談談沙田小一06/07選校...請bk parents分享與教路

lamloloo

alvinchanmama

唔喺wor....我有個一呂家長朋友見過陳元喜(上午)的功課是深過一呂的(以二年級作比較),同埋陳元喜是一星期有中英文默書,而一呂是一星期默中文,另一星期默英文wor...
她說:其實一呂都唔喺傳說中咁深...不過唔知喺唔喺低年級才是這樣的!
有人知道為何一呂的成績咁勁呢?

lamloloo

請問有沒有以下小學家長,可否來分享吓:

排名不分先後:

- 培基
- 一呂
- 沙呂
- 陳元喜(上午)
- 馬鞍山循道衛埋

我好想知道學校的實況.....thanks!

Mcvey

Hi    Lamloloo  and  heiB

Yes,  LKM = 梁鉅謬  -  anyone else think it is a good school?

Mcvey

Hi  heiB

Baptist principle said media of teaching shall gradually become English / Putonghua
but P1 stays English / Cantonese for comfort of students (only Chinese Literature in Putonghua)

may be because  Baptist Kinder mainly in Cantonese
My boy shall start K1 there this Sept.
What do you think?

heiB 寫道:
Mcvey
Can you tell me the chinese name of LKM?  I'm also thinking of Baptist University Affiliated and Pui Kiu College.  But I like Pui Kiu more as the media of teacher is putonghua.

honeybbb

lamloloo
係呀, 一呂P1 D功課真係唔深, 有D深D既幼稚園K.2/3既功課唔差好遠, 佢地係咪真係咁勁呢?定還是仔女入到去讀既家長都係對子女有所期望, 所以著重佢地既功課, 一路support仔女, 所以讀上去時佢地明顯係明白所學既野, 成績自然好

MYMAMA

請問有沒有家長,可否來分享吓

聖心小學

Any ideas for this primary school?

我好想知道學校的實況.....thanks!

heiB

我曾在上年培僑的簡報會中見過一位羅校長,沙田培僑是不是那人呢?印象中那人很親切.比浸小的校長更親切.

heiB

Mcvey
浸小的簡報我都有出席.校長話家長要有心理準備小一會好少功課做,英文就會先學拼音.校長講常識科同數學科會用中文授課的.我聽唔倒校長話會用普通話授課.可能我要查清潔啦!

lamloloo

Mcvey

i had also attented the introductory talk of Baptist primary.... but i still haven't heard that they are teaching in putonga!

alvinchanmama

唔好意思，咁遲先回覆．
因為我以前在一間有關興趣班地方工作，成日到聽到或見到陳元喜的家長或學生．所以我先這樣說，另外有部份學生好曳，我會用死性不改來形容個啲曳學生．
（私人意見）其實呢初升一年班，功課最好不要太深．因為第一年，小朋友“人新路不熟”升小一，功課深的話，小朋友好難適應．

ZZPAPA

Yes, Mr Law is more professional and gave me a confidence that he can manage Pui Kiu College smoothly.

I have visited other primary schools and join their talks before, some only presented a "Sales" talk, but not really care about the children.

  

lamloloo

ZZPAPA

are u the parents of Shatin Pui Kiu?

do u have some expereince in research of DDS school last year?

Please share with your analysis.... thanks

mariachn

Hi Lamloloo,

Sorry, so late to reply,just back from holiday.

My school net is 88, you have interest in 陳元喜, so I want to know your school net.

妳要鎖緊第一志願,從一而終,不要三心兩意呀!

lamloloo 寫道:
mariachn

my school net is 91...how about u?

lamloloo

mariachn

hello..... your school net is 88, do u like 陳元喜...

my school net is 91.. if i choose 陳元喜, i need to 跨區!

so i hesitate because i cannot 從一而終於!

what's your choices? can u share?

mariachn

hello lamloloo,

我大仔在05/06,統一派位派到沙田官小. 但我沒有選擇陳元喜作第一志願!我家附近有小朋友讀繄!唔覺得特別outstanding!

妳在91綱,應有更好的選擇, 如呂明才,培基等...如妳鎖定的第一志願在綱內!妳抽中的機會便會大一些!
像我一樣,第一次自行選擇我選沙官失敗!第二次統一派位,我再接再厲,在填表的時候跨區和同綱我都是選擇沙官作第一選擇!結果ok左!因為更加機會!

試下多些了解妳區內的好學校,先再考慮跨區!

It is my experience, hopefully it can share with you. Good luck !      

lamloloo

mariachn

Really thanks for your sharing and advices.....

but i fear that if the lucky draw fails, no one know what school will be allocated in 2nd, 3rd.... or etc? so i think about the less competitive school in 1 st choice....

Yes... Pui Kei is also my target! (Note: 1st round 自行 stage.... in 05/06.... the enter ratio is approx. 1:3, it still takes risk!!)... what do u think?

What is your feeling of 沙官? Do there too many homeworks, dictation in a week? How do about their extracurriculum activities? Do the students study in happy environment?

mariachn

Hi lamloloo,

好學校一定多人爭,自行stage多數都唔得!因為大部份quote 都比左兄弟姊妹,只有好少人派到位! 以沙官為例 都是大圍區必爭自行stage : 只有20人派到! 統一時得70個位 (比例都是 1: 4).


那麼妳在統一時乙部第一志願可以填最喜歡的,第二志願就填無甘熱門的學校. 例如培基放在第一志願,那麼就不要把呂明小放在第二位,妳要選一些無甘熱門的學校作第二志願 (但尚算喜歡的).還有甲部只填一間心儀的學校,2nd  & 3rd blank for it, 派不到便跳到乙部. 不會浪費quote! 希望妳明白我的意思!

沙官好正我同仔仔都好喜歡,我有朋友的仔仔讀緊, 她說homework不是太多.都好輕鬆,好開心!課外活動就要自行接送!不過05/06年轉full day,唔知安排課外活動會唔會有變,因為下午校就有校車接送! 但有信心轉full day會更好!

Maria  

ZZPAPA

My son will study in P2 this year.  As I have attended the seminars conducted by other DSS primary schools before, the one presented by Pui Kiu Colleage is more impressive and the teachers are well qualified with good academic background.  The presentation materials are well organized and the new school can provide a good studying environment to students.

Besides, my son can be trained with fluent Putongua which I believe that both language (Putongua and English) are the most important elements for him to communicate others and acquire other knowledges.

lamloloo

ZZPAPA

thanks for your feedback and analysis....

now i would also to attend different P1 talks for comparison.... same to u :)

hope to attend the coming P1 talk for understanding the Pui Kiu's mission.....that would help me to make a decision !

Ummmm..... which school for your son studying in P1 last year? do this quite difficult and cummy to change school?

Welcome to hear your sound for son's school life!

Many thanks!!!