想統計今年校際朗誦得獎成績-邊間學校?

overview

92分好勁噃...

我哋剛比賽完, 係市區但89分都攞第一

原文章由 菇芝bebi 於 07-12-8 00:00 發表
我係屯門區, 小一/二獨誦阿女個同學仔英文同普通話都俾d名校跨區個第一, 其實佢都係好叻架啦, 第二都有92分 全場6個獎都係跨區同我地學校晒 ...

菇芝bebi

我都唔知呀~~都係校長咁講我咁聽, 舊年有個同學入總決賽 不過今年就勁多跨區囉

原文章由 overview 於 07-12-9 02:47 發表
冠軍賽點通知架, 我仲以為告一段落...
到時係唔係所有區既冠軍mix up 埋比賽呢(唔分區只係同組同級) ?

gogochurch

May I know which St. Paul are you referring to :-

SP Convent, SP Boys, SP Secondary Primary School, SP Co-ed ?

原文章由 sandylaw 於 07-12-8 13:48 發表


6號中文獨誦都係 St.Paul取得冠軍和亞軍，
另一亞軍是中華基督教會基灣小學

gogochurch

I thought HKSMSA no longer have the Final Competition ?  

原文章由 菇芝bebi 於 07-12-9 11:14 發表
我都唔知呀~~都係校長咁講我咁聽, 舊年有個同學入總決賽 不過今年就勁多跨區囉   

鳳梨

小一, 二中文故事:

冠軍: 太古小學
亞軍: St. Mary
季軍: DGS (3 位)  & 1 boy (school ?)

gogochurch

I also notice that DGJS students are competing in different districts like TM, NTW and NTE, while the students are not living in that district and the school is not located there.  That may really be a strategy to get more Champions ?   

原文章由 菇芝bebi 於 07-12-8 23:07 發表
係呀! e+係區賽, 所有冠軍都會有冠軍賽, 所以今次有女拔跨區入tm個英文冠軍, 我地都好激氣:evil: :evil: :evil: 中文又係俾一間港島區小學   (件校服服有個白色十字架)d名校就係 ...

鳳梨

經學校報無可能可以跨區噃,
除非某d項目唔夠參賽者,或者係"open"
其實好多其他地區參賽者都表演好好..

原文章由 gogochurch 於 07-12-9 23:06 發表
I also notice that DGJS students are competing in different districts like TM, NTW and NTE, while the students are not living in that district and the school is not located there.  That may really be  ...

gogochurch

According to the HKSMSA regulation, the candidates are free to select competing in any district.  In selecting a district outside the school, the candidate may avoid competing with their own school mates, as there is a high chance that students from the same school are grouped together in one event.  The dispersement of students to different districts therefore increase the number of champions the school may get, presumably all its students are of high quality.  

原文章由 鳳梨 於 07-12-9 23:42 發表
經學校報無可能可以跨區噃,
除非某d項目唔夠參賽者,或者係"open"
其實好多其他地區參賽者都表演好好..

鳳梨

oic...你係男拔, 女拔走入去荃灣比賽係人都知你唔係呢區啦..

不過我哋經學校無咁做而好多場都自己人打自己人 , 唔緊要只要發揮得好就夠, 而邊個攞到獎都係為學校增光啫

原文章由 gogochurch 於 07-12-10 01:55 發表
According to the HKSMSA regulation, the candidates are free to select competing in any district.  In selecting a district outside the school, the candidate may avoid competing with their own school ma ...

j_py

純粹個人觀感:

其實睇左咁多年校際朗誦節, 得一個感覺, 得一個評判, 賽果好主觀.  有d評判比較喜歡著重聲線運用, 要恰到好處, 唔鍾意大動作; 有d就鍾意配合動作的演譯方法, 聲線亦喜歡較高音及誇張的. 各種風格有不同的好處, 視乎個人喜好.  

不過, 無可否認, 那些名校的學生的表現真的好淡定, 每個都很有大將之風.

鳳梨

剛剛留意到原來北大朗誦比賽有個係for校際既優勝者.

http://www.pkuschool.hk/download/PKU%20Speech%20Festival%20&%20Events%20%a5_%a4j%b0%ea%bb%da%ae%d4%bbw%b8%602008.pdf

原文章由 gogochurch 於 07-12-9 21:23 發表
I thought HKSMSA no longer have the Final Competition ?  

julietta

原文章由 鳳梨 於 07-12-10 03:31 發表
oic...你係男拔, 女拔走入去荃灣比賽係人都知你唔係呢區啦..

不過我哋經學校無咁做而好多場都自己人打自己人 , 唔緊要只要發揮得好就夠, 而邊個攞到獎都係為學校增光啫

...

我個仔聖若瑟小學有同學(三年級)英文獨誦攞第一及第三 (灣仔區), 中文獨誦攞第一(新界區)。此外還有同學參加普通話朗誦和散文, 至於名次就未知。

AKLAMY

I agree that if there are more than one judge is better. I think at least 3 judges is great.

原文章由 j_py 於 07-12-10 10:20 發表
純粹個人觀感:

其實睇左咁多年校際朗誦節, 得一個感覺, 得一個評判, 賽果好主觀.  有d評判比較喜歡著重聲線運用, 要恰到好處, 唔鍾意大動作; 有d就鍾意配合動作的演譯方法, 聲線亦喜歡較高音及誇張的. 各種風格有 ...

菇芝bebi

集誦個評判仲衰 連未叮之前d學生上台隊型都comment

原文章由 stccmc 於 07-12-10 23:16 發表
Is absolute fairness important?  Not for me.  My girl learnt a lot just by practicing for almost months and going up on stage and did her best.  

What is fair, anyway?

daisykkqq

我都覺得應該最少兩個judge，月頭小女已參加，當日其中一間學校取得冠亞季，冠軍85分。

huayan

我想問下,知吾知d名校有無提供特別訓練比ｄ參加者？？

小女個間就無喇，只鼓勵小朋友勇於嘗試，得獎只視為bonus.

AKLAMY

No..no..no..I am not talking about fairness here. I am talking about variety. More juges will have different views on voice, tones..etc.

About the absolute fairness? Nup..there isn't such a thing I guess cos' everyone is subjective...hahaha..

原文章由 stccmc 於 07-12-10 23:16 發表
Is absolute fairness important?  Not for me.  My girl learnt a lot just by practicing for almost months and going up on stage and did her best.  

What is fair, anyway?

overview

我哋學生老師好落力, 幫小朋友日日practice, 又比佢哋on stage表演吓, 結果成績好好, 有d包辦三名, 有小朋友係不同比賽都拿三甲, 相信judge係都一致覺得係好好. 我哋每場自己友都有2,3個, 分數都係1分之差咁上吓

原文章由 huayan 於 07-12-11 09:40 發表
我想問下,知吾知d名校有無提供特別訓練比ｄ參加者？？

小女個間就無喇，只鼓勵小朋友勇於嘗試，得獎只視為bonus.

overview

冠軍85分, 低左d喎, 我都睇左幾場,
大多88分攞冠軍

原文章由 daisykkqq 於 07-12-11 09:25 發表
我都覺得應該最少兩個judge，月頭小女已參加，當日其中一間學校取得冠亞季，冠軍85分。