"公民式"數學好定係"學林"數學好?

carollam310

carollam310

carollam310

carollam310

Bowiema
學林數係咪即係奧數呀 定係差唔多 邊度有學林數學呀 呢度睇唔到各區地址http://www.selin.com.hk/

mercury16

公文式我個女(k3)學咗差不多九個月,剛剛升3a,每日做10張paper,時間用咗５至10分鐘,學公文好處係做功課會真係快咗字體整齊,同鍛練耐性,專心,自學自習,但我覺得進度俾較慢,升級要成半年,學校學緊＋–數公文都未學,唔知係咪我間教室慢呢?有冇其他媽咪可以分享吓呢?

Bowiema

carollam310,

學林唔同奧數ga.....奧數係著重思維, 唔係跟學校課程既. 佢地無post到centre既地址, 你可以打去問下, 邊間近你屋企.  

Gordon_No_4

My daughter has learned Selin when she was in Primary 1. (She is now in Primary 2) What I observe is, Selin cannot improve her speed of computation.

Weeks ago I attended a parents talk on Kumon. My impression is Kumon is more organized and structured than Selin.  Many a time, I spotted the mistakes in my daughter's Selin worksheets. Probably, Kumon has been in the market longer than Selin and their worksheets have improved a lot.

There is no way to excel the academic year in Selin. That is, if you are studying P2, you will always be working on P2 worksheets. However, there is way to advance in Kumon. That is, if you are studying P2, you may work on P3 or even higher grades worksheets depending on your self ability.

Moreover, the teachers of Kumon are more well-trained than Selin. Kumon is a system imported from Japan and Japan is very famous of quality system. As far as I observe in the Kumon Parents talk, the Kumon teachers must register and train in Kumon way. So, you can expect consistency of teaching quality among different teachers. However, it cannot be found in Selin. My daugher's Selin teacher employs a lot of secondary or university students as part-time teachers to teach on behalf of her.  Of course, such part-time teachers have not been trained at all. This cast my worries on the teaching quality.

I have just enrolled my son, who is K2, to Kumon. I cannot see the results yet. But seems that he is attracted by the colourful Kumon worksheets. I have intention to change my daughter to Kumon this summer. My daughter's problem is not on problem solving. Her problem is on computation speed. No harm to make a change, I think.

One point I oberve about Kumon is students have to start at a level lower than his/her present capability. Probably, 3 - 6 months have to spent before he/she can learn what it is learned at school presently. But, this is a feature of Kumon. If desires to take Kumon, have to follow it.

Ivy124

聽你咁講...學林又好似幾o岩我囝囝...唔該晒

[quote]
Bowiema 寫道:
Ivy124,

小一開始學ok la, 我大仔都係小二先開始學. 其實佢數學唔係太差, 只係錯d唔小心, 心諗, 比佢去try下, 點知, 真係效果幾好, 唔小心改善

Ivy124

佢要點樣先比你升level?

[quote]
mercury16 寫道:
公文式我個女(k3)學

carcar123

咁請問奧數同Selin和Kumon又有何分別呀?

睡覺

個人鍾意學林多d...因為真正懂數學唔係要計算計得快嘛，到左高年班，只係識公式，單係計得快唔係咁惦架。

不過我全部坊間的數學課程都無比阿仔學，但就買左d學林數學的練習、奧數及數學好玩俾阿仔，有時叫佢自己做，唔識問我，有時會同佢一起解疑難，我好少叫佢不停操練計"死"數。

我覺坊間買的學林補充練習已不錯，唔係話好難，可以自己教返。 :wink: 你試下去書局逛逛睇下啦﹗你跟佢一起做，單對單上課也不錯哦﹗

hermanpapa

好耐冇見，係邊個topic泡？我近來在小學區威，亞仔小一嘛！

睡覺 寫道:
個人鍾意學林多d...因為真正懂數學唔係要計算計得快嘛，到左高年班，只係識公式，單係計得快唔係咁惦架。

不過我全部坊間的數學課程都無比阿仔學，但就買左d學林數學的練習、奧數及數學好玩俾阿仔，有時叫佢自己做，唔識問我，有時會同佢一起解疑難，我好少叫佢不停操練計"死"數。

我覺坊間買的學林補充練習已不錯，唔係話好難，可以自己教返。 :wink: 你試下去書局逛逛睇下啦﹗你跟佢一起做，單對單上課也不錯哦﹗

Leolonglongma

Ivy,

我的小朋友由k2學了一年多公文, 但經與老公商量, 決定停了它. 他們大概3-4個月完成一個level, 上堂評核, 未能在指定時間內完成的話, 整個level, 重新再做一次, (係做一次, 唔係學一次, 因為其實上堂都係小朋友用半小時做家課, 好少會問老師), 問題是我們在家, 每次都可以在指定時間內100%全對的做好家課, 但上堂評核, 因身邊有其他小朋友說話, 影響了他, 未能在指定時間內完成, 便要重新再做, 小朋友覺得悶, 家長會覺得浪費金錢, 而且重覆了3 次, 我們有跟老師反映, 希望佢參考功課時間, 讓他升班, 但老師拒絕.  我們覺得繼續下去, 不見得會對小朋友有利, 而且他們彈性不足. 所以決定斬纜.  而且我家姐的兒子學了3-4年公文數, 初期成績好像突飛猛進 (因為要不停操練), 但到了5年級, 因實在每天要不停的做太多paper, 最後小朋友由積極變成逃避, 不斷欠交. 所以是否參加公文數, 家長真的要三思.  初期可能你會覺得小朋友成績躍進, 但慢慢你會發要死做的副作用....

pigchu

Leolonglongma所說的和我小朋友都係一樣, 當初係好明顯有進步的, 不過我覺得呢個進步係我地做父母所付出的, 因為他在公文只係做一本(因是派回一本回家的), 其餘會派六本比我們, 而回家就要自己做, 仲係不停重覆咁做同一樣野(小朋友都覺悶), 我覺得咁既話我自己在家都可以print比佢做啦, 我之後都轉了學林, 因為我唔希望佢只係不停做而識得做, 而當條question唔同出法時佢就唔識, 因學林係幫佢解釋及分析題目的, 在初學時係唔會覺得明顯好左, 但學多1個月度..明顯小朋友係學識睇題目而去做, 而家我小朋友做學校功課都係睇題目先做, 而佢係好唔like返公文..但到依家(1年度)佢都好like返學林, 而且當佢學校有test時, 可以同佢地說唔要取功課(公文就一定要取..唔會體諒..even請sick leave都係), 而校長又時常叫人再報其他科....好煩..又叫學生一定要準時入錢交學費..   

睡覺

睡覺

睡覺

hermanpapa,,
      HAHA ..好耐無見...
      我近來在BK四處亂竄......又黎惹事生非咁...



你阿仔派位好嗎？定係讀直資或私小？.....

我阿仔今年都係讀小一..我真係好興奮.....生左LI個玩具俾我玩，雖然激氣，但也很好玩，很刺激也，因為好似係我自己升小學咁....好新鮮...﹗

小學萬歲﹗       

hermanpapa 寫道:
好耐冇見，係邊個topic泡？我近來在小學區威，亞仔小一嘛！[quote]
睡覺 寫道:
個人鍾意學林多d...因為真正懂數學唔係要計算計得快嘛，到左高年班，只係識公式，單係計得快唔係咁惦架。

不過我全部坊間的數學課程都無比阿仔學，但就買左d學林數學的練習、奧數及數學好玩俾阿仔，有時叫佢自己做，唔識問我，有時會同佢一起解疑難，我好少叫佢不停操練計"死"數。

我覺坊間買的學林補充練習已不錯，唔係話好難，可以自己教返。 :wink: 你試下去書局逛逛睇下啦﹗你跟佢一起做，單對單上課也不錯哦﹗

[/quote]

wewangwang

請問各位學林數的center怎樣環境,我家附近(藍田)的一間只有細細百零呎的一個單位,沒有間房,只擺了幾張檯,可以想像如Saturday 時間坐了幾組人是會很吵,感覺很不好,還有D老師直覺上好似冇乜quality control 咁.

我想問有冇人試過將軍奧的center,有冇好老師介紹

HuiTung

Agree with most of the mums - NO MORE KUMON!            

carollam310

我都去藍田果間睇過...感覺不太好...唔知D老師教得好唔好呢