SKH(AM) vs SPK(AM) vs St Cat vs KCIS

LittlePanda101

Mt Butler 60 graduates around 10+ will go to SPCC

alvinmamami

How about the % of SC students going to SPCC?

dwkw333

alvinmamami 發表於 12-3-20 17:18
How about the % of SC students going to SPCC?

~20 out of 800...

nlj1216

SPK for sure as mine is a girl...and won't take the risk of going thru the primary allocation (though SPK not guarantee taking all their kindergarten students to their own primary).

bigheadchiu

如果讀兩間，不如一早讀寶山。錢多讀兩間少少，但入spcc機會好大。因又有alumni，女兒又應幾smart......

seeker.email

Out of curiosity，我都想知道寶山學生入SPCC的track record是怎樣。
（可是寶山並不是報名就有得面試，可以負擔學費就可以讀。）

giselemama

For bremar hill nursery. About 50% will go to St Paul coed, the rest will go to CIS, German Swiss etc. However, you should account the factor that parents/kids that get accepted to bremar hill are usually  those that will get accepted by Co-Ed i.e i think these kids, with their family background, will get accepted into co-Ed even if they did not study in bremar hill - so rather, I think Bremar hill somehow "preselected" these students....
To help you decide, last year my daughter got an offer from bremar hill and SPN (my target primary school is also co-Ed) after alot of struggle I gave up bremar hill and took SPN. Reason is simple:  I could have the safety net of a very good primary school (ST Paul Convent) and still apply for co-Ed, and  they too take in quite a number of students from SPN and SPK, while for bremar hill, the chance for getting into co-Ed  is only 50-60% with no safety net. Since the chance of SKH getting into coed is lower than bremar, I would suggest to choose SPK for your girl.

appleton

回復 giselemama 的帖子

Thanks for the tips.
But I heard there is minimal number of SPK/SPN graduates in SPCCPS... and the fact that they belongs to different religion may influence Ms Leung's decision perhaps?

siden

原帖由 appleton 於 12-03-21 發表
回復 giselemama 的帖子

Thanks for the tips.

咁你計比例實係SKH多人去SPCCPS架啦，如果你真係咁鐘意SPCCPS more than SPC, 咁你快啲放番SPK個offer出黎俾其他人，去SKH la,一定有好多媽媽多謝你！

appleton

回復 bigheadchiu 的帖子

Applied but didn't get offer last year...
BH is not for ordinary people...

bigheadchiu

If you are very keen on SPCC, then skh is for sure the best bet from your current options.  Going to two schools will bring no good for the kid, 1. Not enough rest and play time, 2. Different religion, 3. Similar school syllabus and activities can bored the kid.... This is a matter of how much risk you wish to take, no right or wrong, everyone have different views, and no one can answer for you.

CoffeeCake

其實除左寶山,其他KINDERS既入SPCPS數字已不可作完全參考.
而家COMPETITION比2003-2005年出世果批大左好好好好多, 但好多人仍然用呢批人畢業KINDERS時的數據來參考(即係現在讀緊P1-P3果D),結果會好大分別的.

appleton

回復 hophopbunny 的帖子

Good analysis!

giselemama

hophopbunny 發表於 12-3-21 14:46
除非你有其他後著（如夠分入其他名津校。。假設爸爸是SPCC舊生媽媽是名津校舊生），否則SPK會保險些。

SPN ...

exactly what I wanted to say..........the children of majority of my colleagues and friends studied or is studying in SKH (central) - there is a group who got into Co-ed and a group who didnt - so to me although SKH is a very good KG it does not provide safety net, which I think is very important. Of course as hophopbunny said, unless you as parent is an alumni of a good school which provides you with a safety net, SPK is better.

   

giselemama

hophopbunny 發表於 12-3-21 14:46
除非你有其他後著（如夠分入其他名津校。。假設爸爸是SPCC舊生媽媽是名津校舊生），否則SPK會保險些。

SPN ...

hohoyy

回復 giselemama 的帖子



giselemama, 你小朋友也讀/將讀SPK嗎 ?

giselemama

hohoyy 發表於 12-3-21 18:00
回復 giselemama 的帖子

No my daughter is studying SPN just sharing because I had to make a similar decision as appleton previously - SPN vs bremar hill (even higher chance for co-ed entry than SKH) and my target primary school is also co-ed. Finally gave up bremar hill (the person on waitlist must be very surprised that anyone would give up a place in bremar hill) for SPN because I want to have a back up.