軒尼詩官立vs番禺會所華仁vsSt. Joseph

hkchina2000

我有朋友個仔讀緊Hennessy am, 佢話功課唔係外間傳咁多.  男仔上QC機會有30%, 全校連女仔計就18%.

wlk168win

係呀! 軒官會有機會上QC, 其實有朋友話過, 官立學校上"名"校機會幾大, 但仲有邊d就唔清楚.
St. Joseph一般人都有講過話幾難讀.

zzkate

Dear wlk168win, hkchina2000,

                

zzkate

motheroffour 寫道:
wlk,

Please don't act like that. Bad influence on kids.

motheroffour

How about your boasting behaviour?  I wonder if it is your "motto" of teaching your 4 kids?

          

zzkate

siutingmama 寫道:
motheroffour

When I saw what you have quoted in this thread, I think I must write something to interrupt.

I totally agree with hkchina that what you have been stating in this discussion is merely a show-off of your case.  Sorry, nobody will appreciate such an act.

When you say all schools are equally good and kids are all equally smart, then why do you at the same time say that our kids are all in the very very best school...you should only say your kids are studying in NORMAL SCHOOL only, nothing special.

Be honest, are the schools your kids studying the target school of you and you get the application for them and choose the school for them or did you pick it up randomly???  The answer is obvious !!!  You plan for this !!!  But
I see no point you discourage other caring parents to search information of good schools for the good of their beloved kids.  

If you don't have any useful info or not interested on this topic, you'd better open a new topic to invite people to "share your happiness of having kids studying in the dream schools of others"  I doubt if anyone would like to give it a damn.


[quote]
motheroffour 寫道:
Sorry, we, BK parents, decided to become responsible and have decided NOT to compare schools. It is unfair to kids who are not studying in famous schools.

Our motto is: All schools are equally good and all kids are equally smart.

[/quote]

Agree!         

motheroffour

wlk and hkchina,

Dear both of you.

As chairman Mao said, "those who did not do any research had no rights to say anything."

What you said about SJC, WYC and Henessy are just without basis. Do you think you could have helped Maisy by these "hearsay" comments.

As I said, you like to take matters out of their context. What a pity.

Take the example of the  democratic march yesterday, the orgianisers said there were 250,000 people but they said they can't tell us how they arrived at this figure. But the HKU reasearch team said there were about 60,000 to 80,000, and they explained their methodology in calcalutions.

So watch out for parents giving out biased comments about schools. Most simply do not have basis, and are imaginations only, sometimes.

wlk168win

zzkate:    

xiaomama

"ALL schools are equally good and kids are all equally smart."


不可能吧?十根手指的長短都不一樣啊!

npMaMa

motheroffour 寫道:
Sorry, we, BK parents, decided to become responsible and have decided NOT to compare schools. It is unfair to kids who are not studying in famous schools.

M-O-F

Please don’t use “we have decided” as you have no right to draw conclusion on behalf of BK’s parents.
If you don’t agree people to label famous and infamous school, why do you always emphasis your kids study in very very famous schools.  It is really contradict to all your remarks!   :tongue:

npMaMa

Wootaitai,you are right!  Don't waste our precious time.

For Wah Yan , it has its secondary school, overall is good but limited places for lucky draw.
For St. Joseph, English school, keen competition among students but more places for lucky draw.
For Hennessy, if the kids can get into top 50 positions, the chance to go to band 1 secondary school is higher.
I have the same difficulty in choosing one of the above for my son in the year of 2007!

motheroffour

Wootaitai,

You have missed our discussion about biased comments. You said you 'think' SJC boys are active and better at English. Where is the evidence???

You are misleading the BK parents. If you don't mind, please shut up. Other BK parents have already told us that they wanted to share 'facts' and 'information' and not imaginations like 'I think'.

Please provide facts and information.
I feel sorry for our BK parents most of whom are intelligent people except perhaps a few.

wlk168win

Hi npMaMa + wotaitai:
我想, 若沒足夠分數, 就不好博華仁, 因為, 去年有人20分都入唔到, 今年唔知. 不過, 華仁真係幾難入.
反正軒官都幾好, 可以試吓.
St. Jo, 英文真係幾深, 我問過書局d人, 佢地話St. Jo d 英文應該係最深(禁當然有可能難讀d, 不過都係因人而異既!).

Maisy

我個仔2歲, 其實我都係想同佢想定入邊間小學好, 從中決定入邊間幼稚園. 我心大心細唔知邊間好, 所以問吓大家意見.聽吓過來人意見. 如果無興趣研究呢個問題d人, 咪唔好答

Maisy

wlk168, npMaMa + wotaitai:

我當然想個仔將來入皇仁啦, 所以都想揀軒官, 但驚個仔唔叻入唔到皇仁, 驚住比佢壓力太大.

St. Jo, 我都知英文係幾深, 而且小學升中學8班變4班, 如果升唔到原校, 唔知派得好唔好.

華仁好難入, 但小學升中學有成70%機會. 但我想我未必揀華仁, 因為我唔係天主教, 會好難.

motheroffour

wlk,

Not only did kids with 20 marks failed in Wah Yan last year, kids with 20 marks also failed in SJC. So Maisy, I think the safest is Hennessy based on random probability. Forget about which is the best of the three.

Just choose Hennessy.

麟媽媽

Maisy,

如果你個BB只係兩歲，
真係諗定都唔知有無用。
有好多人選擇有直屬中學既小學，
都係貪將來升中有保障，
因為中學收生方面對直屬小學有利。
但大家都應該知道家下07年教改，
正正衝著呢類學校 >>  一係結龍，一係脫鈎。
結龍有隱憂，達標不到80%請轉中中，
名校們要做到3科全達標？真的有難度…
名校為保百年英中招牌，會否脫鈎？
脫左鈎又會點呢？仲有無人爭餐死？
真係未知之數？睇下DPS脫鈎之後如何？
舊年係呢度比人彈到呢... 真係慘...
唉....幾十年無功都有勞吖！
所以咁早唔使煩住，只因太多變數。

motheroffour

Wootaitai,

Now you are talking.

It is based on points and lucky draw. So at last you agreed with me that there is no need for Maisy to compare. It was the system that made my kids study in what most BK parents called famous schools, it has got nothing to do with me. So you now understand that I did not boast.

Maisy does not have any special relationship marks for her kid. No way out. I was telling her the truth. Perhaps, she should try some DSS schools as a kind of guarantee of good eduction.

Just as Uncleedward said, the elite system for the privileged class is now building up through the DSS system. I may be harsh in words but that is life in Hong Kong.

motheroffour

麟媽媽

You are right. Wah Yan Secondary principal not long ago said they will not accept Wah Yan primay boys any more in the future if their English standard continue to fall.

Most Wah Yan Primary parents know this news, but whenever any BK parents asked about how good is Wah Yan primary, they keep silent to HIDE this point. They always say it is a good school. Do you think these parents are dishonest.

You knew this information also, right?

So beware.