點樣可以知道鋼琴老師架資歷?

chichingmama

我想問吓各位可否要求個老師比張證書我睇, 他們會否唔高興. 我只係覺得公司請人都要睇張cert. 我比咁多$請你(可能好長時間)冇可能唔睇得, 我有問過一啲琴行, 只係口頭話他們有8級, 但就冇證書睇, 所以我就唔學.

另外想請教對於五洲琴行有何評價???

thanks

bbqueen

ming2 寫道:
bbqueen

$800/45min/4堂,我覺得起碼都有八級或以上加上超過五年0既經驗啦

你囡囡係咪四五歲左右呀??如果真係坐唔定,咁點解要學45min咁長呀??半小時都夠啦..加上佢只係用一本書,45min會好悶架喎?!...講真個句,咁悶俾我都坐唔定咁長時間啦...

如果你話囡囡係二月開始學,45min一堂,重要一開始只係教teaching little fingers (重要係跳黎教),跟住就學first grade個本,重要只係學左幾首...咁囡囡都唔係彈左好多歌咋喎?!....如果每堂都係學45min,講真個句,我唔覺咁樣教得唔算快呀...不過最緊要係囡囡識唔識睇音,數拍子,同埋手型好唔好咋..基初最...

Actually, I neve seen her grade 8 certificate but I believed she is qualifed to teach.  She got some kinds of teaching cert.  Some of her students also got good result in the music festival.  From my observation during the class, 係睇音,數拍子,同埋手型, Miss 都跟足 ge......

My daughter likes do some colouring( 認notes)....  so you can imagine 30 mins is not  enough for her ar..... so her Miss said she need to attend 45 mins class wor!  But what she learnt is not 成正比!!!

Smiile

ming2,

Hi, 您個小德德都好可愛wor ! 不經不覺兩個小朋友返學，您真係會free好多架 !

希望迦迦會有一個愉快的學習開始啦 !

Smiile

bbqueen

ming2

I think the teacher let her do some colouring because she will not be so bored at the begininng.  However, my daughter seems get used to do this on every lesson.  Of course, I don't like la.    Sometimes, they do the theory exercise during the class.  Do you think it's necessary?  Actually, I prefer to spend the time to teach more new songs ar.......

chichingmama

ming2:

謝謝你的回答.    

bbqueen

ming2 寫道:
bbqueen

我自己教左咁多年,都教過唔少小朋友,我都明白有時係要用呢類coloring0既練習去提起小朋友0既學習興趣,不過我唔鐘意小朋友係堂用完成全個練習,因為咁樣真係好晒時間,(家長亦好晒錢....ha..ha..因為私人跟我學0既學費真係唔平嘛...)不如用多d時間去教小朋友彈多些歌仲好...不過當然要小朋友係屋時肯練琴先得啦...否則教得多歌時佢又唔練琴,咁都係冇用...

我個人覺得thoery exercise,只要係堂上教識小朋友,最多俾佢地試做一兩條,佢地知道點做,其他返屋企慢慢做已經足夠....除非個小朋友係屋企真係唔識做(或者係懶做),咁就會係堂上做多少少,等佢掌握到先再返屋企做...我個人認為無須次次都係堂上做晒d練習...

ming2

I will talk to Miss this coming lesson. Thanks!

Pls check pm!

bbqueen

ming2 寫道:
bbqueen

收唔到你pm喎?!

ming2

Pls check pm again.  

kcarol

bbqueen
colouring 對幼兒係好好既method, 不過.. 堂堂係甘.. 會唔會誇張少少呢!?!?
miss 可以start 左個頭, 慢慢就要放手, 等小朋友自己黎, 堂堂都用晒去填色, 不如你自己買本番黎同小朋友填色好過

bbqueen

kcarol

初學琴ge 小朋友係唔係都會做吓colouring, 等佢地唔會咁悶?  通常45 mins 會教多首歌? 用幾多本書?

sally1

ming 2
我想下...我個小朋友都學琴學左成年...miss話佢彈得比較慢...d音唔係好熟....佢用左另一本琴書教佢....但我覺得好奇怪本來教佢係用英文字(如CDEFG & CBAGF)來記住d音...而加就用本書上有12345的手拍位來教.
另本來1個星期一堂.....miss又要求1個星期2堂.....上左2星期....但又唔見小朋友有咩進步....我是否要轉miss呢?

加菲貓

我都覺得好平, 所以想肯定佢係唔係演奏級, 佢係全職上門教琴, 這星期將會上第一堂,  試過先知.

hhma 寫道:
唔知合唔合理
但肯定係好平[quote]
加菲貓 寫道:
WAIMAQQ,

謝謝你! 佢收$180/45min 5級, 上門, 合理嗎?

[/quote]

kcarol

bbqueen
講真果句, 我都要我d學生做coloring, 不過.... 番屋企做啦, 頭一兩次, 會spend 多d時間, make sure 個學生識, 但之後上堂講左、教左, 同佢go through 一兩條, 佢可以跟到, 就要佢自己番屋企做架啦, 唔係既話, 多多時間都唔夠, 特別係小朋友, 拎起支顏色筆, 好多時就唔捨得放手

其實甘細個小朋友, 係唔係真係可以坐定定45min?? 如果佢得30min 坐定定, 之後15min 係好sleepy 既話, 我覺得係waste of time & money。同埋我好concern 呢45min 係唔係好有效率甘運用。

好難一概而論45min 可以彈幾多歌, 要睇小朋友架, 我有d學生, 好醒目, 又有練琴, 睇譜又快, 一堂彈4-5本書都ok, 但有d慢吞吞, 叫佢擺好隻手都好似d維園阿伯甘 , 呢d小朋友一堂彈到4本書我都笑呵呵     

kcarol

sally1
唔好介意我加把口
你miss 會唔會係試緊用另一個方法/system去教你個小朋友, 睇下佢用第2個system 會唔會快d上手呢??? 呢個純粹我推測
加堂開始左幾耐呀??