有冇小朋友係黃懿倫處學鋼琴

kaka0814

至於 CDEFG (音名),

我覺得對鋼琴學習者, 用 Do Re Mi (唱名) 會比較好, 尤其高級一點開始要掌握不同的 scales 和 調性時, 這些都很重要。不過, 我曾經參加過台灣的教師研習, 發現他們那邊也是用fix-do 的原理, 而且一樣有很多音樂人, 到底誰是誰非, 我很難說了。

sumsummummy

Hi, Kaka0814,
I want to know more about the acture admission requirement for the pre-junior class & the junior class. Is it more easy to apply for a pre-junior class ? During the interview, what will they do test except for playing 2 pieces of songs? Is it need to well-prepare before apply for this course? Sorry for asking so many question as I plan to let my son try the pre-junior course next year.
Thank you for giving so many information here!
one more, are you teaching clarinet? Which level & where you teach? My son is learning clarinet in group at school, do you think that it is better to learn clarinet in single rather by group?
Thanks for your reply!   

kaka0814 寫道:
一隻快一隻慢
不同時期 - 睇樂器啦呢個
不同作曲家
不同風格

仲應該準備埋viva voice
因為個考官隨時可以問野, 雖然機會好細

anyway, 你個老師應該可以幫你選到曲
如果選唔到, 我諗你可能要考慮第二位老師
呢 d audition 係咩時候都會遇到
應該唔會有問題

kaka0814

As far as I know, they will have first interview on the audition first. You play the songs, and that's all!!

If they want to know more about your son, they will call you up for the second interview, but some of them may not have this and will be directed into the program.

For Clarinet stuff, please check your PM.

Kathy-lau

kaka0814

Why can professional be able to know you are really good or not in 5-10 seconds? What are the assessment criteria in these few seoconds or by these professional musican-Ms. Eleanor Wong, Mr. Ray Wong and Mr. Cumberland?


[quote]
kaka0814 寫道:
Grade in fact doesn't mean anything. They look for someone's quality rather than $$. 6 mins in fact is TOO MUCH for audition. Professional will be able to know whether you are really good or not in 5-10 seconds!!!

kaka0814

That's very easy for them. You could never cheat their eyes for you understand / not understand.

They will know you before you start playing the music. If you have had lesson with them, you will see how they prepare before you play. So I said, 5-10 seconds is almost enough to tell you are good and could put further to consider.

Other than Piano, such as Woodwinds / Strings. The first sound is almost enough to say you are in consideration or not. That's my personal experience when I did my audition.

Kathy-lau

kaka0814,

I think it may be true for string and woodwind instruments but not for piano. Anyway, thanks for your opinion.

哈里波特

I agreed with kaka0814, even piano, just play 1-2 pages, they know who will be qualified.

kaka0814

In fact, once you sit on the chair, and put your hands on the piano, they will know. These are very fundamental requirements of a real pianist.

Pay for some music concert, and think why you will be impressed when Mr. Yundi Li come out from the backstage, even he didn't start his music.

Sindy

跟名師學琴,係唔係每日都要練幾個鐘架?有無d人係練一個鐘都滿足到佢地呢?(係個個人都唔同的,但有無聽過練一個鐘既例子呢)

thanks

kaka0814

well, 練野唔係睇時間0家喎... 係睇下練得到唔到方法..

就好似食野咁
可以食兩個鐘都未飽
可以食飽左但係唔健康的
或者.. 食半個鐘就又健康又精神

真係好難講.... 人地識得練, 可能練半個鐘都夠...

lulubabies

kaka0814 ,

有個問題想向您請教: 請問一位教演奏級的綱琴老師須要有什麼履歷呢?    

kaka0814

Um... 唔好話請教啦, 我都唔識答。
我自己就跟大學的教授學, $600+ 一課。
如果鋼琴老師可能要更貴, 因為也看名氣。

其次是音樂系的畢業生, 到演奏級要學習分析的部份其實很多。尤其因現在很多演奏級學生都沒有學習八級樂理, 要自己解釋作曲家到底做甚麼, 實在太難。

也許要其他人幫幫忙了, 講到底也不是個鋼琴人。

lulubabies

kaka0814,

多謝您的解答.

鋼琴老師的學費會比教授貴? (從朋友提供的資料中, 令我一直以為教授級的老師是最貴的)

還想請問: 有演奏文憑是否代表有能力教演奏級呢? 再麻煩您   

kaka0814

可能誤導了, 我意思是指教鋼琴的教授會比其他樂器的貴。

至於有演奏文憑是否代表有能力教演奏級這個問題
就好似讀中五係咪可以教番中五咁
明唔明我想講乜?
有些人雖然是那個級數, 但不代表他有沒有能力
也不是說所有有這個級數, 就有這個能力

教學的能力, 其實和演奏能力有很遠的差別。
就像教書的老師, 並不代表學歷高就一定是好。
有時經驗可能更加重要。

lulubabies

kaka0814 ,

其實我的諗法都是跟您一樣.
但是, 我見到坊間可以教演奏級的鋼琴老師, 他們的資歷大多是只有演奏文憑, 所以我都好

kaka0814

實在是很難講, 坊間還有很多只有五級樂理的人就去教五級樂理。

如果你到演奏級程度, 不妨問一下老師有沒有轉介。

Kathy-lau

kaka0814,

Would you tell me what are the requiremnts of each of the following dean of APA looking for when my child attends Junior Music audition of APA next year?

Piano: Ms. Eleanor Wong (my child learnt for two years)
String such as Cello: Mr. Ray Wang (never learnt before)
Woodwind such as oboe: Mr. Cumberland (never leanrt before)

Am I too greedily if I enrol three instruments at the same time for my child that will eventually diminish the chance of being admitted?

As far as I know, Mr. Ray Wang held open public concert last year but I couldn't see Ms. Wong and Mr. Cumberland perform in public. Have Ms. Eleanor Wong and Mr. Cumberland performed music concert in Hong Kong during the past years?  

哈里波特

Mr. Cumberland is major in Percussion, he is a very good man, he's very sincere.

Aries媽咪

我朋友個囡囡亦是跟一位教授學琴, 但教授無收佢任何費用, 因佢囡囡好有天份, 不足六年班, 已考取演奏級, 仲要考得好好成績,  朋友說佢囡囡都不是每天練琴, 係有需要考試或比賽先會練多d時間, 平時都係一個鐘.

Sindy 寫道:
跟名師學琴,係唔係每日都要練幾個鐘架?有無d人係練一個鐘都滿足到佢地呢?(係個個人都唔同的,但有無聽過練一個鐘既例子呢)

thanks

kaka0814

對不起, 我暫時沒有學生/朋友是一次過報三個課程的。

而 Junior 真的會收完全未學過的學生嗎 ??
我真的不知

也許要其他媽媽給意見哦