Wah Yan or St Joseph?

chelsea

I fully agreed and support what 麟媽媽 have stated, we as a "arent" also need to do some homework or background checking before you advice or comment, otherwise on a no fact basis, one will fall into a bias opinion.

Chelsea

LilyMaMa

華仁or聖若瑟兩間都係好學校，只係各有所好啫。
以客觀來睇，華仁小學位雖少，但小朋友無咁大壓力、無太多不必要的競爭，學校人情味較濃，而且對升中來說，耶穌會大把學位，絕對有能力搞掂全部自己的小學生，直屬或變唔變一條龍根本無大分別，華仁的學位比起其他名校：如la Salle(驚)貴得多，而且華仁亦會重建。
聖若瑟學位比較多，但亦現實得多，學校對學生有一定的高要求，無論小學生、家長、升中.....壓力大得多，兩間中學都係超級band1英中，梗係揾間無咁大壓力嘅來讀，只在乎能否入去讀到。

GreyParrot

fannycheungmc 寫道:
good method is join sjc primary then jump to wah yan sec if sjc secondary do not accept.

呢個係絕對冇可能的事。  因為如果小朋友是聖若瑟小學band 1 生已經直入聖若瑟書院；  如果唔係band 1生，自己中學都唔收，華仁中學(以及其他band 1中學)又點會收呀？     

fannycheungmc

miss lunn ma mi,

you played with words very well. the final conclusion form your advice is that there is no gurantee wah yan second will take wah yan primary like in the past because of the new 75% requirement. i checked and found out that you made analyse in a thread in the pastand you quoted figures and said wah yan has lesser chance now days and even worse than st jo situation. but you wah yan parents all suddenly kept silent and met with wah yan school to protest in the dark, not to make angry wah school managemnet, i know from som wah yan parents. Now you tried to play down the situation. the real fact is wah yan will not promise to take back all not up to english standard of wah yan primary boys. i clearly remember the percentage you showed us to support wah yan situation is worse than st jo.

you NEED to be honest, lunn ma mi.

麟媽媽 寫道:
都唔知邊個naive?!
如果要清楚了解，多D搵資料，
係度亂”up”只會比人笑！
早排你話華仁斷龍已是一大笑話，
而家佢地只是直屬關係，何來斷龍！？
如果因為新語言政策，即結龍學校要75%達標，
所以大把傳統名校hold 住喇，又點只華仁？
仲有早兩日都有人post 過又有新改動，
我唔係度講喇，你自己有心就去搵喇！
咁如果學校唔結龍，咁便要終止直屬關係，
你口口聲聲話華中唔收華小生，
無錯吖，如果唔結龍當然無直屬額喇，
但又唔止華仁有呢個問題喎…. 何況無一間學校表態喎。
St. Jo、喇唦、St. Stephan’s Girls、協恩….
間間都有脫鈎既機會。
咁你又點知St. Jo 穩陣可以直升呢？
家長要多D認知，亦要幫助孩子，
一齊努力，好多沒直屬中學既小學，
D學生都自強，打做出好成績，
唔使靠直屬學額考進一級名校。
如果有一日華小真的跟華中脫鈎，
只要努力，機會同其他官小一樣，
邊個掂，咪邊個考到囉！

唉….都唔知點解同你講咁多…
直情”塞”錢入你袋呀！


[quote]
fannycheungmc 寫道:
don't be naive, if school (wah yan) tell you that no more direct intake, you parents will march on the streets, look at ST Mark after they said they dis-link with primary, look at the reactions of the parents. Actually, in a latest news report , wah yan refused to disclose their plan.
I will not consider wah yan anymore. That is my choice. Play safe now than regret later after join wah yan.

[/quote]

Sindy

fannycheungmc 寫道:
the real fact is wah yan will not promise to take back all not up to english standard of wah yan primary boys

係邊度都係唔up to standard係唔收返架啦．．．．特別指華仁似乎小題大做ｄ．．．．．st joe更加唔會收啦．．．點解你又唔特別話st joe呢？唔通st joe會收返band 3生咩．．．唔好話band3，band2都要聽天由命呀．．．

mission

At present St Joseph's college only admit 60% from its primary school. The percentage is low (if not the lowest).

  

麟媽媽

你唔好亂咁"up"。
你講我以往post 既，
大姐，個D係新既直屬額呀！
減呢個學額，全部直屬中小學一樣架！
點樣St. Jo 情況好過華仁呀？！
關咩75% 事呀？呢個75%係新既升中語言機制呀！
兩樣野都完全唔同，你話你搵我D舊post，
最好你再 copy 之後係度post，
我都唔使晒氣同你解釋！
我最怕D 人唔知，自己又唔用心搵資料又亂咁"up"，
我無辦法同你溝通到，完全唔夾channel！

你去報St. Jo 喇，
keep住全級三百幾人考頭70-80 名，
即全班約頭10名，應該可以直升架喇。





[quote]
fannycheungmc 寫道:
miss lunn ma mi,

you played with words very well. the final conclusion form your advice is that there is no gurantee wah yan second will take wah yan primary like in the past because of the new 75% requirement. i checked and found out that you made analyse in a thread in the pastand you quoted figures and said wah yan has lesser chance now days and even worse than st jo situation. but you wah yan parents all suddenly kept silent and met with wah yan school to protest in the dark, not to make angry wah school managemnet, i know from som wah yan parents. Now you tried to play down the situation. the real fact is wah yan will not promise to take back all not up to english standard of wah yan primary boys. i clearly remember the percentage you showed us to support wah yan situation is worse than st jo.

you NEED to be honest, lunn ma mi.

[quote]

leeleelumlum

[quote]
麟媽媽 寫道:
你唔好亂咁"up"。
你講我以往post 既，
大姐，個D係新既直屬額呀！
減呢個學額，全部直屬中小學一樣架！
點樣St. Jo 情況好過華仁呀？！
關咩75% 事呀？呢個75%係新既升中語言機制呀！
兩樣野都完全唔同，你話你搵我D舊post，
最好你再 copy 之後係度post，
我都唔使晒氣同你解釋！
我最怕D 人唔知，自己又唔用心搵資料又亂咁"up"，
我無辦法同你溝通到，完全唔夾channel！

你去報St. Jo 喇，
keep住全級三百幾人考頭70-80 名，
即全班約頭10名，應該可以直升架喇。


我係街外人, 睇啲stat, 都知麟媽媽上述嘅係'堅'喇...
好心你喇

麟媽媽

其實有幾多分去報機會大呢？
係首輪自行分配學位，
基本上20 分以上先好入表，
因為20 分以下抽籤都無機會。
St. Jo 係呢個階段有約150個學額，
華仁因為分左上、下午校，
只可報其中一晝，只得37 個學額，
論抽中機會，應St. Jo 高得多。

St. Jo 多學額，升中競爭自然大，
英文水準亦高，小朋友要好努力，
應該OK 既，我兩個朋友既仔，
都可以keep 住全級50名之內，
話唔辛苦無壓力你都唔信喇。

華仁壓力無咁大，但都總有壓力的，
而家讀咩學校都係咁架喇。
學校操行都捉得幾緊架，
如果小朋友無時停，你要預左，
可能日日都比人寫手冊，紅當當呀。

不過眼見呢兩間既學生都是快樂的，
St. Jo 既比較活躍一點，華仁的定一點。
有時壓力未必只來自學校，反而是來自父母。

fannycheungmc

Lunn ma mi and sindy ma mi,

I know both your sons studied in wah yan prim and you cannot admit the truth that Wah Yan Sec principal already stated about half a year ago that they will not dragon with wah yan primary because of the deteriorating english standard of wah yan prim. this is to also safe Wah Yan from forced to change into CMI secondary school because of 75% threshold for english langauage ability of all secondary form one students.

Don't misguide BK parents by your so called figures on how many students in each and the percentage of admission to secondary, this is not the point at all because we are talking about breaking the dragon. By the way, your figures are history and when teh new 75% englsih standard come on to effective, then these figures are meaningless at all.

Face the reality. Tell the truth to parents. Even those not admitted back to st jo secondary, they are still better than the best students in other schools. Wah Yan will surely take more st jo boys than wah yan boys because the st jo boys english is much better than wah yan boys. Understand?

麟媽媽 寫道:
其實有幾多分去報機會大呢？
係首輪自行分配學位，
基本上20 分以上先好入表，
因為20 分以下抽籤都無機會。
St. Jo 係呢個階段有約150個學額，
華仁因為分左上、下午校，
只可報其中一晝，只得37 個學額，
論抽中機會，應St. Jo 高得多。

St. Jo 多學額，升中競爭自然大，
英文水準亦高，小朋友要好努力，
應該OK 既，我兩個朋友既仔，
都可以keep 住全級50名之內，
話唔辛苦無壓力你都唔信喇。

華仁壓力無咁大，但都總有壓力的，
而家讀咩學校都係咁架喇。
學校操行都捉得幾緊架，
如果小朋友無時停，你要預左，
可能日日都比人寫手冊，紅當當呀。

不過眼見呢兩間既學生都是快樂的，
St. Jo 既比較活躍一點，華仁的定一點。
有時壓力未必只來自學校，反而是來自父母。

麟媽媽

     
答你都晒聲壞氣。

千尋

千尋

fannycheungmc 寫道:

Face the reality. Tell the truth to parents. Even those not admitted back to st jo secondary, they are still better than the best students in other schools. Wah Yan will surely take more st jo boys than wah yan boys because the st jo boys english is much better than wah yan boys. Understand?

fannycheungmc,

May I have the following comments on the above statements you made.

1.  I agree with you that the overall English standard of St. Joseph's students may be above Wah Yan's.

2. However, with regards to the top 25 % amongst the band 1 boys in Wah Yan, your statement may not truly reflect the real situation.  Indeed, the English standard of the cream in Wah Yan should not be inferior to those of St. Joseph's.

BearMum

fannycheungmc,

你講的是否真的己confirm Wah Yan Sec principal said will not dragon with Wah Yan primary OR 只是有chance not dragon only.  This is different ga wor.

而接龍的限期是2012, then if this year Sept 06 to study at Wah Yan primary that means 2012 just time to Form 1.   甘影響唔到今年入學的小一.  

Please correct me if I'm wrong!

Sindy

Sindy

fannycheungmc 寫道:
Lunn ma mi and sindy ma mi,

I know both your sons studied in wah yan prim

你連最基本我個仔得三歲,你都唔清楚,但就好似好清楚咁話我仔係呢度讀,都有d問題啦.................唔好將唔知既事講到好真咁.....應該係知乜講乜先啱架

GreyParrot

我不是華仁家長，當中情況我不便多加評論。  但作為聖若瑟家長，可以話你知事實並不如你所想像。  

聖若瑟中學唔收的小學同學，並不是唔憂冇學校收。  還記得去年幾次呈分試主要科的試卷都出得十分之深，本來考A的同學變了考B，這些同學當然冇無題，他們仍然是band 1生，但成績稍遜的同學就會由B變C，甚至D。  這些band 2生好彩的話，大抽獎會入番自己中學，唔好彩的，連去其他比較好的中學取報名表都冇資格，因為大部份好的中學都要求主要科有B以上。

事非經過不知難，當中壓力只有自己知。

fannycheungmc 寫道:
Face the reality. Tell the truth to parents. Even those not admitted back to st jo secondary, they are still better than the best students in other schools. Wah Yan will surely take more st jo boys than wah yan boys because the st jo boys english is much better than wah yan boys. Understand?

felix喵喵

真係頂唔順, 她竟然仍在胡說八道,
重係樹講自己有機清楚, 有機明白,
我懷疑他根本在"撥火", "撩交打",
完全冇諗個會報讀華仁,
只是在"唱衰其他學校", 暗地裡就報其他學校,
這些人最好是不理他, 唔洗回應,
等他自己發瘋語,
他越講得多, 其他人就會知道他"冇料".
係哦, 你快d去報st. jo lar, 你會快樂d 啊.
真係...願天主保佑!

板主, 有人在搗亂呀...注意, 注意!!!!!!

fannycheungmc

一句就夠：要達標，華仁升中絕對悲。

felix喵喵 寫道:
真係頂唔順, 她竟然仍在胡說八道,
重係樹講自己有機清楚, 有機明白,
我懷疑他根本在"撥火", "撩交打",
完全冇諗個會報讀華仁,
只是在"唱衰其他學校", 暗地裡就報其他學校,
這些人最好是不理他, 唔洗回應,
等他自己發瘋語,
他越講得多, 其他人就會知道他"冇料".
係哦, 你快d去報st. jo lar, 你會快樂d 啊.
真係...願天主保佑!

板主, 有人在搗亂呀...注意, 注意!!!!!!

麟媽媽

點解你有口話人無口話自己？？
原來你最鐘情於SJC，咁你去報囉，
唔使搵佢同華仁比較架？！
又無人迫你報華仁。
好老土啊.........

fannycheungmc 寫道:
i disagree with YxxChild, he is strong worded and only said prejudice things because he likes HKUGAPS. I agree HKUGAPS may be very good, that is his choice. I prefer old traditional schools, i prefer free education and good ones like SJC more. Please don't attack me just because I do not like what you like.