請問幾歲考鋼琴一級試?

AndyRain

Hi, Esmond'sMom

請問有沒有competition可介紹小女參加呢? 主要都係想幫佢練大膽d.

謝謝!

Esmond'sMom 寫道:
Anyway, exposure is very important for building a kid's confidence, and I agree with her teacher that getting a low score in the exam (especially the first time) has negative impact on the kid.

AndyRain

hi, lycheema

我諗你同我都一樣覺得好抽象, 唔知點樣才叫做進度合乎理想進度.  學數學會較容易知道, 一年級上學期要學加數, 下學期要學減數等.  若孩子在學一年級上學期時計加數計得好, 咁樣我地就會知道佢既進度合乎理想.  若佢能學埋減數, 就叫做超乎理想.  你有無同感呀? 係我地無能力去判斷佢既能力!! 哈哈!!

其實, 我唔係話怕miss教佢教得慢左, 只係諗住若佢既進度未如理想, 咁睇下點樣可以再幫下佢.  同埋想了解孩子多d.

lycheema 寫道:
Hi, Esmond's Mom

My daughter started learning piano at 3.5, now she is 4.  My husband and I do not know about piano, so we have no idea if she is learning in a normal pace.  I only know she can now play by 2 hands simple songs looking at the movement.  Her teacher  teaches her 0.5 hour a week (she has other students immediately after my daughter's lesson), I have asked her teacher whether she could increase the time say to 45 min, and she said it is not necessary. Not sure if it is because of her tight schedule or not.  No information can be referred.

Just wonder whether my daughter could try the test in mid-2007.  Other mothers said it's 4-5 years old, then I wld talk to the teacher again and try to make some arrangement/preparation.

Lycheema  

Kubi

我囡囡5歲，學琴已１年多，而家學緊第３本書
囡囡都好鐘意彈琴，每次叫佢練琴佢都好樂意，但有時佢只彈自己鍾意既歌，彈到唔駛睇琴譜，又快，其他唔熟既就唔願彈

AndyRain,
你囡囡真係乖，可以每日練琴45分鐘 我個囡都肯練，不過唔會練得耐，一來佢唔係首首都肯彈，二來ｄ歌仔又太短，好快彈完一首，叫佢彈多幾次佢又唔鐘意

我想問下好唔好硬性規定佢練45分鐘，定係由得佢練晒佢要練既歌就算 因為我怕咁樣好似係我迫佢咁 同埋45分鐘咁耐，真係可以每本書每首歌彈幾次，會唔會太耐，佢會覺得悶呢

AndyRain

Hi, Kubi

想問你指學緊第3本書係mug野意思呢? book3?

我個女都唔係每日都練45分鐘的, 只係通常.  有時做唔切d野, 都唔夠時間俾佢練45分鐘.  我就唔係數足45分鐘先俾佢停手, 只係depends on佢練成點同見到佢個死款都係無心機練或眼訓, 就會收工.  我會不停咁要佢重覆練, 練到我收貨為止先練另一條新歌.  因為連我呢個外行都唔收貨, 又點可以過到老師那一關呢? 所以我能執佢的, 都執佢, 執得幾多得幾多啦.  都試過佢彈錯左我都唔知架, 但我都叫做盡左我既責任啦.

其實邊有可能唔停手咁彈足45分鐘呀, 又要話俾佢聽點樣錯, 點樣改, 有時又要氹下佢, 有時又要鬧下佢, 都用左唔少時間啦. 除非有時間剩先可以彈番d舊歌咋.  不過我通常有時間淨都係會教佢一d未學既歌, 咁我諗到佢學時會易d上手.  學你話齋, 成日都彈舊歌都真係幾悶的. 咁亞女聽到我話教佢新歌, 佢又會好興奮.  間住間住咁攞, 得少少時間淨就彈舊歌算啦.  有好多時間就可以教佢新歌攞.

Esmond'smom

Noted with thanks.

Kubi

AndyRain,
由個囡學琴至今，只係買左三本琴書：
１）John Thompson's Easiest Piano Course Part One
２）John Thompson's Easiest Piano Course Part Two
３）John Thompson's Modern Course For the Piano-the First Grade Book
佢係一本學完再買第二本，第二本學完，剛剛買左第三本學緊，我都唔知算唔算係book 3

其實我想知我囡囡既進度算唔算慢 佢一星期學一堂（３０分鐘）每堂學一首歌仔，我有個朋友個囡學早我個囡少少，佢話佢個囡每堂可以學４－５首歌，一套書有六本，已經學緊第三套書 不過個老師唔係首首都教，係抽黎教

gabrielmum

Esmond'sMom,

我都想問0下仔仔進度點呢？因為我自己對鋼琴一無所知，請問你對於佢ge用書有0羊意見呢？

仔仔5歲，學琴3個月，用0左以下ge書：
1.Alfred's Basic Piano Libray----Prep course A (Lesson + Technic)
2. Alfred's Basic Piano Libray----Prep course B(Lesson + Technic)
而家用Alfred's Basic Piano Libray----Alfred's Basic  1A (Lesson + Technic+recite+theory)

thank you

AndyRain

hi, kubi

咁奇怪既??? 我個仔同個女學琴都唔係學完一本先一本架. 連我小時學琴都唔係只得一本書架.  

亞女個miss叫我買了三本琴書, 一本係john thomson, 一本係b字頭的, 一本係e字頭的 (唔記得個名).  每堂都教晒3本書, 每本書教一首歌的. 每堂都係學30分鐘. 上了4, 5堂度, miss叫我買多一本書tim.  而家4本書輪住教. 通常30分鐘都只係夠時間教到3首歌, 因為又要彈一次功課, 執下d功課既錯處, 再教新既歌, 都真係唔夠時間的.

亞女個老師都唔係順住教的, 因為佢應該係覺得適合的教先.  唔知係咪首首教呀, 因為未教晒一本書.

唔怪之得你話同亞女練琴會悶啦, 因為每次只有一首新歌, 咁梗係悶啦, 所以亦會有好多時間淨番, 可以練舊歌的.  我唔識綱琴的, 但係我都覺得同時間學2,3本書會好d, 因為每本書都有佢既好處, 或個女有唔完善的, 可以有多幾首差不多的俾佢再打好d個底.  

我個人意見, 或者esmond's mom可以俾d專業d既意見你參考.  參考完你再同老師商量一下啦.

YanYan0116

我個女(6歲)都係同一時間學3本, 每堂30分鐘, 每堂每本都會學2-3頁.

1) john thomson part one ---> part two-----> Grade one

2) Es........(橙色面) ---> STEP BY STEP ---> Micheal AR...

3) A dozen a day (粉紅色) ----->  (綠色) -----> everybody likes piano

但我個女已學了10個月, 唔知點解老師無叫佢報考試, 我見該琴行貼

Kubi

AndyRain,Esmond'sMom
多謝你地既意見�提醒
咁我好唔好轉琴行呢 其實呢個老師係第二個老師，對上一個老師係因為某ｄ原因唔教，琴行就轉過第二個老師教我個囡，兩個老師都係一堂教一首，順序咁教，所以我以為一般都係咁 而我朋友個囡既老師係上門既，我就更加以為呢個係上門同琴行既分別 :cry:

另外想順帶一問，琴行收費表係逐級收費既，最初係收初級既學費，今個月開始收我個囡一級既學費，而朋友既上門老師仲未話要加佢價，係咪正常？？

ACAC

Hi Esmond'sMom,

Pls check PM.

ACAC

lycheema

AndyRain

I totally agreed with your comments on our kids' progress.......... 真的無能為力.

Esmond's Mom

Thank you for your analysis, you are an expert in this field, and I am not....

By the way, my daughter has finished:-

John Thompson's  - part one

is learning:-

Rhythm Publishing Co Sdn Bhd - Theory Made Easy
Rhythm Publishing Co Sdn Bhd - Piano Lesson
Rhythm Publishing Co Sdn Bhd - Finger Exercise

Lycheema

AndyRain

Hi, Kubi

唔好客氣啦, 大家都係邊做邊學既亞媽, 梗係要互相照應啦, 我都話我唔識綱琴的, 所以都係俾你參考下咋.  

其實看完你的回覆都覺得你個女既進度係慢左的, 因為我個女每次教3首歌, 咁點計都快d啦, 同埋我又唔覺得亞女練唔切的, 所以我覺得教2-3首歌的進度並不是過份進取及催谷出來的結果.  所以你在練琴時會好得閒的.  最初唔提, 只係唔想影響你, 待esmond"smom專業的確定教為公平.

好或夾的老師真係可遇不可求, 最初亞仔都係係琴行學, 點知遇啱個發夢的老師, 同佢商量過個仔既planning, 之後佢可以問我出年暑假考一級嗎, 我話唔係呀, 上次與你商量時你話可以考2級的.  再無耐, 佢又問.......我頂佢唔住, 所以幫佢轉老師.  唔想再side佢時間, 一年既時間對於一個7歲的小孩來說是佔了他10幾個%, 真係好side的.  你真係要聽下琴行老師講下點解每堂只教一首歌先得啦.  你判佢死刑前都俾個機會佢解釋下, 況且你都應該交晒今個月的學費, 仲有2, 3堂要上, 聽完再諗諗啦.  唔好唔問呀!!!

我個仔係琴行都係升到"學一級"時開始收佢一級的學費.  而而家我地上門的miss就好似係每2個level先加一次學費的.  所以我個仔由開始升一級水平到而家, miss話佢應該有2級(定係學2級)都無話加佢學費, 同我個女而家初學既學費相同.  其實上門的收費好睇個老師點樣定的.  好似補習咁, 無一定的, 每個人都可以唔同.  其實學費都唔係最緊要的(能付膽到便成), 都係你情我願, 明碼實價, 最緊要係個miss好唔好.  遇啱個唔好的, side左個細路d時間先至係最慘呀, 因為有錢都買唔番時間的(我個人覺得啦).  

AndyRain

lycheema

唔緊要啦, 大家既細路都係差唔多, 得閒大家分享下, 我有問題問下你, 你答下我, 咁樣應該可以好d.  唔識都有人share下嘛.

gabrielmum

Esmond'sMom,

多謝回應。
(另外，我原來仔仔而家用緊Alfred's Basic Piano Libray----Alfred's Basic  1B，之前講錯1A)

請問佢之後可以用0羊書呢？可唔可以比d意見呢？THANK  YOU

Esmond'sMom 寫道:
Hi gabrielmum,
Your son is 5 and only learnt for 3 months, so the books he's using right now is ok/normal for his age and level.  Not all teachers use the same set of books or start with the same books.  For the time being, the books he's using should be enough, however, after a couple of months, he should be introduced more series of books other than Alfred's in order to get a better balance.  Just wait and see what the teacher will assign him later.