La Salle vs Ying Wa

mamimummy

High Profile?! 對. 林校長都只是借協恩個名, 如果她不是前協恩校長情形會跟現在一樣嗎 ? 協恩不是她一手帶起的, 更不會因為沒有她而失去精神, 動力 和 吸引力.

原帖由 Jean 於 08-11-24 23:07 發表
Ying Wa小學太新, 老師資歷不見突出. 而林校長, 前鋒又係佢, 後防又係佢. 比佢做得更好的校長亦有不少, 只是無咁high profile啫.

LS雖然係派位, 我認識既LS boy家庭背景都非常非常好.  就算資質普通既學生, 只要有 ...

[ 本帖最後由 mamimummy 於 08-11-25 00:24 編輯 ]

abmum

I am of the view that before making a choice, you'd better best estimate and understand the boy's ability and his personality.

To survive in such kind of Super Band 1 school (LS and DBS), the boy must be a very tough, outgoing, active or excellent academic background.   

Confidence is very important in the child development.  Take a shool that your boy will belong to the range "above average" of that school.    Don't place the child to a school that he only marginally meet the standard, he will loss the confidence which is not worth.

So, only you know your boy and you are required to be honest to put him to the place that best fit.

原帖由 Yonniewong 於 08-11-24 16:15 發表
still LS...

loy211

我都選喇沙,津校,慳番d錢俾佢學野.

smartcar

I think most parent here would opt for LS over all else.  And I did also.. I did the attempt in two occasions for LS lottery but fail, even my son was born Catholic with 20pts.

It is normal to fancy famous school.

However, I am more than happier to be in Ying Wa.  My son loves the school very much altought the school keeps him very busy from Mon to Sat.  

YW is the most traditional school in HK since 18XX.  The school just celebrated her 191st Anniversary.  All celebrities of old YW alumini attended the function.  However, YW is low profile in the past and lost lust comparing to earl noble school as DBS and LS.

YW is on the move and has chosen the right direction now.  YW has underlying strength to compete and publicity helps it to achieve.  

YW's boys are confident and cheerful kids.(why, becoz I see him everyday

jennytms

其實我們不應在這裡比較學校的好與不好, 最重要是你覺得那所學校適合你的小朋友. 之前曾在網上見到一些有關"林校長"的訪問, 她講得很有道理, "名校"是否實至名歸, 最重要就是要有好的老師, 有愛心的老師, 能夠因材施教, 能將每一個小朋友的才能都能充份發揮, 咁就真係能做到名副其實的好學校. 我囝囝很幸運地入到這所學校, 雖然他自行分配都入到一間心儀的官校,但我們都會讓囝囝入讀英華, 因我們想小朋友可以開心快樂地成長,相信英華這所學校就是可以做到這點. 我們亦好欣賞林校長對教育那顆熱誠的心.

以上純粹個人意見. 如有說得不好, 望多見諒.

小謙伯伯

From La Salle's school song:

"There are famous schools in plenty,
With their heroes by the score,
And they flourish high and mighty,
But La Salle is something more."

So, you know how to choose.  (laughter : )

LLPP

Bruce Lee Fans - LS of course!

smartcar

SAM Hui and Leung Kam Chung fans,

of coz Yin Wa

vivian3328

首先申報，小兒現在在英華讀小一。
講真，如果抽到LS，根本無可能會放棄LS而選英華。因為人始終有啲虛榮心，LS個名係响啲！
但就好睇個小朋友得唔得，因為壓力係好大既。5年前，我同事佢個仔(好好彩)抽到入LS，當然全家都好開心啦。但佢仔仔確係跟唔上，結果，不停補習，老師不停要見家長，全家壓力都超大，同事亦因此同仔仔關係惡化！最後，佢將仔仔送咗去英國。於是全家都開心哂！因為LS係抽既，小朋友都有啲差別，跟唔到就好辛苦。
你當我係賣花讚花香啦，只可以講小兒返學好開心，我所識既小一家長都表示兒子都好鐘意返學，咁佢又學到嘢， 又一條龍，仲想點喎！

mayc

Dear all:

昨天明報教得樂拔小,喇沙,英華三位女校長分享教子心得,不妨了解多些她們的教子理念!

http://hk.wrs.yahoo.com/_ylt=A3xsaNa6wCxJwaEA9Lqzygt.;_ylu=X3oDMTE4OHJlb2c0BHNlYwNzcgRwb3MDMQRjb2xvA2hrX2ludGwEdnRpZANoa2MwMDNfNzE-/SIG=12g74f1v2/EXP=1227756090/**http%3A//happypama.mingpao.com/cfm/Ebook1.cfm%3FCategory=happy

不過這是上一期的內容,也是有關英華的,不妨了解多些才決定!

[ 本帖最後由 mayc 於 08-11-26 11:27 編輯 ]

MTRC

作出選擇前,我會多考慮小朋友的特質和先放名校的負累,我記得約在五、六年前,某報頭條刊登了一則新聞關於舊小男拔生放棄一條龍直升男拔而决心離開選擇其他中學,我記得家長說除了第一天收到舊小男拔取錄後十分興奮後,家長和小朋友都未開心過,名校學習壓力和競爭實在很大,你和你的孩子是否適合,請三思。其實ㄚW是一個不錯選擇,一條龍直升中學,愉快開心學習,不需要煩呈分,爭入直屬中學

nigelman

想指出,近年英華(中學)收"即食"運動員,已到畸形情況,e.g. 20歲兵球學界 A grade代表仲讀緊F.4, 全隊 A grade籃球隊正選都係插班生,和男拔"交換"泳手.

Is this the school you want your sons to study?

hogwarts

LS should be a better choice for me if both schools accepted my boy.  

I guarated from a school used to have some connection with the LS brother.  The LS brothers, same as Wah Yan's fathers, do have a very unique experience and system to run school.  Yes, many will say LS being too tough, but learning is a tough process.

I have no experience with YW but both are good schools.  One may like to go to LS because of the school's tradition or simply it is "free of charge" and one may like to go to YW because of Mrs. Lam.  At the end, it is the boy's and his parents' own inputs will count more.

kyliema2006

有些學校是不可以接受成績下滑的事實，最快捷的方法就是外求，為求成績，不擇手段，英華如是，喇沙亦不惶多讓。所以我覺得SPCC在頂級名校當中是最有校品的一間。

原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-27 06:39 發表
想指出,近年英華(中學)收"即食"運動員,已到畸形情況,e.g. 20歲兵球學界 A grade代表仲讀緊F.4, 全隊 A grade籃球隊正選都係插班生,和男拔"交換"泳手.

Is this the school you want your sons to study? ...

[ 本帖最後由 kyliema2006 於 08-11-27 10:06 編輯 ]

cutiemo

Hi Yikyubb,

can you share are you score 20 and live in net 41?
as your son has been accepted by LS..

also, any one accepted by LS by score 20 not living in net 41?...

原帖由 yikyubb 於 08-11-24 15:45 發表
小兒獲兩校取錄,很難選擇, 如不用考慮學費問題,
從(師資 / 功課 /學校成績 /學生品德)作比較,請給意見.

nigelman

SPCC has tried to offer full scholarship to tempt the most famous young table tennis player of LSC before he started F.1. BTW, SPCC is too expensive in the current economic situation.

vivian3328

嘜呢個係問題咩？原來你而家先知有啲咁既情況！你唔係話LS無咁做嘛！我相信好多所謂名校都有咁既現象，只不過係多定少。其實有嘜奇怪，你個仔讀書讀得叻，你都有可能插班去你認為更好既學校啦，你唔轉校我好欣賞，但你個仔轉校，我亦覺得無問題。好既運動員轉去佢哋覺得更好既學校無可厚非。

原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-27 06:39 發表
想指出,近年英華(中學)收"即食"運動員,已到畸形情況,e.g. 20歲兵球學界 A grade代表仲讀緊F.4, 全隊 A grade籃球隊正選都係插班生,和男拔"交換"泳手.

Is this the school you want your sons to study? ...

nigelman

轉校不是問題,但收個程度唔夠,20歲仲讀緊F.4,作為一間有191年歷史之名校,係咪咁害個學生?而對其他原可代表學校出賽之同學都不公平,這正是"買人"之壞處.而且在籃球隊更加過份,很多校友已表示不滿.Sam Hui都係中六入英華,但佢A-level成績優異,正正係win-win situation,對雙方都有好處, 這正是家長們可望見到的情況.

hingmami

依種情況第時會唔同，而家英華小學收生咁勁，肯定唔駛收外援。

原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-28 07:53 發表
轉校不是問題,但收個程度唔夠,20歲仲讀緊F.4,作為一間有191年歷史之名校,係咪咁害個學生?而對其他原可代表學校出賽之同學都不公平,這正是"買人"之壞處.而且在籃球隊更加過份,很多校友已表示不滿.Sam Hui都係中六入英 ...

gracechung

我唔係話偏幫邊間學校，事實上，聞說好些名校就係咁，唔同學生有唔同function，有些負責讀好書爭成績，有些負責運動爭獎，根對唔係過別學校做法對與不對，根本成個香港的觀念同風氣就唔健康！

原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-28 07:53 發表
轉校不是問題,但收個程度唔夠,20歲仲讀緊F.4,作為一間有191年歷史之名校,係咪咁害個學生?而對其他原可代表學校出賽之同學都不公平,這正是"買人"之壞處.而且在籃球隊更加過份,很多校友已表示不滿.Sam Hui都係中六入英 ...