入到DGJS學生的家庭背景

daudau1111

Totally agreed.

whatever

太好啦,終於有人講返些中肯既說話啦。
YongXin，
十分欣賞你。

唔好神化?間學校.

無錯DGJS係香港最優秀的學校之一, 但一樣有來自唔同家庭背境的學生, 我有個好同事的女都讀緊DGS, 父母都是打工仔, 阿女本身好醒好努力, 父母又關懷; 我覺得應該欣賞這些, 而不是去標籤任何學校或學生.

goodenough

昨晚睇完電視之後，直情愛上了這學校。我並不是神化間學校，不過他的魅力實在太令人神魂癲倒。他竟言可孕育出這麼優秀的人材。

mrswintsang

請問是甚麼節目？我很想一看。可否介紹一下，看有否辦法再看一次？謝謝。 :

YongXin

節目叫"課堂由我創", 昨晚TVB播出, 其實主要是教統局宣傳點樣叫通識教與學.

作為理智的家長, 應該客觀地欣賞學校和家庭, 能夠攜手教出這些精英中的精英. 至於家中書房大過間公屋, 又有金色宮廷椅, 真是與學校無直接關係, 個個學生家中都有金色宮廷椅咩. 始終最寶貴的, 是父母的關懷和學生的實力.

作為理智的電視觀眾, 就當是宣傳片吧! 這些找最好的來宣傳的硬銷技倆, 點樣令人信服你是講緊一般事實的全部呢?

circleda

It's a problem like chicken and egg, can you tell which one come first?

christf 寫道:

Is it really true that the school "可孕育出這麼優秀的人材"  or it can attract "這麼優秀的人材" because of her well-established fame?

Which one is the dominant factor ?, or

What do you think on the relative weighting of these two factors contributing to her final success?

Any views for sharing ?

cwpge1983

"作為理智的電視觀眾, 就當是宣傳片吧! 這些找最好的來宣傳的硬銷技倆, 點樣令人信服你是講緊一般事實的全部呢?"--------這個節目喺講"課堂由我創"主題喺介紹學生點樣由開始探討課題，資料搜集，訪問及辯論而完成一個'課題探討'。DGS 本身就喺名牌，仲需唔需要博宣傳??況且所謂     "家中書房大過間公屋, 又有金色宮廷椅"------  喺DGS裹面祗係普通家庭而矣！見怪不怪!!!唔好用有"錢"眼鏡而用欣賞學校及學生嘅角度嚟睇啦!!

YongXin

唔洗咁敏感, 我所指的宣傳是教統局為通識教育的宣傳, 唔係話DGJS為自己學校宣傳.

教統局為通識教育宣傳, 可以有很多其他更全面的方法, 為甚麼不也同時訪問一些通識都做得好好的新界平實學校呢?

cwpge1983 寫道:
這個節目喺講"課堂由我創"主題喺介紹學生點樣由開始探討課題，資料搜集，訪問及辯論而完成一個'課題探討'。DGS 本身就喺名牌，仲需唔需要博宣傳??

circleda

I do think: 1) Firstly, it's not only the technique/system/mode they used, or some magic wands they have. A important part is their culture,  philosophy and environment. These are not likely to be portable to other school, or taking root with other group of students; 2) These factors are also affected by the intakes so they would like to have the control on selection of students.

christf 寫道:
My interest is to know how much is the school's effort towards the final success of her students.

If all the students of DGJS/DGS were replaced by a group of average students, will the students have significant improvement in their final achievements?

If yes, then how can DGJS/DGS achieve these?

What are the major differences (e.g. experience of teachers, education system, mode and style of teaching, environment and facilities, external linkage and connections, .......) of DGJS/DGS as compared with an average school?  

Anything that an average school can learn from DGJS/DGS in order to enhance the achievements of its students?  

I think this is the most important point that deserved our attention in order to help students of other schools as not many students can be benefited from the "good schooling" offered by DGJS/DGS.

Tigerprawn

Tigerprawn

[quote]
教統局為通識教育宣傳, 可以有很多其他更全面的方法, 為甚麼不也同時訪問一些通識都做得好好的新界平實學校呢?
[quote]

5 more episodes will come

cwpge1983

YongXin:"通識都做得好好的新界平實學校呢", 可否介紹吓所指嘅學校呢，唔該哂!

YongXin

如果我有能力作出介紹, 睇怕都做咗教統局的天才高官了. 我針對的是教統局宣傳通識的手法, 不是針對任何學校或學生. 出面自由廣場都有更激的言論, 討論教統局的低能宣傳手法.

也請各位睇清楚我一直在這版的留言, 運用一下理解能力, 睇清楚前文後理, 不要段章取義, 切開一句半句來咬住我唔放.

我是絕對認同DGJS的成就, 更加認同家長和學生的努力, 請不要標籤我是一個反名校, 憎人富貴的八婆.

"唔好神化咗間學校.

無錯DGJS係香港最優秀的學校, 但一樣有來自唔同家庭背境的學生, 我有個好同事的女都讀緊DGS, 父母都是打工仔, 阿女本身好醒好努力, 父母又關懷; 我覺得應該欣賞這些, 而不是去標籤任何學校或學生."

”太好啦,終於有人講返些中肯既說話啦。
YongXin，
十分欣賞你。”

"作為理智的家長, 應該客觀地欣賞學校和家庭, 能夠攜手教出這些精英中的精英. 至於家中書房大過間公屋, 又有金色宮廷椅, 真是與學校無直接關係, 個個學生家中都有金色宮廷椅咩. 始終最寶貴的, 是父母的關懷和學生的實力."

cwpge1983 寫道:
YongXin:"通識都做得好好的新界平實學校呢", 可否介紹吓所指嘅學校呢，唔該哂!

cwpge1983

嘩!!唔洗咁大反應嘛？我見妳Quote  :  ""教統局為通識教育宣傳, 可以有很多其他更全面的方法, 為甚麼不也同時訪問一些通識都做得好好的新界平實學校呢?""  我見妳特別mention  "通識都做得好好的新界平實學校"  以為有好介紹,便順路請教吓以作參考啫!!再者，連妳閣下都覺得好難找到合適中學介紹，教统局咪借所謂嘅名校嚟推廣囉!!!

ohnono

我都係覺得教統局差。其實香港咁多學校，駛乜搵間最勁既學校呀。搵間勁勁地既咪得囉，應該好多學校都有英文辦論比賽啦。重有喎佢地重好刻意揀兩個隊長的家庭背景(指裝修，其它就唔知，斷估都唔會差)都好好的來做介紹。其他D成員可能無錢裝修間屋，咁就無得介紹。比人覺得佢地好hard sell囉，係sell呢兩個女同學，跟住sell埋間學校，好似唔係sell佢地的通識科。有小小喧賓奪主。

FUNG12345

其實名校都唔係個個有錢o既, 只係比例高姐
我識有d dg都唔係住大屋, 揸benz
好多dg返學都係搭巴士, 地鐵

我覺得搵兩個屋企大得嚇人o既學生出黎, 都冇乜問題呀
我唔信一個住細屋o既dg學生會想比人上佢屋企做訪問
同埋, 我聽人講, 果兩個主角都好多條a