分析各區以往派位數據

iantsang

Justmade 發表於 12-9-26 22:35
5** = 過往3年,每年 世襲 > 30%學額，只有20%計分位，競選最激烈
5* = 過往3年,1-2年  世襲 > 30%學額，約 ...

very good wor!  

you heard my explanation?

Justmade

iantsang 發表於 12-9-27 09:31
very good wor!   

you heard my explanation?

Your first post had already explain the rating meaning, I just add in some elaboration.

My son is K3 now and I need to know the rule of choosing school.

I read your posts for data analyse, which is very useful and I had recommended them to some other parents in our kindergarten.

Thanks for your great work!

silverbell

Thanks Ian and the other members for the information and the analysis. My heart starts to beat fast and I feel  sweat on this not-so-hot morning. The battle is about to start. Relax....

katherinelum

Thanks

LuLuKiuKiu

eaubobo

lynndang

感謝分享！

tonymeg

amazing data analysis

gudbb

Bigpig_2007

Hi~! 真的很好，很有用！

請問我想找小班教學band 1有愛心學校給囝囝。本身95但可用40， 41 ，20分抽邊區好d…?

horwing

Bigpig_2007 發表於 13-7-27 00:21
Hi~! 真的很好，很有用！

請問我想找小班教學band 1有愛心學校給囝囝。本身95但可用40， 41 ，20分抽邊區 ...

妳確定自己有20分? 通常20分代表妳你某校舊生或者同宗教的學校, 咁已經大大限制左妳的選擇.

大部分名校都唔係小班教學, 論愛心亦未必係佢地的長處, 先確定妳的取向, 再作決定.

最後提醒一句, 常住地址應該只有一個, 請不要借用他人地址, 小心因小失大.

iantsang

tonymeg 發表於 13-7-26 17:34
amazing data analysis

Thank you very much for all the support but please noted that this thread was posted ONE year ago!  

Bigpig_2007

回復 horwing 的帖子

本身基督教, 基督教學校就20分, 其他就只有15分吧~

Band 1 ok, 唔使一線名校, 最緊要校風, 師生好!

我係怕TKO中學校網唔得, 而且一定搬.... 所以會考慮搬轉網九龍區.

Bigpig_2007 發表於 13-7-27 00:21
Hi~! 真的很好，很有用！

請問我想找小班教學band 1有愛心學校給囝囝。本身95但可用40， 41 ，20分抽邊區 ...

妳確定自己有20分? 通常20分代表妳你某校舊生或者同宗教的學校, 咁已經大大限制左妳的選擇.

大部分名校都唔係小班教學, 論愛心亦未必係佢地的長處, 先確定妳的取向, 再作決定.

最後提醒一句, 常住地址應該只有一個, 請不要借用他人地址, 小心因小失大.

angie0828

Thx for sharing

iantsang

Bigpig_2007 發表於 13-7-27 13:09
回復 horwing 的帖子

本身基督教, 基督教學校就20分, 其他就只有15分吧~

Please note that being a Protestant doesn't apply to all Christian schools.  Each and every one of them can decide individually on what are the criteria (e.g. same church) to be rewarded the 5 points.  So, you might have made an assumption that you have 5 points for all of them but in reality this is not true.

On the contrary, all Catholics have 5 points for all Catholic schools.

sadsam

想問下那虐數據是從何得知?同準確度高嗎?

iantsang

sadsam 發表於 13-7-30 09:57
想問下那虐數據是從何得知?同準確度高嗎?

These are public data that are issued from EDB every year in the annual report.  However, these data are only available for one year as the link to reports from previous year will be removed by the more updated one.  So, they need to be collected over few years.

Of course there are further calculations and analysis being performed based on the raw data.

sadsam

iantsang 發表於 13-7-30 11:23
These are public data that are issued from EDB every year in the annual report.  However, these data ...

多謝你無私同我地分享呀!

Eileenknn

:loveliness:

mamath

iantsang 發表於 13-7-30 11:23
These are public data that are issued from EDB every year in the annual report.  However, these data ...

請問有沒大途徑得知個別學校自行階段收取的學生是多少分(e.g. 30, 25、20)?  Thanks.