簡A level 或 IB 學校？二者有何分別？

Cherishvalue

nintendo 發表於 17-6-1 12:40
香港人如果選中文一定係 Chinese A (first language)，所以一早應該 Group 2 讀 Spanish French 或甚至 Ja ...

據我所知不論香港或英國的IB 學校，也有中國學生讀B 中文 （有D仲讀SL！）

HSMOM

按IB官網每半年發佈全球成績的統計， maximum possible 分數只有45。有能力的學生可能選超過三科HL修讀，而在 Maths Subject, 有Further Maths Higher Level 選項，但全取也只是7。  對於坊間所謂52分之說，不能盡信。如果我沒記錯，應該要兩科語文選項中都修讀HL,才能獲所謂bilingual diplomat qualification.

poonseelai

HSMOM 發表於 17-6-4 23:08
按IB官網每半年發佈全球成績的統計， maximum possible 分數只有45。有能力的學生可能選超過三科HL修讀，而 ...

不是兩個語文HL, 是兩個語文都讀first language, 另一方法取bilingual diploma 是subject 3 or 4 用second language 考， 例如中文first language, 英文secobd language, subject 3 or 4 用英文考

nintendo

Cherishvalue 發表於 17-6-4 21:58
據我所知不論香港或英國的IB 學校，也有中國學生讀B 中文 （有D仲讀SL！）
...

This has been discussed many times in EK.

(1) It is the responsibilities of the IB schools to assign the appropriate language level class to students. Local Hong Kong students cannot take Chinese B. IS students that have always taken Chinese at B level can take Chinese B at DP. I heard that a few years ago, an ESF parent wrote to IBO complaining that local IB schools allow students to take Chinese B. And IBO has taken serious action. I do not think local students can still take Chinese B.

(2) Even if you succeed in cheating your way to Chinese B, do not be too happy. Universities will look at the background of the students. So good luck.

poonseelai

nintendo 發表於 17-6-5 00:49
This has been discussed many times in EK.

(1) It is the responsibilities of the IB schools to ass ...

IBO 是有關注香港學生考Chinese B 情況，亦聽聞香港的大學有就此討論過，但知今年中大港大law和中大med有出conditional offers 給考chinese B HL香港學生，会否日後收窄？未知

Cherishvalue

nintendo 發表於 17-6-5 00:49
This has been discussed many times in EK.

(1) It is the responsibilities of the IB schools to ass ...

同意 - 有經驗的大學一眼就能看破

大食媽咪

nintendo 發表於 17-6-1 12:40
香港人如果選中文一定係 Chinese A (first language)，所以一早應該 Group 2 讀 Spanish French 或甚至 Ja ...

啱啱睇返。。。我有啲唔係好明。。。。
咁睇,即group 1一定係考first language ,group 2就一定係考 language B 或 ab initio。
咁香港人(留學海外又好,國際學校又好),報IB 的話,group 1都一定係英文架啦,係咪?咁考中文就係group 2,即係language B (SL/HL) ,係咪咁架? 咁香港人一定考中文as first language 又即係乜野意思?
想了解多啲,請指教。

17-6-5 10:12 上傳

下載附件 (159.98 KB)

17-6-5 10:12 上傳

下載附件 (116 KB)

poonseelai

大食媽咪 發表於 17-6-5 10:12
啱啱睇返。。。我有啲唔係好明。。。。
咁睇,即group 1一定係考first language ,group 2就一定係考 langua ...

One can take both Eng A and Chi A - bilingual diploma

manning2014

Activehealth 發表於 17-6-4 19:26
舊年ESF South Island School 南島中學學生陳諾德IB 考7科包括Further Mathematics 全取7分，加3分TOK pres ...

The 2016 IB result of South Island School is here.
http://www.sis.edu.hk/2016-ib-diploma-exam-results/

Sorry, there is no record of 52 point (or officially). The max score is still 45.

"At the highest levels of attainment two students scored themaximum 45 points (out of only 146, world-wide). Six students scored 44 points and a furtherthree scored 43 points."
                                                                                                                                               

                               
                       
               

manning2014

大食媽咪 發表於 17-6-5 10:12
啱啱睇返。。。我有啲唔係好明。。。。
咁睇,即group 1一定係考first language ,group 2就一定係考 langua ...

In principle, students take both language A in group 1 and 2, will be granted bilingual diploma. But due to limited resource, individual IB schools could not provide a full range of courses for student to choose. Eg, some schools in UK do not provide Chinese Language "A".

大食媽咪

poonseelai 發表於 17-6-5 10:34
One can take both Eng A and Chi A - bilingual diploma

咁即係話,group 2都可以係揀language A, 而香港人考就一定無得揀,因為中文都一定係first language, 咁就一定要要係 bilingual diploma 咁考?

大食媽咪

manning2014 發表於 17-6-5 10:44
In principle, students take both language A in group 1 and 2, will be granted bilingual diploma. But ...

咁我明明0地啦。因為之前見到又話香港人就一定中文係language A, 所以有啲confuse.
謝謝回覆^^

nintendo

poonseelai 發表於 17-6-5 07:03
IBO 是有關注香港學生考Chinese B 情況，亦聽聞香港的大學有就此討論過，但知今年中大港大law和中大med有 ...

If those were IS students of course they can take Chinese B.

nintendo

poonseelai 發表於 17-6-5 07:03
IBO 是有關注香港學生考Chinese B 情況，亦聽聞香港的大學有就此討論過，但知今年中大港大law和中大med有 ...

In the past, HKU and CUHK law and med had taken Chinese B students. No problems. The most important thing is the BACKGROUND of students.

大食媽咪

nintendo 發表於 17-6-5 13:32
If those were IS students of course they can take Chinese B.

本帖最後由 大食媽咪 於 17-6-5 16:27 編輯

我女讀國際學校,因為轉校原故,正要作出決擇選讀中文(已讀6年),或法文(已讀1年)。舊校兩科都係必修,而家要二選一。。。
所以好想知道國際學校背景,半個香港人既佢,如選中文,會唔會一定要考IGCSE Chinese as first language &IB Chinese Language A. 我知佢一定唔夠班考as first language.
正如你之前提過,如果一定要迫住考first language 試,咁就不如drop Chinese, 讀 French as foreign language 算(雖然其實我好想佢讀中文)^^"

Activehealth

manning2014 發表於 17-6-5 10:35
The 2016 IB result of South Island School is here.
http://www.sis.edu.hk/2016-ib-diploma-exam-resul ...

South Island School weekly eBulletin issue no.1
19 August 2016

http://www.sis.edu.hk/issue-no-1-19-august-2016/

Message from the principal

"Our IB results have been published elsewhere but re-marks since the results came out have taken us just a fraction below our best ever scores and two more students were able to secure   45 points -making a record breaking total of   FOUR     at SIS in 2016"

17-6-5 20:54 上傳

下載附件 (1.75 MB)

Activehealth

HSMOM 發表於 17-6-4 23:08
按IB官網每半年發佈全球成績的統計， maximum possible 分數只有45。有能力的學生可能選超過三科HL修讀，而 ...

個男仔IB真係考咗七科每科七分滿分+3分EOK/extended essay.

只係IB 從來無人試過咁嘅爆燈成績，好似以前會考最多考九科，突然有人考十科攞全A，之後正有所謂十優狀元。

識個男仔，佢仲係其中一個prefect。

manning2014

Activehealth 發表於 17-6-5 20:54
South Island School weekly eBulletin issue no.1
19 August 2016

Sorry, you got thing wrong again. I didn't argue on how many students at SIS achieving max 45 points. My statement was IB students can only get the max score of 45 points no matter individual students took more than 6 subjects out of his interest, in contrast to what you said he has got 52 points.

"舊年ESF South Island School 南島中學學生陳諾德IB 考7科包括Further Mathematics 全取7分，加3分TOK presentation & extended essay, IB 總分52。"

So again, no IB students will get more than 45 points.

Artie

武航 發表於 17-6-1 17:33

外國可能資源較豐富吧, 可選的科目較多, 比如女兒的朋友在英有修電影, 我相信香港未必有吧

My son's school provide Film (and Theatre as well). I noted that at may be 4-5 students would be going to film or theatre programs overseas this year. Very happy for them.

Artie

洋子 發表於 17-6-1 12:27
我只知道我gei姪在英國讀IB, 佢間學校是一定要求Chinese留學生揀中文作為first language, 對於中文吾太好ge ...

IB 並不會分柝文學為獨立科，而是將文學加在 first language 科內。
Language A 分 literature 和 language & literature 兩個 stream。
Literature stream 故然是文學為主，但即使 Lang & Lit 也有約一半是文學。
這是很多人沒注意到的。