DGJS 今日開始 2nd Interview

Babu0710

我好似講緊大、細女機會均等喎！呢個亦係事實！唔通大部分都是細女才算均等嗎？而面試班方面，校長都有講過不喜歡亦不鼓勵，而我指的都是長時間接受面試班訓練的，原因好簡單，佢地的答案、表現都是十分相似、老練，我識的朋友中至少有六個相同case，沒有2nd in，但在其他校又收到唔少offers，小的有兩三個，最多嗰個有七個，只是DGJS及GH唔得（上年）。仲埋只是參考意見，講出所知的實況，絕對無意打破面試班的飯碗！

Loso

事實係四、五個細女入倒真係唔足以代表大細女機會均等囉！咁啱我又識一班有讀面試班(唔只7個添啦）而又讀緊DG喎，咁我咪可以話校長呃我咩？利益申報我同面試班全無

Babu0710

算吧啦，如你想討論面試班如何有效，有優勢，另開一個post吧！大細女問題，都唔只我一人講機會均等，我只可以証明校長冇特別偏好收大女，長時間受面試班訓練面試過程中亦唔見得有特別優勢！

Loso

問題係你嘅參考意見有落差啫！我都深信只要小朋友叻，DG係唔會理大細女啦！

原帖由 Babu0710 於 11-11-20 13:01 發表
算吧啦，如你想討論面試班如何有效，有優勢，另開一個post吧！大細女問題，都唔只我一人講機會均等，我只可以証明校長冇特別偏好收大女，長時間受面試班訓練面試過程中亦唔見得有特別優勢！ ...

Babu0710

你都幾得意，你講：「我都深信只要小朋友叻，DG係唔會理大細女啦！」是否同意大細女機會均等？！如果唔係知道有冇背景的超細女係DGJS P.1讀，我都唔會有呢個想法啦！收得當然是校長覺得叻同適合，我又唔覺有咩問題！如果我講到面試班問題，另你有咁大反應，對你有什麼影響、冒犯，真係失覺、失覺！況且呢到只是個人發表意見的地方，亦無謂針鋒相對。

Loso

講極都唔明：DG會公平對待大細女，這點大家同意，面試班如何與我何干，敏感的似乎是閣下，想提出是閣下「參考意見有點落差啫！」
Anyway,明就明，唔明亦冇辦法，不過若果因在下意見令你感到唔舒服，在下同你講句「唔好意思」囉！而我亦唔想再作糾纏了！

原帖由 Babu0710 於 11-11-20 13:40 發表
你都幾得意，你講：「我都深信只要小朋友叻，DG係唔會理大細女啦！」是否同意大細女機會均等？！如果唔係知道有冇背景的超細女係DGJS P.1讀，我都唔會有呢個想法啦！收得當然是校長覺得叻同適合，我又唔覺有咩問題！如果我講到面試班問題 ...

Babu0710

其實我覺得係你唔知自己講緊乜，我一直只是說DGJS大、細女機會均等，叻、合適咪收，講些例子亦只是講出所見的事實，說明自己為什麼有這說法！唔覺有咩唔妥，亦唔明你點解有咁大反應，字字針對，最奇最後你的想法又變回應同！Anyway，各位細女家長，冇上面試班的小朋友，請有信心，加油，你們的小朋友並沒有因此而機會細左！

blueroselam

只要校長試到該小朋友有鬥心, 思考叻, 反應快, 應該無分大細女架! 要知道學校年年成績優異, 公開比賽也一樣! 你地就知學校收生標準! 入得去既程度都有返咁上下!!

LSKLTK

Yes, agree.  No need to argue, just let's share.  Actually, we can have a break now after one year preparation for primary if we are not keen for DGJS, SPCC or other toppest school. Well, it is not easy......

eirisc

大細女機會均等唔代表什麼. 如一個一月一日出世同十二月三十一日出世比.細女一定要比大女超級smart，才可以有同一水準。試問一個細路大一年可以識多幾多嘢.所以就算學校機會均等都無用.如果細女有大女嘅料.一定好吸收同比大女smart.除非學校有唔同標準唔同月份嘅學生.否則一定唔公平.而家唔係40歳同41歳嘅分別.係5歳同4歳嘅分別，係人生嘅1/5時間.如果唔係超級勁.邊有得揮呀.試問現在比多一年時間D細女.一定學多好多嘢.到時再做同一個interview一定唔同.

Babu0710

你的講法我都幾認同，其實考得入去的，學校都認為是最好的。我覺得學校收生時的睇法亦都一樣，只看表現、資質，冇perfer收大女！只可以講，細女家長在培養、準備方面會緊密啲，大女用差不多6年時間可拉長做，但細女就只有5年。

KwanPark

According to past years record or statistics, less than 10% small girl can enter to P1.  If the figure excluded the related person, only less than 8% small girls are successful and that small girls should be more or less extremely smart types or genius type.

Babu0710

Small girls 指九月以後出生還是十一月以後出生？純粹好奇問下，因我知嗰幾個是十一月以後的。

KwanPark

Information verbally coming from internal, small girls means Sep or Oct or Nov or even Dec, I don't clarify it, but in general, it should be "means" Sep or later.

UncleGrand

Hi Babu0710，

謝謝你的分享，以你所講DGJS似乎是不太刻意收大女的，但也想一問所謂「冇背景」的細女和「有背景」嘅真的有分別嗎？

Thanks！

Babu0710

我識的所謂有背景的都是家姐係度讀或媽咪是舊生，但唔識係細女（因識的細女都是冇背景），我估計（純粹估計）會易入啲（但好像講過無分加，一視同仁），因為都識幾個家姐係度讀。而好有錢同學校好有關係的我不認識不能答你。而學生真係唔少好似之前post講的「彈彈下」咁，似乎學校唔咁介意活潑好動的學生，起碼唔駛先操場集隊才上課室，放學亦唔使排隊自己落樓上校車或家長接，但當然上課要守規矩！

Angelakibb

請問DGJS SECOND IN-ED囡囡現時有冇D OFFER吸引程度泊得住DGJS呢 (如GOOD GOOD 津校 及 ST PAUL CO-EDU) ? 我囡15分搏天神當然失望而回 ...
手頭上又唔知點取捨D 直資 / 私校 ... 好煩呀 !

tumtum

Re. preference or not for big girls, I also agree that the school does not automatically shortlist the older girls, it will be based on interview performance.

However, having said that, I also believe it is difficult for the "small" girls to perform at the same level as the "big" girls.  Of course there will be exceptions, and not because the "big" girls are automatically smarter, but one year difference at their young age makes a big difference.

I know of 13 girls that got into 2nd in this year.  9 of them were born in Sept - Dec 2005.

Lamka

For those 冇背景kids, are they from CCKG?  CCKG only accepts kids within the same calendar year so they won't have those BIG BIG kids born in 2005.  

Talking about 彈彈下, my colleague who has kids studying in CCKG and now in DGJS, he told me most of girls in DGJS are 彈彈下!  So no worries if any of your girls 彈彈下 in DGJS interviews.

Agree BIG BIG girl has an average advantage in interviews, mentally can handle those tricky questions easily than small girls.  Of course, no absolute case.  My girl was a small girl got 2nd interview in DGJS last year (repeat K2) while try again this year as a BIG BIG girl.  If I got the DGJS offer, I will be an example to prove BIG BIG girl can get offer than SMALL girl.  My background never changed throughtout this year but the difference is my daughter is mature this year.  (have attended some ECAs to improve language but not much certificates).

P.S. My girl is not the DGJS type so if we fail, it proves again Mrs. Dai is consistent in her selection.  Of course, I don't expect too much and we are not a DGJS fans.

UncleGrand

Hi Babu0710，

唔該晒你寶貴的資料，我只是擔心如果有背景的考生(正如你所說的)一定收的話，咁我們的機會咪更加微.....唉