結龍學校獲「優待」 被抨不公

youma

Many traditional famous schools (with affiliated primary schools) were prepared to change to one dragon.

If they really do so, the chance of outsiders to these secondary secondary will be much reduced.

EdT 寫道:
吾計直資同私校,好似得英華同St Mary。佔全港學校不到1%, 估下架乍。D校長為拗而拗姐。

Mrssslui

那麼,現在若入讀了,有否影響升中呢?
還是2012年後入讀的才有影響呢?

WYmom 寫道:
[quote]
Mrssslui 寫道:
所謂既聯繫學校,多數未必只有一間小學跟中學聯繫,那麼,怎樣一條龍呢?

聯繫 or 直屬 schools are not one-dragon schools, they need to break their link by 2012 if they cannot form a one-dragon.

Just wonder how many of these schools will become one-dragon.  I think maybe only those top schools can be one-dragon, or they may just change to DSS.[/quote]

麟媽媽

2007年9月入小一的是尾班車。

Mrssslui 寫道:
那麼,現在若入讀了,有否影響升中呢?
還是2012年後入讀的才有影響呢?
[quote]
WYmom 寫道:
[quote]
Mrssslui 寫道:
所謂既聯繫學校,多數未必只有一間小學跟中學聯繫,那麼,怎樣一條龍呢?

聯繫 or 直屬 schools are not one-dragon schools, they need to break their link by 2012 if they cannot form a one-dragon.

Just wonder how many of these schools will become one-dragon.  I think maybe only those top schools can be one-dragon, or they may just change to DSS.[/quote][/quote]

Mrssslui

麟媽媽,

謝謝你的解答.
請問從何得知呢?

judy

2. 但這不是容易與否的問題, 英中準則本來是[以學生為本], 讓有英語聽講能力的可以選擇用英語上課, 因此它並非是評審學校成為一條龍的工具, 其實中中龍也是龍啊! 而給一條龍學校「優待」根本是[以學校為本], 理據也十分諉牽強,並對其他要收85%band1才成為英中的學校不公;

youma，

我講算啦！算啦！我一早說過，一條龍，只是做証小一至中六一間學校，不是甚麼一條龍=好学校，不是甚麼一條龍=英中，更不是甚麼一條龍=band1英中。

看世事，有時，應有同情之心，要有無限之同情。記不記得和你争論小一入學辦法公平否之女士(我看唔明，不知他在說甚麽)，當時一間band3中之band3小學一轉名，甚麽也沒有改，换個地方，轉名一轉名，他就撲過去，你同佢講喂嗰間轉名啫，佢想死咁樣，又人身攻擊，又話你有病。不錯，有的人又講"講理"，又講"信緣"，好像很有禪機咁，其實，口頭禪而己。如果你令其無得升英中，佢死比你睇，角璋又點負責得了呢？此其一。

看世事，有時用合理，用合乎社會利益比公平更具建設性。我看一條龍是值得推行之政策，鼓勵學校轉龍，值得。此其二。

第三，對傳统之保存，如果讓華仁，喇沙，MCS等名校沒有條件咁轉龍，我也舉脚讚成。這些名校是香港的歷史，是美好之回憶，是無價寶。

麟媽媽

2012年係deadline吖嘛。
一係結龍，一係脫鈎，
我照"tun"番六年咋！

Mrssslui 寫道:
麟媽媽,

謝謝你的解答.
請問從何得知呢?

Mrssslui

咁唔係應該2012年先開始行咩?
或學校決定結龍個年就開始行?

麟媽媽 寫道:
2012年係deadline吖嘛。
一係結龍，一係脫鈎，
我照"tun"番六年咋！

[quote]
Mrssslui 寫道:
麟媽媽,

謝謝你的解答.
請問從何得知呢?

[/quote]

麟媽媽

唔….如果結左龍都要照行喇。
但而家間間未落實接龍的，
多是英中因又怕直屬小學唔達標…
咁唔接龍咪要脫鈎囉…
如果脫鈎2012小六咪係尾班車囉。

Mrssslui 寫道:
咁唔係應該2012年先開始行咩?
或學校決定結龍個年就開始行?
[quote]
麟媽媽 寫道:
2012年係deadline吖嘛。
一係結龍，一係脫鈎，
我照"tun"番六年咋！

[quote]
Mrssslui 寫道:
麟媽媽,

謝謝你的解答.
請問從何得知呢?

[/quote][/quote]

Mrssslui

應該唔會即刻實行個喎!
如男小拔,佢話脫勾,都係等最後個班小學生(宣報後計)升中後才實行.
如2012年既小六係尾班車,那麼讀緊佢地既小一至小五咪好慘囉!隨時冇得上車.
咁D家長揀唔揀好呀!咪要博一次.

麟媽媽

2012年小六既而家仲係K.2 之嘛。
所以我估計各直屬校應該會係短期內公報，
可能一年之內，睇吓結龍定脫鈎定轉DSS囉。
咁2008年入讀小一既(而家K.1)，
咪要諗清楚好唔好報已脫鈎既小學喇。

Mrssslui 寫道:
應該唔會即刻實行個喎!
如男小拔,佢話脫勾,都係等最後個班小學生(宣報後計)升中後才實行.
如2012年既小六係尾班車,那麼讀緊佢地既小一至小五咪好慘囉!隨時冇得上車.
咁D家長揀唔揀好呀!咪要博一次.

Mrssslui

麟媽媽,
我睇佢既意思係話2012才決定,而不是2006決定,2012實行喎!

麟媽媽

好似係2012實行，唔係決定喎。
你個小朋友而家幾大呀？

Mrssslui 寫道:
麟媽媽,
我睇佢既意思係話2012才決定,而不是2006決定,2012實行喎!

ykwong

lunma,

I think you are wrong, according to the newspaper, from my bad memory, it should be reinforced to all schools in 20o7/08. As 30% of discretional allocation, 10% for other net..... the rest of 85% for connecting schools should definitely deduced.

Correct me if i am wrong.

Mrssslui

我大件事D,大個個冇問題,細個個跟住入就唔掂啦!
如果冇得結龍既話,到時又唔夠分揀第二間.
都係睇定d先.

judy

ykwong,

lunma講紧結龍，搭錯線了。

麟媽媽

yk,

好耐無見你喇！！你答我>>我錯晒又點話喇！
不過...你講緊好似係新既直屬收生額喎....
Mrsssliu問緊接龍同脫鈎限期。

ykwong 寫道:
lunma,

I think you are wrong, according to the newspaper, from my bad memory, it should be reinforced to all schools in 20o7/08. As 30% of discretional allocation, 10% for other net..... the rest of 85% for connecting schools should definitely deduced.

Correct me if i am wrong.

ykwong

麟媽媽 寫道:

你答我>>我錯晒又點話喇！

Really touching!

yes, pick the wrong line.

Mrssslui

yk,

咁你有何高見呢?

ykwong

Mrssslui,

不敢!

But if there only exists two thro' train school nowadays, your problem is only concerning these two.

One of them, can't be comment, otherwise WWIII will be commenced.

I think, no school is going to make chain forever. For those still willing to do so, they should have pyschological ready to tease off the EMI label! Or more than reasonable confidence to think they could behold the label.

The point is, do you really think the present elite schools will form chain with such uncertainty? If yes, are they still your cup of tea?

If not, why bother to think. what is your situation? I mean how old is/are your kid/s?

I just look forward to seeing whether the present elite school change its link into train or not.

Sorry no high view!

麟媽媽

衰野，見你唔聲唔聲，
你都有留意近日BK 猛人喎。
你唔使怕bor，邊有人夠你講吖？
佢至多發難，亂咁搵D野鬧你架啫！

ykwong 寫道:

One of them, can't be comment, otherwise WWIII will be commenced.