31網男仔應該點揀

hot1234

panchu,

I think mission opinion is correct, choose the one you like the most as the first choice which base on luck.  If you choose the school with better chance such as 循道 but you don't really like (presume you like YMT), then you may find regret afterwards even if you get the 1st choice.  It is of course better to have direct secondary school but I don't think it is the main point unless it is the one you really like.

The key point of the game is that you have to choose carefully especially the 2nd choice, and I think 循道 or Tak Sun is a good choice if you really like YMT.  These 2 schools are in fact good enough.   

mission

JJ1122 寫道:
mission,
哈哈, 你當時咁明目張膽咁睇呀? 我只係敢用眼尾咋.. 我驚其他家長唔鐘意.   

其實一開始我都心儀舊油天..但係當做左成年research 之後..我開始覺得有中學backup係一個比較穩健既選擇.  當然間中學唔能夠太差啦.  因為小學已經令我咁緊張, 中學一定更加不得了.  小學我仲有信心control 到個女, 中學我一d 都無.   所以好既中學對我好重要. 相信有一部份家長既心態都會係咁, 所以如果係男仔揀循道第一並唔出奇.  論band 1學生, 大家都差不過5x%.  派英文中學循道比油天高20%.  當然係由於大部份都入番循中.  我希望令小朋友對自己學校有歸屬感, 所以我想中小學都係同一間.  油天d方面就一定做唔到.
如果唔介意女校St Mary真係太必然既選擇, 有咩好得過一抽到9年唔洗煩?  不過太可惜始終無運.  

Just a little curious at that time, haha...... Agree with your comment above that primary schools that have affiliated secondary schools as backup are better, unless you are pretty sure that your kid can achieve above average academic performance in the final years at primary schools that don't have affiliated secondary schools (in my opinion).

By the way, according to past records, generally speaking 舊油天 has an edge over 新油天 in secondary school allocations, and  油天 boys have better secondary school allocations than 油天 girls.
:wink:

pan-fd

hi 大家好,我是panchu的friend,多謝大家為我解答兒子的問題,現在明白了如第1志願選了新油天,第2志願再選油天就會浪費一個機會,所以第2志願應該選其他才對,又如第1選了德信,第2及第3就不應該選油天了。但我有點不明白,如以上述所說,我選了新油天做第1志願時,第2及第3是否應填些冷門些才易中呢?(當不好彩抽不到第1志願時)還有,在第2輪的第1部份,我是否應填了新油天做第1志願,而第2及第3留空不填才為上策呢?另外,如將新油天選為第1志願,但舊油天不選或放得後些,這樣會否影響學校對我的睇法,當第1,2輪都不好彩派不好時,學校會覺得我沒誠意,不以它們2間做第1,2志願呢?請各位再指教

pan-fd

yinyin

如果你不填, 便會求其派一間比你

pan-fd

yinyin,

但這樣的機會率會否提高呢?還是跟本是一樣呀!?

pan-fd

JJ1122

pan-fd,
你先要明白張form 係有兩part, 一part 簡稱甲部, 係可以任填3間全港小學落去.  第二part 簡稱乙部, 就只可填你所申報住址既小學網內既小學.
通常你聽人講第2, 3 位唔填都係講緊甲部.  乙部基本上你應該儘量填哂所有學校既.
就以今年油天既安排, 似乎舊油天係歡迎任何有填佢, 無填佢既都可以攞form.  都會安排面試.  當然背後佢有冇歧視無揀佢既學生, 就無人會知.   
第2, 3位應該揀一d 你認為入到都開心既學校.  並唔係一定好冷門.  

pan-fd

JJ1122,

謝謝妳的解說,我原以為甲部填一間機會會大些,但好像填滿心水的3間機會才大些。

第2, 3位應該揀一d 你認為入到都開心既學校. -- 但入到都開心既學校會在第1輪給其他人選滿了,我想會較難些,所以我才說"填些冷門些才易中"

pan-fd

pan-fd

可否再次請教妳們,妳們會覺得新油天或德信哪一間會多人選它及選它收生機會率會高些,其實2間我都心儀,只是還是太擔心今年人數多,令到我的機會率降低。

pan-fd

JJ1122

pan-fd,
每間學校只可以拎5% 學位出黎for 甲部個part.  其他個d 都係比番乙部.  所以唔存在 "但入到都開心既學校會在第1輪給其他人選滿了".   eg. 學校有80個位for統一, 咁只有4個係比甲部既人攪.  其他76個係向番乙部架.
基本上甲部你填第一間係好hit 既話, 你唔填2, 3都無問題, 因為都實入唔到咁滯.   因為你住31網, 你focus 向番乙部啦.  甲部你將新油天填第一啦 或者大貪d 填 d 勁hit 既 如 拿巴個囉.  

我估新油天多d.  因為生一仔一女既好似比生兩個都係仔 or 女多.(起碼我有8成朋友係一仔一女).  為著個細既著想, 好多時都會選擇男女校.  亦有部份家長係唔喜歡齋校既.  又有家長喜歡學校有男有女覺得平衡d.  再加上宗教背景, 油天既天主教又比起德信既東亞xx教 多人認識.  

toby豆

JJ1122

德信都係天主教架.......
東亞教育促進會只係辦學團體

pan-fd

JJ1122,

這樣我又明白多些,好像怎說都應該是講彩數,好運的話就不用擔心了。

還有不太明白妳所說的"或者大貪d 填 d 勁hit 既 如 拿巴個囉"

pan-fd

mission

pan-fd 寫道:
JJ1122,

還有不太明白妳所說的"或者大貪d 填 d 勁hit 既 如 拿巴個囉"

pan-fd

May be she's talking about 喇沙小學 in 41net   

Below is this year's press release in June by 教育統籌局:

在不受校網限制的學校(甲類學額)選擇中，有78.1%的家長選擇其所屬校網的學校為首志願，顯示家長多希望子女就近入學。在參加統一派位的兒童當中，獲派甲類學額的佔2,635人*，而乙類則佔20,545人。

*Out of this 2,635 kids only about 430 kids are allocated to their chosen primary schools of nets other than their own school net .

The chance of getting 跨網派位 is extremely low (though not impossible).

pan-fd

mission,

thank you very much

pan-fd