2013 IB Results Reporting Thread

HKTHK

回復 daisychan 的帖子

Table on page 1 updated to show LPCUWC results

HKTHK

Table on page 1 updated to show CKY results

112200

CKY....31.2 no wonder.

hkparent

原帖由 112200 於 13-12-10 發表
CKY....31.2 no wonder.

It's quite astonishing. It's such a popular school in the eyes of many P1 applicants. It's a serious test of its teaching philosophy.

annie40

回覆 ckwliu 的帖子

I don't think the level of  CKY students is that bad, especially those 14 students should have been selected from whole grade . Would it be possible that teachers pretend they know how to teach? and in fact, they don't.

daisychan

回覆 annie40 的帖子


Agree. I think the general quality of the students is good. This year 4 or 5  CKY students were selected by LPCUWC.

poonseelai

annie40 發表於 13-12-10 19:53
回覆 ckwliu 的帖子

I don't think the level of  CKY students is that bad, especially those 14 studen ...

CKY offers only IBDP and not DSE. The 14 students were already the whole cohort.  

daisychan

Are they the first batch of IB candidates?

nintendo

esf 有 btec，唔算 ib only。

nintendo

annie40 發表於 13-12-10 19:53
回覆 ckwliu 的帖子

I don't think the level of  CKY students is that bad, especially those 14 studen ...

乜唔係要係 qualified ib teachers 先可以教 ibdp？
至於學生，本身質素唔應該差到是拿 31 分 average 的水平。
我只可以話，是學校的責任：首先，他們 pre-ib 做得唔好，不能令學生順利適應 ibdp 的學習方式。另外，學生可能失分在 internal assessment，因為他們不習慣 ib 評估方式，也不明白 internal assessment 的重要性。至於 external exam，如果是 math 和 science 就唔難應付，可能好多人會唔同意，但其實佢地 d 題目肯定冇香港 hkcee 或 hkal 咁 tricky。但 group 1 (language a) 和 group 3 (humanities) 的題目就真係較難捉摸，尤其 group 3 ，選錯科真係可以死得好慘。還有，香港好多人以為 group 6  的 music 易，其實 ibdp music 和香港學生學樂理好唔同，就算你 8 級琴，都未必代表會讀 music 讀得好，好多有玩樂器的，都是呢科中伏，個個以為自己 8 級，就 6-7 分 十拿九穩，讀落先自一 d 都唔易。

112200

Students switch from one school to another one is normal and happen on all schools. This is not a vaild excuse.

HKTHK

Is 31.2 a good result?  Clearly not.  Although several schools don't disclose their results, CKY probably has the lowest score in HK.  But this is their first year.  I would give the school the benefit of the doubt and am sure they will improve from there.  As for the reason for the low score in its first year, does it matter?

hkparent

原帖由 112200 於 13-12-11 發表
Students switch from one school to another one is normal and happen on all schools. This is not a va ...

It has good IGCSE results (for those few students who transferred to LPC or on average?), so the problem may be its IBDP programme.

annie40

The school should take all responsibilities for such disastrous results. With such results students seem unable to get admission into college.They should not send students to take IB in case they are not well prepared. Or the school is weak on judgement and assessment? Please don't forget SPCC takes the 1st year IB as well.  It is not an excuse.  

If I am parent of IB studens at CKY in form 3 or 4, I would try to transmit to other schools.

caa

annie40 發表於 13-12-11 12:33
The school should take all responsibilities for such disastrous results. With such results students  ...

Agree. If I were parents of this school, I would definitely need to know the reasons for such bad results, in order to make an informed decision as to whether to let the kid continue at this school.

112200

原帖由 annie40 於 13-12-11 發表
The school should take all responsibilities for such disastrous results. With such results students  ...

I agreed w you. Besides SPCC ,SIS also having their first year in IB, that is not an excuse. Furthermore this is cky 2nd year of IB, i am afraid it has been forgotten by most people. Regarding why cky took IB, i think i can share more. Cky student follow IGCSE during secondary school , but IGCSE does not have upper level , those IGCSE school need to choose either the british GCE or IB as their upper curriculum. For cky, while they apply an extreme end of 活動教學 therefore the british GSE definitely is not feasible for their students. While IB is a new and require creativity , under no other choice thats sounds more reasonable yo be connected with.  As from the v begining, the cky master has mentioned this is a new way she want prove her logic and dream....  trial & error on IB. Now the dream is over.

hkparent

原帖由 annie40 於 13-12-11 發表
The school should take all responsibilities for such disastrous results. With such results students  ...

Me too. If I were a parent, I'd definitely look for other IB schools.