讀女校係唔係唔好?

G-Ma

我身邊大部份讀女校的朋友都未結婚, 對感情事更是無所適從, 特別是我妹妹也是讀女校, 她的要好同學朋友中只有一個是結了婚.  有時我發現她們對異性要求很高, 總是在細微事上有很多不滿, 幾次都是這樣分開了.  雖然說日常生活中仍是有機會接觸到異性朋友, 但在求學時期留在學校的時間是最長的, 所以我覺得好重要.  

當然以上純粹個人經歷, 不是說所有讀女校的就一定嫁不出, 只是我作為母親在我選校時我會選男女校, 感覺較全面.

jk67jk

G-Ma 寫道:
我身邊大部份讀女校的朋友都未結婚, 對感情事更是無所適從

..... 但我有很多女性朋友, 小學與中學都是讀"男女校", 也是未嫁喎！    睇怕, 到哩個年紀都唔嫁, 已經係唔嫁囉~~~    所以, 同學校冇關！ 哈哈！

ChiChiPaPa

US Department of Education
Single-Sex Versus Coeducation Schooling: A Systematic Review

www.ed.gov/rschstat/eval/other/single-sex/index.html

Highlights of conclusions:

1. In general, most studies reported positive effects for Single-Sex (SS) schools on all-subject achievement tests.

2. Co-Ed (CE) schooling only had a positive impact on the self-esteem of males.

3. SS students showing more interest in and taking more difficult courses. Students at coed schools tended to have gender-typical subject preferences. For example, girls at girls-only schools were more interested in math and science than were girls at coed schools.

4. SS schools fostered higher educational and career aspirations for girls.

5. SS schooling could be associated with a number of post-high school, long-term positive outcomes, including postsecondary success, reduced unemployment (males and females), reduced propensity to drop out of high school (males and females), the choice of a nontraditional college major (for females), and political activism (for females).

6. SS schooling could be associated with only a few negative outcomes, e.g. eating disorders.

mothershares

Chichipapa,
Thank you so much for posting the useful report. I wonder whether there're any similar reports written for HK students????     

babyhowie

其實中小學係米讀齋校有嘜所謂？大學都會男女同校架啦！

遲

ChiChiPaPa

mothershares 寫道:
Chichipapa,
Thank you so much for posting the useful report. I wonder whether there're any similar reports written for HK students????     

Wong, K.C., Lam, Y.R. and Ho, L.M. (2002) The Effects of Schooling on Gender Differences. British Educational Research Journal 28(6): 827-843
  
www.agsa.org.au/gender/gender03.doc

This study report results from a longitudinal study of Hong Kong students (over 45,000) who undertook public examinations in 1997. When initial ability was controlled, multi-level analysis revealed that school type did impact upon gender differences in achievement. Girls studying in single-sex environments had higher attainment levels than their co-educated peers. Boys, however, achieved more within co-educational contexts. Methodological considerations involved in the study of gender differences are also discussed.

longfung

我中學時女校, 同學感情很好校風亦很好, 畢業超過廿年都有聚會.至於兩性關係, 很多同學都一樣在高班時開始拍拖, 都不知多投入!!!
何況今時今日的學生活動多多, 接觸其他人的機會多的是, 要出問題多數是本身的問題而不是齋校的問題!!

mothershares

//Wong, K.C., Lam, Y.R. and Ho, L.M. (2002) The Effects of Schooling on Gender Differences. British Educational Research Journal 28(6): 827-843

www.agsa.org.au/gender/gender03.doc
//

Many thanks again    

ZZdaphne

6. SS schooling could be associated with only a few negative outcomes, e.g. eating disorders

ChiChiPaPa

好好奇？點解會eating disorders，有冇解釋呢？我ah 女！P. 5，有考慮升中入女校，男女校班房秩序會disorder。
Thanks！

ChiChiPaPa

ZZdaphne 寫道:
6. SS schooling could be associated with only a few negative outcomes, e.g. eating disorders

ChiChiPaPa

好好奇？點解會eating disorders，有冇解釋呢？我ah 女！P. 5，有考慮升中入女校，男女校班房秩序會disorder。
Thanks！

Mensinger (2001) in comparing SS versus CE schools (high school, private, Australian, n = 142), found significant differences for females on eating disorders as measured by scores on a truncated version of the Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI), with higher scores for SS students (F(1,138), =14.623, p= .000). SS students were more likely to develop an eating disorder than CE students.

Eating disorders can be defined as syndromes where individuals develop an unhealthy view of their body and low self-esteem. This leads them to attempt to alter that body image by excessive weight change and through unhealthy means. Mensinger (2001)  examined the likelihood of developing an eating disorder. Eating disorders occur predominantly in females and, as such, no results are reported for males. This study reported results favoring coeducation for high school females and measured eating disorders during high school.

For more detailed explanation of the possible causes, please refer to the following link:

Sex Composition and Eating Disorders (Please click)

Other than the above article, there are other researches of similar topics:

http://www.singlesexschools.org/eatingdisorders.htm

[Please note that singlesexschools.org is held by NASSPE which is an organization promoting single-sex education. Therefore it may not provide a balanced view between single-sex and coed schooling, but the site contains much useful information on this topic.]

bighug

agree

longfung 寫道:
我中學時女校, 同學感情很好校風亦很好, 畢業超過廿年都有聚會.至於兩性關係, 很多同學都一樣在高班時開始拍拖, 都不知多投入!!!
何況今時今日的學生活動多多, 接觸其他人的機會多的是, 要出問題多數是本身的問題而不是齋校的問題!!