2013 IB Results Reporting Thread

HKTHK

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

I did this adjustment as well but after looking at how other schools do their disclosure, they all seem to only average the results of students who did get the diploma

ANChan59

Understand, consistent is the key.

HKTHK

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

But the rumoured figure of 29/30 could very well have been correct if that student scored below 23

daisychan

回覆 nintendo 的帖子


回覆 nintendo 的帖子:

"我個人就唔想仔女讀 english b。如果只讀 english b，選擇少好多，而呢個情形，唔係話考 ielts 或 sat 可以幫到手。
大陸學生，台灣學生，因為課程限制，冇較高水平的英文科選擇，因此可以靠考 sat 或 ielts 等幫補。
但 ibdp 明明有 english a，學生都唔讀，只讀 english b，大學就知係乜事，因此唔可以為靠 sat 或 ielts 可以補償。
我自己比較過，我覺得 english b 淺過 dse english，難聽 d 講，我覺得香港學生讀 english b，真係 "好渣"。"


我亦是因為不想女兒只讀 English B, 所以安排她轉校。

新校在 Orientation Week 讓學生出席由老師講解 language subjects 的內容及考試要求。女兒都覺得 English B 和 DSE English 差不多。而 English A 因為有 literature 成份，她覺得可令她更了解、學好及掌握該語文及文化。但我不認同香港學生讀 English B 係 "好渣"，因為有時衹是學校的刻意安排罷了。

ANChan59

回覆 daisychan 的帖子

我都聽說上一屆學生英語水平是 OK，考 lELTS 都有 6.5-7.5, 相等於 DSE 5 至 5**。

poonseelai

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

I would like to the university placement for the students taking IB Eng B, but seems no information is available in Logos website.

ANChan59

poonseelai 發表於 13-12-16 10:02
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

I would like to the university placement for the students taking IB Eng B, but ...

I don't know much of their university placements and programs results.
I guess which affect more in top program admission rather than university placement. It means more general program than professional program offers.

poonseelai

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

True, 好似之前有討論講過第一介無同學鍾情醫同法律，所以無人入這兩科

hkparent

原帖由 poonseelai 於 13-12-16 發表
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

True, 好似之前有討論講過第一介無同學鍾情醫同法律，所以無人入這兩科 ...

I heard from a parent that they have DSE students going to medic/law this year.

1.3CC

回覆 annie40 的帖子

The honour of success to parents and schools, the blame on failure to school.

1.3CC

回覆 ckwliu 的帖子

ANChan59

hkparent 發表於 13-12-16 18:20
I heard from a parent that they have DSE students going to medic/law this year.

Off topic. We are talking about IB.

wingsma

一口氣看了，大家都對CKY的IB成績很失望，甚至比對DBS有30%學生取不到本地大學的最低入學資格更失望，真有點費解！
公道一點，CKY是新校，開校時只收了兩班小二(約五六十人)和四班小一，亦即第一屆IB學生當年是從其他小學完成小一後轉到CKY，恐怕他們都不是從一線學校轉來(有錯請指正)，但經常有人要她與其他名校比，另一費解！
當然，31.2比最差的還要差。
假如︰
1, CKY的首屆畢業生是原本五、六十人中的精英，較差的已離開了，走到外國升學，或走到本地其他學校如LPC，則那成績確反映學校的不濟；
2, 離開的是較好的，剩下較差的，成績平均約30，但LPC最差的14人平均(25+2X26+4X27+4X29+3X31)/14=28.8 分，你們可想像網羅全球精英學生的學校有這樣的成績嗎？

ANChan59

多謝你對學生素質的背境，你對學校又有甚麼見解。

如果學生走得就走，是否亦反映一些問題。

bobbycheung

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

1. CKY is new to IB and it is not unusual to have more students leaving for other schools in this transition period.  Students are unsure as to how well the school will perform and they might choose to leave so as to avoid the "risks".  
2. I think ckwliu pointed out the crux of the issue.  The question is what expectation or promises did CKY give to the students /parents and what did the school deliver at the end?   One needs to measure the IB results against these expectation or promises.  
3. What problems have the school identified and what remedial steps have been taken?
4. As an example of (3) above, I note that CKY's IB prospectus 2013 says the school offers English A, Chinese A, English B (HL) and Chinese B (HL).  
http://cky.edu.hk/wp-content/upl ... _Prospectus2013.pdf
Did the school insisted that all students should do English A and Chinese A?  If so, what were the English A scores?  I am not suggesting that the school should manoeuver the subjects so as to achieve a Bilingual Diploma.  I am just wondering if the school had assessed the English level of all students correctly before making or letting them to take English A.  The school has all the result details showing which subject or subjects fall most short of expectation and I guess it wouldn't be that difficult to identify what the problem is.

wingsma

回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

學生中途離開，有很多可能性︰
1, 覺得學校名不符實，走為上著；
2, 因誤解而結合，因了解而分開。理念不同，另覓他校；
3, 有更好的選擇，如LPC, DBS, SPCC, IS等，如得這些學校取錄，確實很難擴拒，學生要留，家長也要未必准許；正如不少名校生都會轉到LPC或當年的恆商，這都不是那些名校之罪；
4, 不少家長會讓小朋友在中小學某階段到外國留學，廿多年前DJGS的小一每班約40人，到了小六會減至廿幾人，主要是學生出國留學，今天不知是否不同！
以上第1,2點會是學校的問題，第3,4點則不然，但實情如何，我們都不知，可能各種情況都有，但ckwliu肯定屬於第一種！

丘成桐在中大、BILL GATE IN HARVARD、李澤楷在史坦福都是未畢業便離開的，這又反映甚麼？(純屬搞笑)

ANChan59

wingsma 發表於 13-12-28 15:14
回覆 ANChan59 的帖子

學生中途離開，有很多可能性︰

明白。
第 4 點跟 1, 2, 3 是有關連。