12網區男孩子, 家長你地會點排位呀?

kerobobo

LLT:
您部手寫板壞左咩?我仲未諗到第二志願填邊間好.

LLT

Charlotte_mom,

Since there is no K1 in St. Josp. Kinder, you still have time to wait and see.


kerobobo,

I have no hand-writing pad in my office but at home.

If you fill in Wah Yan or HRGPS as your second or third choice, you are doomed to fail.  This is the last advice that I can give you

Wish you good luck!

麟媽媽

如果減110個學額預備接龍，
即是仲有大約5 班大概200個位，
咁小一派位情況都唔係咁差啫。
LLT，佢地中學5 班定6 班？
如果接龍，除左全收小學之外，
中學仲要留20% 比街外人，
如果中學有6 班都夠位，
但如果得5 班，一係中學再加一班，
一係小學再縮至4 班，
如果唔係都接唔成龍架喎，係咪？

麟媽媽

Charlotte_mom,

St. Jo 中學前排咪籌款擴建既，
學校夠大開到6 班咁就掂囉！
真係鄧人諗吓都開心，
諗得幾咁美滿……  

primary2007

麟媽媽

我仔都有唔少同學住銅鑼灣同灣仔的，
東區都唔少，自行分配學位入得既，
呢個階段手持20 分先會有機會，
咁住邊都無影響既，華仁位太少，
借地址大抽獎報St. Jo機會高得多！

primary2007 寫道:
原來身邊個個是用假地址。
麟媽媽 ，真係想起來好笑，華仁會唔會
多數不是住在12net ？

LLT

麟媽媽,

From the government web-site, it is revealed that the students' establishment of the 'big Jo' is, at the moment, 200.  It is thus reasonable to infer that the big Jo has 5 classes in each grade.

Personally, I am not quite optimistic about the 'through-train' arrangement under consideration for the following two reasons:-

(1) the problem that the big Jo has on its limited school space, which hinders a remarkable expansion of school seats;and

(2) the hurdle it may encounter in achieving the minimum percentage set by the Education & Manpower Bureau on students who have the ability to receive English media instruction in order to maintain its status as an English secondary school.

Most probably, I believe, the only choice left to the school board is to end the little Jo's feeder school relation with the big Jo, if the 'through-train' idea is not materialised nor are both schools change into DSSs.

If this 3rd final option is chosen, I'm afraid that the prospect of the little Jo is dim in the long run.  It will be sad if, one day, it has to take in girl students in order to stay survive

khwong67

I don't think the chance to go st jo is not that great as you thought.  The reason is that many parents will chose it same as yours.  

cheukyin

其實我都係咁諗, 不過都想知道, 我本身係軒官o既舊生, 唔知個排位又係唔係咁呢?

cheukyin

Charlotte_mom 寫道:
華仁有分上下午校嗎? 唔sure tim!
不過如果第一揀華仁上午, 第2揀華仁下午基本上已經side機會(有咩理由華仁揀第2都有得入丫!), touchwood衰左, 真係唔知派左去邊wor!
個個都鐘意上晝班, 如果我無私校做backup, 我會playsafe, 擺st jo or軒官下晝or華仁下晝o係第一, 再擺st james做第2(因為擺d名校做第2根本無機!)
如果有私校做backup, 我會搏盡d

其實我都係咁諗, 不過都想知道, 我本身係軒官o既舊生, 唔知個排位又係唔係咁呢?

麟媽媽

你唔好咁講喇… 雖則真係可能發生，
令到我諗到我地都可能係咁既下場….
我地校方一直都表態「唔會」轉直資，
但限期快到，接龍又死，唔接仲死！
我地唔通真係要好似DPS 咁，
要收女仔？但同網咁多女校，
有女既都唔選St. Jo / 華仁喇！！

其實，MSS、St. Paul's Cathoilc 同埋St. Francis'，
一樣有呢個問題架？但佢地好似無咩講點處理既？

LLT 寫道:

Most probably, I believe, the only choice left to the school board is to end the little Jo's feeder school relation with the big Jo, if the 'through-train' idea is not materialised nor are both schools change into DSSs.

If this 3rd final option is chosen, I'm afraid that the prospect of the little Jo is dim in the long run.  It will be sad if, one day, it has to take in girl students in order to stay survive

stevema

"其實，MSS、St. Paul's Cathoilc 同埋St. Francis'，
一樣有呢個問題架？但佢地好似無咩講點處理既？"

My impression is the teaching/ learning quality is much better in these girl schools than St. Jo.  If the figure I heard is correct, only 1/3 of the student can go to their secondary school. So St. Jo is screening students, same as other SSs, 1/3 is band 1, can go direct to their secondary.  This is only personal impression, please correct me if I am wrong.

麟媽媽

因為而家政府要直屬中小學，
一係結龍，一係脫鈎，
而家D 直屬中學收1/3 既話，
當然Band 1 人數都佔某個比率，
但如果接龍又唔係咁講，
接左既話，全收Band 1 至Band 3 了。
如果唔接龍便要脫鈎，
到時一眾直屬小學都再無直屬額，
呢個先係我所提及以上女校一樣要面對既難題。

stevema 寫道:
"其實，MSS、St. Paul's Cathoilc 同埋St. Francis'，
一樣有呢個問題架？但佢地好似無咩講點處理既？"

My impression is the teaching/ learning quality is much better in these girl schools than St. Jo.  If the figure I heard is correct, only 1/3 of the student can go to their secondary school. So St. Jo is screening students, same as other SSs, 1/3 is band 1, can go direct to their secondary.  This is only personal impression, please correct me if I am wrong.

stevema

Yes, I noted the rules. Just I think those girls schools' output is better and more likely to achieve 85% band 1 after 6 years. No such news from those schools.

How is the band 1 percentage with St. Jo after 6 years?

Anyhow, I think only parents like the through train idea, schools have their problem to achieve, they may not like it.

麟媽媽

你意思係呢D 女校可以做到全數收晒，
即是Band 1-3 都可以做到85% 達標？
我無諗得咁樂觀，萬一Band 2 尾至band 3 多於20%，
中學都可能轉做中文中學，好高風險。

根據而家既派位制，
用直屬額由St. Jo 小學上St. Jo 中學既，
都應該係全Band 1 架喇，
問題係接龍之後，能否達標。

Sindy

除左st joe同華一放第一係唔穩陣之外,放乜係第一都入梗的呀,因為有人軒官上第三都入到,聖雅各果d都唔駛講啦.....