SMC - 收到call 2nd IN 未呀？

bigfatboy

咁都得? 咁SMC真係要檢討吓佢地嘅面試制度同安排！但.........其實你有冇擔心過如果學校最終發現會有乜後果?

原帖由 chanwendy 於 11-12-2 14:43 發表


yes, 本來係諗住一試, 佢 check 到咁咪算囉.  而家即係校方根本冇 check.

chanwendy

原帖由 bigfatboy 於 11-12-2 15:01 發表
咁都得? 咁SMC真係要檢討吓佢地嘅面試制度同安排！但.........其實你有冇擔心過如果學校最終發現會有乜後果?

我當初交 FORM 佢係即時比期我的, 我有諗過佢會 CHECK 到然後通知我取消我個期的, 點知一路都冇, 咁我咪照去考囉.  咁佢又一路都冇 CHECK, 咁我就當佢唔介意人再考過架喇.  而且, 第二關比第一關難咁多, 考到先算啦.

仲有我決定交 FORM 時問過一位現任家長意見, 佢都覺得校方唔會 CHECK, 仲大力鼓勵我交 FORM, 我咪交囉.

[ 本帖最後由 chanwendy 於 11-12-2 15:21 編輯 ]

fc1668

chanwendy---咁神奇,不過都係兩個月既野,唔理啦,佢唔知咪由佢囉.希望你成功啦.


我就註冊左無中學既私校小學喇,所以有2n IN都唔去喇,比機會大家啦,況且我都應該無,佢都無打過黎.要請假走黎走去既日子...唉夠喇!大家好運喇~加油呀

bigfatboy

個人感想: 絕不認同此等「無人發現咪等如冇事」嘅諗法及「鋌而走險」嘅做法! 其實咁樣做同「以身試法」有乜分別? 明白現今各家長為咗個小一學位爭崩頭，但請謹記家長身教對小朋友實在有深遠嘅影响!

其實好多家長收咗waiting信都係循正途寫信去求位，點解要行條歪路呢? 唉!

原帖由 chanwendy 於 11-12-2 15:18 發表


我當初交 FORM 佢係即時比期我的, 我有諗過佢會 CHECK 到然後通知我取消我個期的, 點知一路都冇, 咁我咪照去考囉.  咁佢又一路都冇 CHECK, 咁我就當佢唔介意人再考過架喇.  而且, 第二關比第一關難咁多, 考到先算 ...

floppybb

This is really unfair to those on the waiting list.  According to the school's admission procedure, those on waiting will be invited for further interview ONLY after all applicants finished their interviews.  They have to wait probably until next May/June.  Now, you cut the queue and got the chance for 2nd interview at this early stage.  It's a pity for all those on the long list of waiting.     

原帖由 chanwendy 於 11-12-2 15:18 發表


我當初交 FORM 佢係即時比期我的, 我有諗過佢會 CHECK 到然後通知我取消我個期的, 點知一路都冇, 咁我咪照去考囉.  咁佢又一路都冇 CHECK, 咁我就當佢唔介意人再考過架喇.  而且, 第二關比第一關難咁多, 考到先算 ...

[ 本帖最後由 floppybb 於 11-12-5 01:58 編輯 ]

chanwendy

我之前真係冇諗咁多, 亦未認真考慮過公平的問題, 不過經 bigfatboy 提點後, 我真係再次諗諗呢個問題.  當時我諗的係我冇能力寫封好靚的求位信, 就只能靠小朋友的能力了.  為求公平, 我而家的打算係, 如果到時冇見家長, 即係都唔收, 咁就算啦, 如果有得見家長, 我就會同主任講, 留待主任決定係咪真係收啦.  咁如果主任知道後都仲收, 咁即使我讀都會讀得心安理得.

antonyada

同意floppybb 的意見,
強烈要求校方徹查這些情況, 會否只是冰山一角.

原帖由 floppybb 於 11-12-5 01:55 發表
This is really unfair to those on the waiting list.  According to the school's admission procedure, those on waiting will be invited for further interview ONLY after all applicants finished their inte ...

TheWiseMom

Chanwendy's case is that her first application couldn't get a 2nd interview, but her second application could. That raises the question of the effectiveness of interview system. This year, almost every DSS/private school places strong emphasis on interview performance. I've wondered how the schools can pick up the best/most suitable applicants in such a short time of around 30 to 45 min. Or they actually have some applicants in mind (e.g. related/privileged/from famous kindergarten, which may reveal the financial background of the families) who will most likely go to the 2nd in., and they use bad interview performance as excuse to reject those applicants who are just there to "陪跑". This kind of situation may especially happen in top-tier schools. It's because we really don't know how our children have performed during the interviews.

flyda

啱！根本就係學校問題，佢 Application 遞 form period 咁長一定會有好多人去試啦！學校又一路in一路收人，有的 2nd in 咗又即刻比 reject，有啲就遲來先 In; 根本佢係有 target 對象但又行政混亂；同埋好明顯呢間學校對 2nd in 嘅理解同我哋一般家長甚至同其他學校有好大差別。

呢嗰家長誠實的同盡力為子女啫。叫學校徹查wow，學校徹查自己咩。

[ 本帖最後由 flyda 於 11-12-5 12:22 編輯 ]

antonyada

唔好用 "誠實" 來蓋過事實, 人人都知道偷竊觸犯法律, 係咪等於無人知道就可以犯法?

學校沒有核查報名資料有無重覆呢part 絕對係學校行政既問題; 但家長以此行徑將來點可以以身作則, 對其他以正途申請, 等待既後備生更加唔公道; 因為你絕對有足夠準備知道會考什麼, 會點考, 甚至乎背答案, 第二次有2nd in 既機會當然大增.

學校自然要改進, 但係家長呢d 係操守問題.

原帖由 flyda 於 11-12-5 12:04 發表
啱！根本就係學校問題，佢 Application 遞 form period 咁長一定會有好多人去試啦！學校又一路in一路收人，有的 2nd in 咗又即刻比 reject，有啲就遲來先 In; 根本佢係有 target 對象但又行政混亂；同埋好明顯呢間學校對 2nd in  ...

fc1668

唔報都報左喇,加油喇,一於睇下有無機會見到主任同佢講句囉.

原帖由 chanwendy 於 11-12-5 11:09 發表
我之前真係冇諗咁多, 亦未認真考慮過公平的問題, 不過經 bigfatboy 提點後, 我真係再次諗諗呢個問題.  當時我諗的係我冇能力寫封好靚的求位信, 就只能靠小朋友的能力了.  為求公平, 我而家的打算係, 如果到時冇見家 ...

chanwendy

因為有啲學校係真係可以第一輪唔成功, 在第二輪再次入表申請的, 所以我當初先會再次入表的, 冇諗過咁大迴響.  總知我到時有機會見主任, 我就會坦白講.

bigfatboy

其實現今家長嘅壓力真係好大，尤其去到考小一、中一或公開試階段，所以好容易為咗幫仔女爭取機會而迷失，但無論點困難都應該遵守遊戲規則! Anyway, 欣賞你勇於面對嘅態度，希望你囡囡考到適合佢嘅學校亦讀得開心!

原帖由 chanwendy 於 11-12-5 11:09 發表
我之前真係冇諗咁多, 亦未認真考慮過公平的問題, 不過經 bigfatboy 提點後, 我真係再次諗諗呢個問題.  當時我諗的係我冇能力寫封好靚的求位信, 就只能靠小朋友的能力了.  為求公平, 我而家的打算係, 如果到時冇見家 ...

bigfatboy

非常贊同! 此事反映學校制度有漏洞需要檢討，但更重要係家長嘅操守!

其實當事人都勇於承認及面對，希望其他家長不要再「合理化」此等違規及引致不公平行為!!!

原帖由 antonyada 於 11-12-5 15:31 發表
唔好用 "誠實" 來蓋過事實, 人人都知道偷竊觸犯法律, 係咪等於無人知道就可以犯法?

學校沒有核查報名資料有無重覆呢part 絕對係學校行政既問題; 但家長以此行徑將來點可以以身作則, 對其他以正途申請, 等待既後備 ...

人地既阿媽

明白為人父母會盡一切辦法為子女爭取理想的學校，但必須要 "合法" 和問心無愧。你的做法固然不對，對其他家長是一個壞榜樣。但我欣賞你的坦白和事後反省的能力，希望你能堅持如實地將情況告訴學校。

的確某些學校有第二輪申請的機會，但會在第一輪申請已完結後才開始公開接受申請的。

[ 本帖最後由 人地既阿媽 於 11-12-6 18:13 編輯 ]

floppybb

"你絕對有足夠準備知道會考什麼, 會點考, 甚至乎背答案, 第二次有2nd in 既機會當然大增"  This is the point.

KarenLeo

for information:

2 Nov - First In
25 Nov - Second In (interviewed by 主任, parents invited for interview also)
17 Dec - Received offer letter by mail

Good luck to all!

XianXianMa

請問11月底面試的是否已收到2nd in通知了嗎？
會否有信件通知呢?

杜媽媽

回復 XianXianMa 的帖子

11月底 1st interview
一直無收到任何通知, Xmas 放假後打電話給學校, 得知在waiting list, 詳情年底發信通知.
　

joeyxlma

Same to me!