , 都係果句 , 不吐不快 ! thankyou~

家熹媽咪

hinyanma 寫道:
If not the name, at least I would like to know the school net of the lousy school. A school wiht poor management does not help any child in his develpoment.
Letting others know the school helps to avoid more become victims. The kids have future then.

By the way, the principle will not care unless the parents get away from the school.

take my advice telling others to save the parents and save teh kids

很抱謙 ! 我唔希望喺件事未得到解抉時 , 將件事公開 , 咁對間學校都係唔公平 , 加上 , 由一開始到現在 , 我亦先此聲明 , 唔好問我係邊間學校 , 希望你可以體諒 ! 我當然明白 , 你地都有權知 , 但我亦有我既原則 , 我再強調 , 我開呢個topic 既目的有2 ,

1. 好想有關教育界人仕得到關註 , 做任何決定時可以多加了解 , 唔好再出現我這位朋友既同類事情發生 .
2. 我這位朋友都冇嬲 , 冇怪任何人 , 任何物 , 只係旁觀者既我 , 睇倒有點兒那過 , 我先開呢個topic 黎同大家分享 !

我要講野就係咁多 ! 如果你體諒我既 , 我會衷心多謝你 , 但你唔體諒既 , 我都冇辦法 ! 因為個人觀點角度不同 ! thankyou!

莎莎

我覺得整件事都好奇怪，學校無理由無叫家長出示外地出生兒童的留港資格。　　

我仔在外地出世，有外國ｐａｓｓｐｏｒｔ，但我帶他回港後立刻申請了ｈｋ永久居民權。　　

我記得以前申請幼稚園＆小學時（尤其是自行收生那階段），都會附上護照上証明取得ｈｋ永久居民權的加簽ｃｏｐｙ。

愛麗斯

我非常贊成家熹媽咪唔將間學校名公開，雖然我都認為間學校處理手法有問題。
其實在於學校來説，可以收到一個咁有誠意而程度又唔差既學生，由其是個小朋友是一個説流利英語的，既然個外籍小朋友咁有心想學中文，而入去讀直資學校既小朋友又想學多d英文，真係一家便宜兩家着，何樂而不為呢?如果d小朋友可以有咁好既語言環境，對小朋友幫助也不少呢! :  :  :

Smiley_face

Sorry, just like to know if it is true that Non Permenant resident(永久居民) is not acceptable in Primary school. As far as I know, if the kid is staying in HK legally, he can attend even 直資 or Govt. Primary school.
My son is not a 永久居民 in HK but I am  永久居民 who pay tax and he should able to attend 直資 or Govt. Primary school.

小小bb 寫道:
直資是用納稅人的錢, 不收非香港永久居民是對的, 但學校應該一早看清楚才收生

Smiley_face

According to the Govt. P1 admission leftlet as long as the kids is Hong Kong resident (not necessary Permanent resident) he is eligible to study in P1 in HK not matter Private or Govt School. Please read the link :
http://www.emb.gov.hk/FileManager/EN/Content_1511/emb-lft-e.pdf
It is only shows the school 種族歧視, that is too much. I suggest let everybody know which school it is.

Smiley_face

Agree! 去平機會投訴啦!

Charlotte_mom 寫道:
下? 一收form已經知唔係香港出世啦
本身有咁既standard已經好唔arm, 仲要俾false hope, 真過份
個校長咁都講得出口, 去平機會投訴啦 :evil:

mrsho

I think the boy was borned in HK, right?


"但係我有個朋友同佢個case一樣，個小朋友(也是外籍人)今年剛剛入讀了一間津貼學校(一毫子學費都唔洗都唔交)，咁點一間全政府資助既學校返而可以收非香港永久居民"

麟媽媽

你地睇清楚D先喇。
事主是在因工作關係留在香港的(holding working visa)，
而小朋友因為咁亦都留在香港。
咁佢個Status點同你地係香港公民，
佢係expatriate，點會同你地一樣呢？
如果我去美國做野，
同埋我個仔去，個仔又唔係美國公民，
我都唔可以送佢入public school一樣咋嘛。

小小bb

Smiley_face,
好似依基本法, 香港永久居民所生的子女同樣可以申請成為永久居民, 而現在的case是小朋友的父母都不是香永久居民。但凡事都有例外, 看看辦學團體及政府點睇。



[quote]
Smiley_face 寫道:
My son is not a 永久居民 in HK but I am  永久居民 who pay tax and he should able to attend 直資 or Govt. Primary school.

[quote]

sweetlvhk

如果我第一次出國旅行，乜都唔識旅行社都會有提點需要什麼證件、注意到期日等等…
去買護膚品d sales都會話比客知有乜要注意，佢唔會見到一個生到滿面暗瘡嘅客跟住叫佢買磨沙掛？！
父母係有責任去了解一切，但唔係每個人都懂得點樣心思細密去了解，但有身為一間學校點解可以咁疏忽？如果佢唔係學校，係一間醫院……唉

Smiley_face

小小bb,

"香港永久居民所生的子女同樣可以申請成為永久居民"
There are some conditions on top of it. You can 申請 but not necessary success. In my case, I am a HK citizen without any passport from other country but my husband is a foreigner but not a HK resident. My son was born in other country and by birth if he has other nationality, he is NOT allowed to be a 永久居民 in HK. But this is not we are discussing in this topic.
Back to THIS case here, as long as the kid is staying in HK legally, he is allowed to study in even Gov't School. This is what I have found out by calling 教育統籌局.

小小bb 寫道:
Smiley_face,
好似依基本法, 香港永久居民所生的子女同樣可以申請成為永久居民, 而現在的case是小朋友的父母都不是香永久居民。但凡事都有例外, 看看辦學團體及政府點睇。



[quote]
Smiley_face 寫道:
My son is not a 永久居民 in HK but I am  永久居民 who pay tax and he should able to attend 直資 or Govt. Primary school.

[quote]

AKLAMY

家熹媽咪,
多謝你的分享, 這類事情有可能發生我身上, 因為我小朋友會係下年回港諗書, 同佢伸請左直資小學 (DSS), interview 之前個校長同我地講若果小朋友沒有ROA (right of abode in HKSAR), 學費會貴d, 我地仲未知我既小朋友可唔可以有ROA...因為未伸請, 但已經被學校 interview 左!

我想請問你朋友和她的丈夫兩個都不是HK citizens嗎? 若果父或母一方是HK citizen, 小朋有係咪可以有ROA? 若小朋友有ROA 的話, 他們係可以讀 DSS 的!


Thanks and all the best to your friend and her family.

AKLAMY

Smiley-face,

May I know if your son is holding a dependent visa (depends on you) thus he can stay in HK and study at DSS / govt school ?

Since you mentioned that your husband isn't a resident in HK (i.e. he isn't living in HK, right?), so does it mean that you only needed to prove one parent (i.e. you) is the HKPR , then your son can stay in HK legally?

Hope you can give me some advice cos' I am still not 100% sure if my kids can enjoy ROA. Look forward to hearing from you .

Could you kindly let me know the contact of 教育統籌局 (email address will be great)?

You have a nice weekend.

Smiley_face

Hi, AKLAMY,

One of the parent of the kid need to prove that he/she can support the kid in HK by showing sufficient fund in the bank and a stable job in HK will be enough to grant the kid a dependent visa. The parent not necessary a HKPR.
For the first time you apply the visa, they will grant the kid 1 yr stay and for the 2nd time onward, they will usually grant the kid 3 yrs stay. Here are the information on 教育統籌局. If you need help, you can pm me and I will try my best.
Have a nice day too.  

[email protected]
電話 : (852) 2891 0088
傳真 : (852) 2893 0858
地址 : 香港灣仔皇后大道東213號胡忠大廈15樓

786

中華人民共和國國籍法(1980年9 月10日第八號公布)

第五條
父母雙方或一方為中國公民, 本人出生在外國, 具有中國國籍; 但父母雙方或一方為中國公民並定居在外國, 本人出生時即有外國國籍的, 不具有中國國籍.

第九條
定居外國的中國公民, 自願加入或取得外國國籍的, 即自動喪失中國國籍.




外國出生的BB, 申請ROA時, 人民入境事務處要看這兩條法律去定小朋友有沒有ROA(有永久香港ROA=有中國國籍). 沒有的話, 是如何做ROA去住滿七年, 就不得而知了.

AKLAMY

Hi Smiley_face,
Thanks for the useful information. It is very kind of you offering me help through PMs. I will send you PMs when I need further advice. Thanks so much. Good day!

786 寫道:
中華人民共和國國籍法(1980年9 月10日第八號公布)

第九條
定居外國的中國公民, 自願加入或取得外國國籍的, 即自動喪失中國國籍.

786,
多謝你既資料, 我想請問這第九條 (as above) 用於香港特別行政區嗎? 那是否移民外地已拿外國passports 的港人不能同時擁有兩個或以上既國藉(HK 和外地國藉)?
我記得好似係要填多一張form 若果拿外國passport 時想放棄中國國藉的話, 若沒有填那張form, 應該不會自動喪失中國國籍 (在我記憶中)....
Look forward to hearing from you.. Thanks again for your information.