del del del

k.kung

The entire argument is just based on a purely assumption.

原帖由 maynjune 於 10-11-26 11:19 發表
Hahah....

I think that you still don't understand the point that Lawsonmoon is talking about.  

The argument is about the submission of the address proof, which is no need to be part of acceptance  ...

share123

其實,幾分鐘既面試,系咪真係完全可以肯定邊個一定得,邊個一定唔得? 話完全系取決於面試表現,系咪100%? 住址,家庭背景,幼稚園同課外活動系咪真系完全唔計?? 我覺得系一項校長既綜合考慮,應該系無formula既,總之校長用專業判斷,覺得合適佢學校咪收囉

donutbaby

原帖由 share123 於 10-11-26 11:49 發表
其實,幾分鐘既面試,系咪真係完全可以肯定邊個一定得,邊個一定唔得? 話完全系取決於面試表現,系咪100%? 住址,家庭背景,幼稚園同課外活動系咪真系完全唔計?? 我覺得系一項校長既綜合考慮,應該系無formula既,總之校長用 ...

agree.  there is no rule to this DSS game.  the school is the banker and banker always wins.  if you can't accept the fact that there is unfairness in this game, then it's better not to get involved to begin with.

icbb1230

BTW, I would like to ask how difficult to get an address in good residental area?  Many people even borrow other's address in Kowloon Tong for 41 net central allocation.  Therefore, I wonder why the schools need the residental address proof?

Anyone can answer this?

k.kung

There are too many possible answers.

1. Adminisration purpose -  Some applicants may move to the new living places between the period of the 1st and 2nd interview.  The school may wants to ensure the information in the application form is correct and up-to-date before handing to the headmistress.

2. Interview purpose - Home address is one of the questions that frequently asked by the interviewer.  When applicant's answer is different from the information showing in the application form, the headmistress can quickly identify that the discrepancies are not typos because the address have been checked according to the proofs from the parents.

3. Selection purpose - As per the discussion in this topic, it may be one of the selection criteria.

4. To shortlist those applicants whose parents did not want to cooperate.

原帖由 icbb1230 於 10-11-26 12:37 發表
BTW, I would like to ask how difficult to get an address in good residental area?  Many people even borrow other's address in Kowloon Tong for 41 net central allocation.  Therefore, I wonder why the s ...

[ 本帖最後由 k.kung 於 10-11-26 15:03 編輯 ]

icbb1230

Hi k.kung,

thanks for your reply as DGJS is a school that I definitely will apply for my daughter, so I would like to know more:

1. Adminisration purpose -  I think it is the responsibility of the parent if they have the case.  School doesn't need to consider on this.

2. Interview purpose - yes, I think it's possible.

3. Selection purpose - I need to go through all reply in this topic first.  Is the main reason to scan the family financial background?

4. To shortlist those applicants - same reason as #3?

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 maynjune 於 10-11-26 11:19 AM 發表
Hahah....

I think that you still don't understand the point that Lawsonmoon is talking about.  

The argument is about the submission of the address proof, which is no need to be part of acceptance  ...

lawsonmoon

del del del原帖由 k.kung 於 10-11-26 11:12 AM 發表

閣下的邏輯論完全建基於"校長多次在媒體說取錄與否純看小孩面試表現"。請問你是從那些媒體多次看到上述資料呢?

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 k.kung 於 10-11-26 11:44 AM 發表
The entire argument is just based on a purely assumption.

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 ChuLuLu 於 10-11-26 10:17 AM 發表
Not being part of their administration, I am unable to say definitively why SPCC (or DGJS) should have concerns about the truthfulness of the residential addresses declared in the application forms. A ...

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 Zhaiba 於 10-11-25 11:51 PM 發表
It is really unnecessary to check the address during the interview process if the school really do not care.  The logic is simple.
After you are being admitted of course then you need to have your add ...

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 k.kung 於 10-11-26 09:50 AM 發表
Who are you going to believe?

Someone said DGJS cares about the residential address of appliant because the applicant had to present the proof of address before the 2nd interview.

Someone said DGJS  ...

[ 本帖最後由 lawsonmoon 於 10-11-26 19:45 編輯 ]

k.kung

翻查星島親子王, 戴校長只在第一期接受過一次訪問, 而非閣下所形容的多次, 文中亦無提及"取錄與否純看小孩面試表現"這番說話或相近意思的言論。 可能閣下對這遍訪問理解錯誤了。

原帖由 lawsonmoon 於 10-11-26 19:10 發表
星島親子王

RosalindOrlando

會唔會諗多咗，可能check吓有無寫錯地址及期間搬咗屋呢！

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 RosalindOrlando 於 10-11-27 08:12 AM 發表
會唔會諗多咗，可能check吓有無寫錯地址及期間搬咗屋呢！

natpa

There are always good and bad sides looking at matters.

Thinking positively, a proved read address can ensure once your girl got accepted, the acceptance letter will be delivered to your home address, rather than lost some where else (yes, we write the envelope address). This can be for the ease of the school and parents worries.

Let's wish we'll received the acceptance letter :)

vaga

恕我直言…
如果咁不滿間學校就唔好考慮囉, 何必咁怒氣呢？

lawsonmoon

del deldel del

原帖由 k.kung 於 10-11-27 02:19 AM 發表
翻查星島親子王, 戴校長只在第一期接受過一次訪問, 而非閣下所形容的多次, 文中亦無提及"取錄與否純看小孩面試http://adex.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?bannerid=609&cb=2124表現"這番說話或相近意思的言 ...

lawsonmoon

del del del

原帖由 vaga 於 10-11-27 10:58 AM 發表
恕我直言…
如果咁不滿間學校就唔好考慮囉, 何必咁怒氣呢？

lawsonmoon

又係 "新國民"?

原帖由 natpa 於 10-11-27 10:54 AM 發表
There are always good and bad sides looking at matters.

Thinking positively, a proved read address can ensure once your girl got accepted, the acceptance letter will be delivered to your home address ...