全港最高%分派到Band 1 的中學是那一家小學?

Xanthe

出年小學的banding都係靠今年小六学生考的編班試來分。而過往則是靠前5年學校的學能測驗來分。

健朗媽咪

SandyKL 寫道:
[quote]

以我所知，屯門真係有間中學，正如健朗媽咪話齋，近年真係100%升大學，佢地收生方面冇25分唔收讀預科，有朋友個姪仔24分都入唔到!

我贊成banding係以同區比較，但睇番中五會考及中七預科公開試，新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋，大家唔好再迷信勒!

唔知你講果間係唔係我講果間, 預科100%入u果間預科要收會考26分或以上,而且無位收外來生, 另外會考ab全屯門元朗最高果間同啱啱出高考狀元果間就唔知要幾多分先收

andrew

以我所知，屯門真係有間中學，正如健朗媽咪話齋，近年真係100%升大學，佢地收生方面冇25分唔收讀預科，有朋友個姪仔24分都入唔到!
我贊成banding係以同區比較，但睇番中五會考及中七預科公開試，新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋，大家唔好再迷信勒!

How many as such high quality schools are in that district, how many students are there in the district and how many get the very good result? How can we just give one example to prove that新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋.

To compare which district is better, the simple method is to compare how many EMI schools are there in the district, more EMI school indicates the higher standard of the district.

健朗媽咪

andrew 寫道:
[quote]以我所知，屯門真係有間中學，正如健朗媽咪話齋，近年真係100%升大學，佢地收生方面冇25分唔收讀預科，有朋友個姪仔24分都入唔到!
我贊成banding係以同區比較，但睇番中五會考及中七預科公開試，新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋，大家唔好再迷信勒!

How many as such high quality schools are in that district, how many students are there in the district and how many get the very good result? How can we just give one example to prove that新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋.

To compare which district is better, the simple method is to compare how many EMI schools are there in the district, more EMI school indicates the higher standard of the district.

[/quote]

其實屯門有7間英中, 7間成績都好好, 有一間預科係100%入u, 另外都有90%以上, 有三間出過會考10a生, 有一間近年總共出咗4位10a, 一間高考今年出5a, 7間高考有3a以上的學生夾埋都唔少,所以唔係淨係得一間la同出名學校比,

同埋係同出面同級數的傳統名校比, 係真唔差得幾遠喎, 同埋每個區都有好及唔好的學校, 無理由出面間間都係好學校, 間間都係band1, 其實我地只不過係為之前有人發表"屯門學生同傳統名校學生比會比下去"覺得咁講唔公平, 唔係話市區的名校同學生唔好, 同埋大家唔需要太過強求出名的傳統名校位, 如果成績好, 就讀名校或地區名校都會好, 而且近年地區名校都有好好成績, 仲唔駛去咁遠tim

SandyKL

健朗媽咪 寫道:
[quote]
SandyKL 寫道:
[quote]

以我所知，屯門真係有間中學，正如健朗媽咪話齋，近年真係100%升大學，佢地收生方面冇25分唔收讀預科，有朋友個姪仔24分都入唔到!

我贊成banding係以同區比較，但睇番中五會考及中七預科公開試，新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋，大家唔好再迷信勒!

唔知你講果間係唔係我講果間, 預科100%入u果間預科要收會考26分或以上,而且無位收外來生, 另外會考ab全屯門元朗最高果間同

SandyKL

andrew 寫道:
[quote]以我所知，屯門真係有間中學，正如健朗媽咪話齋，近年真係100%升大學，佢地收生方面冇25分唔收讀預科，有朋友個姪仔24分都入唔到!
我贊成banding係以同區比較，但睇番中五會考及中七預科公開試，新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋，大家唔好再迷信勒!

How many as such high quality schools are in that district, how many students are there in the district and how many get the very good result? How can we just give one example to prove that新界地區果d學校真係同市區傳統名校差唔得幾遠架咋.

To compare which district is better, the simple method is to compare how many EMI schools are there in the district, more EMI school indicates the higher standard of the district.

[/quote]

給予保留英中，係唔係就係高程度既學校，見仁見智，舉個例:柴灣慈幼中學，係該區係band 1中學，而且受到家長歡迎，但被迫轉中中，難道佢程度唔夠??仲有理個教統局怪怪變法，已經係1998年既事，事隔8年人事已幾番新，教育、學校都係一樣。

算勒，我唔想忿開討論英中=高程度學校?雖然一般家長心目中確如是。

健朗媽咪

[quote]

唔知你講果間係唔係我講果間, 預科100%入u果間預科要收會考26分或以上,而且無位收外來生, 另外會考ab全屯門元朗最高果間同

SandyKL

[quote]
健朗媽咪 寫道:
[quote]

唔知你講果間係唔係我講果間, 預科100%入u果間預科要收會考26分或以上,而且無位收外來生, 另外會考ab全屯門元朗最高果間同

cczzko

健朗媽咪 寫道:

保記大興嗰間呀

應該係! 佢

SandyKL

[quote]
stccmc 寫道:
//
仲有理個教統局怪怪變法，已經係1998年既事，事隔8年人事已幾番新，教育、學校都係一樣。
//

傳統名校之名, 全因為"經得起時間考驗"。  每間都一百幾十年歷史, 作育無數英才。  8年?  濕濕碎。  如果傳統名校的 8 年都信唔過, 那麼入到你口中

SandyKL

[quote]
stccmc 寫道:
//
stccmc，你真係一個傳統名校擁護者中既表表者，好敏感!
//

唔係呀, 之不過我呃唔到自己

LLT

I think the proper way in the assessment of a secondary school's peformance is to see the ratio of its students obtaining Grade A in the HKCEE, i.e., the total number of Grade A obtained divided by the number of students in that year who sit the examination.

The result can be distorted if we only concentrate our attention to the number of students who get 10 A in any particular year.  It cannot be regarded as an outstanding school if it has three 10 A students but the total number of A obtained was only 30.  Of course, this example is an extreme case only given for the sake of discussion, which is unlikely to happy in the real world.

I would further supplement that just looking at the successful rate of its students' entering unversities may not be able to appraise the overall peformance of the school accurately.  Please note in this connection that those students who are admitted into its Form 6 are already the chosen one, who get good result in the HKCEE.

健朗媽咪

LLT 寫道:
I think the proper way in the assessment of a secondary school's peformance is to see the ratio of its students obtaining Grade A in the HKCEE, i.e., the total number of Grade A obtained divided by the number of students in that year who sit the examination.

The result can be distorted if we only concentrate our attention to the number of students who get 10 A in any particular year.  It cannot be regarded as an outstanding school if it has three 10 A students but the total number of A obtained was only 30.  Of course, this example is an extreme case only given for the sake of discussion, which is unlikely to happy in the real world.

I would further supplement that just looking at the successful rate of its students' entering unversities may not be able to appraise the overall peformance of the school accurately.  Please note in this connection that those students who are admitted into its Form 6 are already the chosen one, who get good result in the HKCEE.

不如你有時間去下d區校的網頁, 佢地好多都有齊數據(會考優良, 尖子數目......)比你, 你咪可以清楚了解下區校而家的級數去到邊囉

LLT

健朗媽咪:

Thank you for your advice.  I will certainly do so by the time when my son is about to go to the secondary school.

健朗媽咪

LLT 寫道:
The result can be distorted if we only concentrate our attention to the number of students who get 10 A in any particular year.  It cannot be regarded as an outstanding school if it has three 10 A students but the total number of A obtained was only 30.  Of course, this example is an extreme case only given for the sake of discussion, which is unlikely to happy in the real world.

我都想知邊間學校同一年出3個10a個全校會考只有30a喎!
你講la聴下, 等我地大家都知下

就算屯門梁球琚, 係屯門出最多10a生, 但佢地上年只係有一個9a生, 但都有8佰幾優良喎, 所以我都想知道下邊間喎

eddie503

健朗媽咪 寫道:
[quote]
eddie503 寫道:
講時講, band 1 比率高低是跟同區學校比較來做決定; 地區名校分得多band 1 比率, 因為其他校太差; 如果那家屯門名校搬去傳統名校區, 一定比下去....

咁又唔係喎, 屯門而家有幾間band 1英中學都好好成績, 呢幾年都有出會考十優生, 今年仲有間出咗個5a高考狀元,同埋預科有100%升大學,其實唔只屯門, 其他區都有呢d學校,  所以而家地區名校成績同傳統名校比大家實力相近[/quote]


吾好意思, 答錯咀..解錯了題目..我仲以為講緊那一家小學多band one多? 所以同妳所講那間中學.......5a高考狀元,100%升大學.....吾同. 如果係講中學, 因為會考係全港性, 我就認同妳所講.

健朗媽咪

eddie503 寫道:

如果那家屯門名校,搬去傳統名校區, 一定比下去


吾好意思, 答錯咀..解錯了題目..我仲以為講緊那一家小學多band one多? 所以同妳所講那間中學.......5a高考狀元,100%升大學.....吾同. 如果係講中學, 因為會考係全港性, 我就認同妳所講.

咁果幾間中學的學生咪都係由同區小學升上嚟,唔似其他傳統名校咁d學生區區都有(因為好多人跨區報考),  所以同區小學都唔差, 同埋一間小學的banding,唔係學校或學生自己亂嗡, 係由教局評定,有一定法則嚟評定, 係有公信力, 所以我覺得都唔存在屯門或其他地區被評定為band1學生一定會比九龍band1生比下去

同埋地區小學就算小朋友成績唔理想, 都唔會放棄個學生或要佢轉校, 反而會加強補底,會照顧有差距的學生, 希望令學生成績進步, 相反名校會汰弱留強, 淨係留返好的學生, 成績唔好的就要轉校(我有個客佢小朋友每科8x分, 學校都話佢唔適合佢地, 要佢考慮轉校, 每年尾五名都要走),再空出位置比成績好的轉校生,  咁的學校band 1生多d都好正常,

fannychoi

請問是不是梁球琚中學?
tuen mun 官立中學又點?
請問你地覺得tuen mun d 中學勁D 定元朗趙x修中學, 廠商會中學勁d 呢?
可否給我tuen mun 元朗d 勁中學排名呢?