跟本就唔係BAND1組別學生派晒學位先，然後先到BAND2組別學生派位！

CHUCHU

Nata,

嘩吓,你地king 咗成晚呀,有冇黑眼圏呀.
話時話呀,我好細膽架炸.    搏!驚驚!

Nata 寫道:
CHUCHU
無計啦~~  老實講..而家d家長都好進取...好驚自己既小朋友入唔到好學校,唔理小朋友咩成績都揀band 1
心口得一個字  " 搏~! "
我囡囡都派左第一志願......不過唔係band 1啵~
佢成績係band 1尾,無謂搏啦.而且佢又唔想去咁遠返學..
我又唔想佢咁辛苦... 同佢揀左間band 2頭既中中丫 ^^

brother

Nata 寫道:
yesmee
咁你小朋友呢..派得滿唔滿意

我地兩個響度吹水..樓主brother會唔會唔高興呢~ XDDD

當然唔會唔高興，大家都係討論下o者；以防有分BAND錯誤，我覺得小學應該自己咁分：

1) BAND 1
2) BAND 1/2
3) BAND 2
4) BAND 2/3
5) BAND 3

如果咁樣分就清晰好多，以過往咁多年派位計，定個保守Do既分析好D。

BillyM

brother 寫道:
[quote]
Nata 寫道:
yesmee
咁你小朋友呢..派得滿唔滿意

我地兩個響度吹水..樓主brother會唔會唔高興呢~ XDDD

當然唔會唔高興，大家都係討論下o者；以防有分BAND錯誤，我覺得小學應該自己咁分：

1) BAND 1
2) BAND 1/2
3) BAND 2
4) BAND 2/3
5) BAND 3

如果咁樣分就清晰好多，以過往咁多年派位計，定個保守Do既分析好D。[/quote]

說來容易，大部份學校已經咁做，但係都係唔準確，因為每年BANDING的劃分都有出入，往年肯定BAND1的（不是BAND1/2），今年變了BAND2，這都是學校無辦法預計的。

Nata

CHUCHU
嘻~~ 吹水通常都係夜鬼~ 黑眼圈出晒都唔會收手 :
我都唔敢搏... ^^

brother,Billy M
我覺得排左都無用... 其實老師都講左你小朋友係咩成績
我自己就會咁諗,本身間小學唔係咩勁校,d野亦比較淺
考得好唔代表出到去同其他小朋友溝埋一齊之後都係band 1... 我會打番個折..計佢band 2頭咁揀校
係d家長揀校有問題..責任都幾大

Yesmee

Nata :

其實我小朋友今年升小六, 下年才參加派位, 可是我太緊張了, 所以現在要做定 research, 睇定資料, 希望你多多指教 !!    

Nata 寫道:
yesmee
咁你小朋友呢..派得滿唔滿意

我地兩個響度吹水..樓主brother會唔會唔高興呢~ XDDD

BillyM

brother,Billy M
我覺得排左都無用... 其實老師都講左你小朋友係咩成績
我自己就會咁諗,本身間小學唔係咩勁校,d野亦比較淺
考得好唔代表出到去同其他小朋友溝埋一齊之後都係band 1... 我會打番個折..計佢band 2頭咁揀校
係d家長揀校有問題..責任都幾大

如果學校話你的子女是BAND1，但你幫他/她揀BAND2，是否有點對自己的子女不住呢？

請問閣下有沒有經歷過這個殘酷的選校過程？

Nata

yesmee~
原來你係一個好媽媽~^^
我真係乜都唔識....對d學校只係從其他媽咪口中聽番黎..
都係派表前先去問人邊間好  
呀囡更加唔理..話有書讀就得

Nata

Billy M
我都唔知係咪對佢唔住架...
只係知如果搏唔到... 好易唔知攪左去邊..
葵涌英文唔係好多間...
一間程度太高..高到全校得一個人夠膽填
一間女校... 我唔想..
一間又係程度偏高...全級都係得頭五名夠資格去搏
一間最正常..所以個個話係BAND 1既大部份都去填呢間...
咁.....我囡囡係尾... 真係幾危架..

當然我有問過小朋友意見啦..佢話唔介意中中定英中..
唔太差就得...其實讀書都唔係一切..做個好人先係我對佢既要求...可能其他媽咪 會覺得我好無大志..
不過個小朋友讀得開心我覺得都好重要

BillyM

Nata 寫道:
Billy M
我都唔知係咪對佢唔住架...
只係知如果搏唔到... 好易唔知攪左去邊..
葵涌英文唔係好多間...
一間程度太高..高到全校得一個人夠膽填
一間女校... 我唔想..
一間又係程度偏高...全級都係得頭五名夠資格去搏
一間最正常..所以個個話係BAND 1既大部份都去填呢間...
咁.....我囡囡係尾... 真係幾危架..

當然我有問過小朋友意見啦..佢話唔介意中中定英中..
唔太差就得...其實讀書都唔係一切..做個好人先係我對佢既要求...可能其他媽咪 會覺得我好無大志..
不過個小朋友讀得開心我覺得都好重要

完全明白，我尊重你對教育子女的睇法，同意讀書都唔係一切。

但我見到的媽咪都幾慘，跟據學校往績，自己子女的排名肯定係BAND1，但結果是如BAND2般派，結果轆到BAND3學校。其實媽咪都無乜搏到，如果知道是BAND1/2，佢一定打穩陣波，定多穩守突擊，揀一間好野，之後穩陣。

Yesmee

Nata:

真係要向你多多學習. 完全同意你的講法.      

尤其呢句最岩聽:

[size=medium]其實讀書都唔係一切..做個好人先係我對佢既要求, 不過個小朋友讀得開心我覺得都好重要   

Nata

Billy M
多謝你明白...
我地學校都有小朋友成績唔差但碌左去band 3呀..
真係除左講句唔好彩之外都唔知講乜好..
希望佢地可以轉番間好些少啦...

yesmee
淨係學呢樣好喇..眼見新一代無禮貌,崇尚物質,真係幾唔開心
其他方面就唔好學,我係傻既媽咪~  

virgokaren

BillyM 寫道:
[但我見到的媽咪都幾慘，跟據學校往績，自己子女的排名肯定係BAND1，但結果是如BAND2般派，結果轆到BAND3學校。其實媽咪都無乜搏到，如果知道是BAND1/2，佢一定打穩陣波，定多穩守突擊，揀一間好野，之後穩陣。

BillyM:

如果咁樣，咪每年上落數字都好大？
我以為都係得幾個的差別！
其實係點調節法？

我覺得最慘係 band 3 學生，咩都無得揀！
但又鬼叫佢當初唔俾心機讀書咩！

Nata：

而家真係好多學校都叫 band 1 學生只揀一間英中，
但如果我係 band 1，
網內多英中的話，如沙田，我會起碼博三間。

但好似我地北區只得三間英中的話，我就真係只敢博一間啦！因為第二志願根本 full 哂，無運行！

Nata

virgokaren
我讚成丫~~ 多英中..可以填多兩間

mable1124

Yesmee 寫道:
Nata:

真係要向你多多學習. 完全同意你的講法.      

尤其呢句最岩聽:

[size=medium]其實讀書都唔係一切..做個好人先係我對佢既要求, 不過個小朋友讀得開心我覺得都好重要   

呢句說話真是很多父母的心聲。       

Tara

我有個好無知既問題想問 ? 甘係咪即是如果個小朋友係d 唔出名既學校考到 band one 既分數甘佢都可以同d 名校bank one 生一樣選果d 名校 ??

uncleedward

Certainly, if you're sure you kid is in the first 1/3 of the students in your school net. It is a lottery only.

fatbabymother

I agree with virgokaren.  My daughter is band 1 but her school teacher asked her to fill in 中中 as 3rd choice.  She is under Kln City net in which so many 英中.  I argued with her teacher for a few times and finally I filled in about 20 英中. Now she got 1st choice 英中.  If I followed her teacher's advice and she 派 3rd choice 中中, I will be very very sad and angry.

uncleedward

fatbabymother 寫道:
I agree with virgokaren.  My daughter is band 1 but her school teacher asked her to fill in 中中 as 3rd choice.  She is under Kln City net in which so many 英中.  I argued with her teacher for a few times and finally I filled in about 20 英中. Now she got 1st choice 英中.  If I followed her teacher's advice and she 派 3rd choice 中中, I will be very very sad and angry.

Dear Fatbabymother

Sorry to say that your daughter's teacher was probably right.  If your daughter had failed to get her 1st choice, it means she got a lousy random number, it would have been doubtful whether she could get or 2nd or 3rd choice. Anyway, as your daughter got her first choice, that means it does not matter what the 2nd or 3rd choices were. Your daughter was lucky, that is important for this game.

fatbabymother

Thank you for your reply.  But if band 2 can get in e.g. True Light 中中, I put it as 30th choice in my list, I still can get in. Do you agree with me?

judy

Sorry to say that your daughter's teacher was probably right. If your daughter had failed to get her 1st choice, it means she got a lousy random number, it would have been doubtful whether she could get or 2nd or 3rd choice. Anyway, as your daughter got her first choice, that means it does not matter what the 2nd or 3rd choices were. Your daughter was lucky, that is important for this game.

那教師基本上是個無惱之人，要知道九龍城區有1/3之學額是英中，以1/3 band1學生計，基本上是人人有份，永不落空。