真的喜歡YW多過KTS？ 想深入探討下！

小曳人

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 10-12-17 15:17 發表
年年都有呢Dposts不停地比較不同學校，有時並非家長想問意見，只是為comment而comment, 我通常唔會回應。我無讀過KTS,唔可以扮認識，正如未讀過YW的家長就憑一個半個活動就comment整個curriculum，好似不夠全面。無意為YW護 ...

我其實覺得呢個post幾好呀~
大家討論吓啫.. 唔講又點知有乜特別, 然後去諗啱唔啱自己呢?
每個家長要考慮嘅嘢都唔同, 都有好多好多.. 緊唔緊要, 個個人把尺都唔同, 你buy~ 可能係我嘅死穴.. 無問題架!
relax!

小曳人

原帖由 thomasha 於 10-12-17 15:15 發表
我諗學校想栽培你個小朋友，你可以拒絕喎，你想小朋友低調o既話，相信係有辦法o既。

多謝你嘅意見~
e+記底哂各校嘅comments, 做好功課.. 希望到我地作戰時, 會有個合適嘅選擇啦!

TY3388

我只是比較喜歡KTS而非選定了，英華我都很喜歡，我只奇怪為何眾父母心中差別那麼大，所以求過明白。我相信弄清楚了再作選定是更正確的做法，不是麼?

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 10-12-17 15:17 發表
年年都有呢Dposts不停地比較不同學校，有時並非家長想問意見，只是為comment而comment, 我通常唔會回應。我無讀過KTS,唔可以扮認識，正如未讀過YW的家長就憑一個半個活動就comment整個curriculum，好似不夠全面。無意為YW護 ...

[ 本帖最後由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 18:37 編輯 ]

thomasha

Perfectly justified.

I think some parents are so enthusiastic about Ying Wa that they are very eager to "sell" Ying Wa to you.

In my humble opinion, experience of parents of existing or past students of Ying Wa should be the most relevant to you.  Parents whose children have never studied in Ying Wa can only offer impressions and opinions based on hearsay and superficial phenomena.  

That's why I have not offered my opinion, as my son is currently seeking a place in Ying Wa.  If you have time, try to go to the school around 3 pm when the students are off, and observe them by yourself.  Such 1st-hand info would be quite useful too.  (They may have started their Christmas holidays though.)

原帖由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 16:50 發表
我只是比較喜KTS而非選定了，英華我都很喜歡，我只奇怪為何眾父母心中差別那麼大，所以求過明白。我相信弄清楚了再作選定是更正確的做法，不是麼?

...

Yanamami

P4-P6, 功課當然不能在一小時內完成.  但初小就一定得.  我P1個女放3p.m. P6個女放4:10p.m. 通常細果個係家姐放學前(我等埋一次過接放學)一定做完功課, 仲周圍同人玩(有其他媽咪講我知).  每日4-5樣功課, OK o丫.
有三班校車提供, 分別有3p.m./ 4:10p.m./ 5:10p.m. depends on 有乜課外活動. 算相當靈活.

原帖由 JLL 於 10-12-17 14:36 發表


請問你女兒是何時就讀於KTS? 照我的了解, KTS功課不少, 一小時內不能完成. 每天都會有課外活動, 是否不能乘坐校車回家?

[ 本帖最後由 Yanamami 於 10-12-17 17:40 編輯 ]

doramami

Just a little query, I wonder if the Principal of YW will be retired within the coming 6 years?
Will it affect your consideration?

Zhaiba

原帖由 doramami 於 10-12-17 17:50 發表
Just a little query, I wonder if the Principal of YW will be retired within the coming 6 years?
Will it affect your consideration?

To me it will.  Principal of the school is just like the CEO of a company, it will certainly affect my consideration (not the decision in this thread though).

TY3388

Yanamami, 請問三班校車(3p.m./ 4:10p.m./ 5:10p.m.)是KTS提供的嗎？ 另外4:10p.m. & 5:10p.m.去的地區跟正常3p.m.有分別嗎？即是說3p.m.會到我住的地區，4:10p.m. & 5:10p.m.估計也會到我的地區，是嗎？否則活動後接放學會係一個大麻煩！

原帖由 Yanamami 於 10-12-17 17:36 發表
P4-P6, 功課當然不能在一小時內完成.  但初小就一定得.  我P1個女放3p.m. P6個女放4:10p.m. 通常細果個係家姐放學前(我等埋一次過接放學)一定做完功課, 仲周圍同人玩(有其他媽咪講我知).  每日4-5樣功課, OK o丫.
有 ...

TY3388

It's certainly a consideration point in this thread.  I would also consider staff relationship too.  You know, teachers seem "small potato" in the shool due to the fact that principal is too "great".  Does there exist any relationship issue among principal and teachers?

原帖由 Zhaiba 於 10-12-17 18:11 發表

To me it will.  Principal of the school is just like the CEO of a company, it will certainly affect my consideration (not the decision in this thread though).

thomasha

On the contrary, during the 2nd interview, Principal Lam gave a lot of credit to her team of teachers, saying that without these front-line teachers, the vision of the school could not have been carried out effectively.  It seems that Principal Lam does not treat the teachers as "small potatoes".

It would be nice to have some "insiders" to share 1st-hand info though.

原帖由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 19:05 發表
It's certainly a consideration point in this thread.  I would also consider staff relationship too.  You know, teachers seem "small potato" in the shool due to the fact that principal is too "great".  ...

childrenfirst

Of course, it is very reasonable. I got a bit reactive because it recalled my memories about some of the posts of last year. There were several nasty ones and later found out that it was not accurate at all. There was a post said Principal Lam would retire soon. Therefore, I tend to be more careful on commenting a school, not only YW but all. There maybe some parents here would be affected by the comments here.

Of course, everyone has the right for speech but parents must be careful and verify it before taking it seriously.

原帖由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 16:50 發表
我只是比較喜歡KTS而非選定了，英華我都很喜歡，我只奇怪為何眾父母心中差別那麼大，所以求過明白。我相信弄清楚了再作選定是更正確的做法，不是麼?

...

Zhaiba

原帖由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 19:05 發表
It's certainly a consideration point in this thread.  I would also consider staff relationship too.  You know, teachers seem "small potato" in the shool due to the fact that principal is too "great".  ...

What I am saying is this is a factor to consider, but without knowing the replacement, i cannot say this is good or bad.  But whoever will be the principal it will not affect "my" conclusion on this thread.

Yanamami

我是自己接送小朋友的, 只知有三班車.  相信details要入小學一覽問問有用校車service的家長.  但assume是每班車目的地是一樣.  事關校長鼓勵學生參加活動, 提供三班車正為此目的, 亦未曾聽過有家長提過任何不便.

原帖由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 18:56 發表
Yanamami, 請問三班校車(3p.m./ 4:10p.m./ 5:10p.m.)是KTS提供的嗎？ 另外4:10p.m. & 5:10p.m.去的地區跟正常3p.m.有分別嗎？即是說3p.m.會到我住的地區，4:10p.m. & 5:10p.m.估計也會到我的地區，是嗎？否則活動後接放學會係 ...

TY3388

不知道英華是否也有課外活動後的校車安排呢? 我相信這點是很多父母想知道的事, 雖然這未必構成重大選校的原因.

Sinman68

原帖由 Yanamami 於 10-12-17 20:07 發表
我是自己接送小朋友的, 只知有三班車.  相信details要入小學一覽問問有用校車service的家長.  但assume是每班車目的地是一樣.  事關校長鼓勵學生參加活動, 提供三班車正為此目的, 亦未曾聽過有家長提過任 ...

Dear Yanamam,
想請問是不是每一線都有三班車嗎?

小曳人

原帖由 TY3388 於 10-12-17 22:20 發表
不知道英華是否也有課外活動後的校車安排呢? 我相信這點是很多父母想知道的事, 雖然這未必構成重大選校的原因.

我唔能夠直接答到你..
不過舊年聽返嚟, 親戚家長話: 放學有活動就好麻煩, 要自己湊返屋企
我唔清楚detail, 不過我自己會當無校車安排
麻煩有小朋友讀緊嘅家長講講..

[ 本帖最後由 小曳人 於 10-12-19 14:20 編輯 ]

kelvincheng

既然兩間在學術上和教育學生方面都做得十分出色 , 而YW則外加一條龍BAND1英中   

除非有特別原因, 否則大路之選總會是YW吧.

ngwong2

KTS即係邊間呀?

TY3388

多謝elsa回應，好詳細，好清楚。想問下讀讀下離開KTS去其他學校的學生多嗎？是否只為升中早些鋪路的關係？

回答另一位父母，KTS即九龍塘學校﹝小學部﹞。

原帖由 elsa2005 於 10-12-20 02:38 發表
小女已從kTS畢業，我認為：

YW好好，小學部的男仔好smart，接觸過YW中學生，真係好有禮貌，YW的小學及中學在學業成績及才藝方面的表現都有目共睹；而且我個人認為十二年男校完全沒有問題，升中又唔使煩，所以選YW好正常。

KTS好好，勁 ...