請比意見: 如果目標是港島區私小/直資，讀Victoria還是靈糧堂好D, 咁Kentville和

蘿記

係呀 麟媽媽
我見你係

2mings

Hi Charlotte_mom

我睇過 Victoria (click) 既資料,見 2003至2005 兩年入讀堅小及麥小的人數是24及25,以除2年平均計,再加埋你寶山的數字,咪兩間kinder 已佔去 57人,剩番 56x2-57=55 個學位係來自其他幼稚園?

我想問寶山的入學申請表有冇要填父母的中小學名稱? Victoria 就有, 所以父母係來自出名中小學既,就必收! 我朋友個小朋友係interview時打其他小朋友都收在佢讀上午班!

由此引申,只係的名校校友聚埋個間幼稚園,果間幼稚園就會變成名幼稚園?!

Charlotte_mom 寫道:

..................果間唔係寶馬幼兒園, 係寶山幼兒園, 據知情人士講, 今年(arm arm公佈既結果)18個入堅小, 15個入麥小(咁上下啦, 唔記得exact figure), 創歷年新高
不過, 阿知情人士都話, 寶山講到明係揀父母既, 正確d黎講, 佢會assess下小朋友"成材"既機會有幾高, 如果只係"一般料", 寶山係寧願收小d, 都唔會亂收既(明晒啦)

   

蘿記

排名如下

SPCC
HKUGA
DBSPD (Kowloon)
St. Paul’s boy
Ramondi
True Light

Mrssslui 寫道:
咁你心儀邊間小學呀?

蘿記

2mings

點解03-04同理04-05個figure 爭咁遠架

2mings 寫道:
Hi Charlotte_mom

我睇過 Victoria (click) 既資料,見 2003至2005 兩年入讀堅小及麥小的人數是24及25,以除2年平均計,再加埋你寶山的數字,咪兩間kinder 已佔去 57人,剩番 56x2-57=55 個學位係來自其他幼稚園?

我想問寶山的入學申請表有冇要填父母的中小學名稱? Victoria 就有, 所以父母係來自出名中小學既,就必收! 我朋友個小朋友係interview時打其他小朋友都收在佢讀上午班!

由此引申,只係的名校校友聚埋個間幼稚園,果間幼稚園就會變成名幼稚園?!

[quote]
Charlotte_mom 寫道:

..................果間唔係寶馬幼兒園, 係寶山幼兒園, 據知情人士講, 今年(arm arm公佈既結果)18個入堅小, 15個入麥小(咁上下啦, 唔記得exact figure), 創歷年新高
不過, 阿知情人士都話, 寶山講到明係揀父母既, 正確d黎講, 佢會assess下小朋友"成材"既機會有幾高, 如果只係"一般料", 寶山係寧願收小d, 都唔會亂收既(明晒啦)

   [/quote]

2mings

你點睇到爭咁遠? 你有留起03-04果份?  

我都覺得奇怪,今年果份係2年加埋的數字,唔係剩講04-05一年! 唔通04-05 派得唔.....  

蘿記 寫道:

2mings

點解03-04同理04-05個figure 爭咁遠架

meyonw

我朋友女兒上年讀靈糧堂,佢話無考試,無默書,只有平詁表,都唔知點考學校, 我想你選港島區學校, 維多利亞 及 SC 會比較好.

july2005

靈糧堂一班好多學生係事實,而老師仍都好難照顧到每一位
小朋友,（當然我不是只人釘人，而是時常有小意外發生左，先生都唔知，最重要係class room唔算大，但人太多，空氣好唔流通，小朋友成日病，所以我小朋友K2都轉校了 :-|

Ms.ChanChan

靈糧堂真係改變o左咁多？ 當年小女只係生了顆小眼瘡，老師夜晚都打電話來問，而我自己都未留意到，真係慚愧!

有些家長的意見是對的，最重要清楚自己的"目標"。 "目標"是作為升讀名小學的踏腳石的話，靈糧堂果真不是你杯茶了。  我當年揀靈糧堂只係諗住比個女(及我自己)過多三年愉快無壓力的童年，當然唔係話讀其他幼稚園就會好大壓力無晒愉快童年咁，呢d只不過係我好個人的選擇!  但當初真係無咁長遠諗小學諗中學。

此外我是絕對不同意靈糧堂的畢業生上到小學會被比下去的言論! 小女的學友仔不少入到"名校"都表現不俗o架!

小夜曲

Ms.ChanChan 寫道:
靈糧堂真係改變o左咁多？ 當年小女只係生了顆小眼瘡，老師夜晚都打電話來問，而我自己都未留意到，真係慚愧!

有些家長的意見是對的，最重要清楚自己的"目標"。 "目標"是作為升讀名小學的踏腳石的話，靈糧堂果真不是你杯茶了。  我當年揀靈糧堂只係諗住比個女(及我自己)過多三年愉快無壓力的童年，當然唔係話讀其他幼稚園就會好大壓力無晒愉快童年咁，呢d只不過係我好個人的選擇!  但當初真係無咁長遠諗小學諗中學。

此外我是絕對不同意靈糧堂的畢業生上到小學會被比下去的言論! 小女的學友仔不少入到"名校"都表現不俗o架!

我完全和你想法一樣, 所以讓小朋友讀入讀靈糧堂; 不過我是讀鑽石山那間, 所以沒有他們所講的學生太多的問題.......三年來, 每班都是30人以下, 有兩個班主任+1個助理老師, 每個學生都很乖. (記得當年報考時, 都担心考不到, 因為只有120個位, 但有600名考生.)

Hilouey

my daughter study in   Causeway Bay Ling Liang Kindergarten k3 , she is very happy and next year
she study in wan chai st . francis school.
this school homework so little but learn the word so many , and my daughter go to private school all pass so no problem for this school , and this school many fuction for parent & children


hilouey

:        

RainBB

Hi Hilouey

You right but listen from other parent, homework not too much for children, do they really learn a lot of words?

Are you child study in AM?

B媽

好奇怪,成日都睇到d comment 話llc 程度淺, 但我睇其他幼稚園, 都係差唔多!!

我仔仔讀緊hkllc k3, 師生比例3:30+, k1-k3都有英文oral, 都係外國人教, k2開始學寫字, 都要做親子project!老師好清楚我仔仔既野, 學校環境唔錯,我仔仔好少病!  仲好鍾意讀書同寫字!

至於考學校方面,我覺得好睇小朋友表現,同一班入面,有d間間都得,有d相反!校長有無幫忙就唔知啦!

B媽

Hilouey 寫道:
my daughter study in   Causeway Bay Ling Liang Kindergarten k3 , she is very happy and next year
she study in wan chai st . francis school.
this school homework so little but learn the word so many , and my daughter go to private school all pass so no problem for this school , and this school many fuction for parent & children


Hioyey,

你女女讀邊班? 我仔仔讀上高甲,唔知同唔班?

hilouey

:        

Racheltcy

Hi Y2KChild,

Does your child study in LLC?  I am thinking whether I should send my boy to LLC (Causeway Bay) or SKH (Mt Butler).  Do you agree below:

LLC -- more creative and fun, can stimulate the child to learn proactively, develop their confidence, social skills...  but the bad side is their English standard is low and can't train up good discipline (co'z kids are too free at school)

SKH -- not as creative as LLC, traditional teaching method, but also happy environment. English standard is slightly better than LLC.

If you have good advise, please kindly share with me.

Hilouey

hello

my daughter study in LLC AM

Hilouey

MY DAUGHTER STUDY NEXT ROOM HER TEACHER IS MS LEUNG & MS TSE

B媽 寫道:
[quote]
Hilouey 寫道:
my daughter study in   Causeway Bay Ling Liang Kindergarten k3 , she is very happy and next year
she study in wan chai st . francis school.
this school homework so little but learn the word so many , and my daughter go to private school all pass so no problem for this school , and this school many fuction for parent & children


Hioyey,

你女女讀邊班? 我仔仔讀上高甲,唔知同唔班?

hilouey

:        

[/quote]

Hilouey

HI HI RAINBB

I STUDY IN LLC AM , BUT I FEEL MY DAUGHTER LEARN MORE WORD , SO NO PROBLEM IN THIS SCHOOL EVERY ONE STUDY IN LLC IS SO SMART
MY DAUGHTER CLASSROOM HAVE FOUR TEACHER , AND SHE LEARN EVERY WORD SHE CAN TELL ME MORE

HILOUEY

RainBB 寫道:
Hi Hilouey

You right but listen from other parent, homework not too much for children, do they really learn a lot of words?

Are you child study in AM?

B媽

Racheltcy 寫道:
Hi Y2KChild,

Does your child study in LLC?  I am thinking whether I should send my boy to LLC (Causeway Bay) or SKH (Mt Butler).  Do you agree below:

LLC -- more creative and fun, can stimulate the child to learn proactively, develop their confidence, social skills...  but the bad side is their English standard is low and can't train up good discipline (co'z kids are too free at school)

SKH -- not as creative as LLC, traditional teaching method, but also happy environment. English standard is slightly better than LLC.

If you have good advise, please kindly share with me.

LLC is no discipline is totally wrong!!  They are free but they have timetable!!  They have free-time in a day but it's not mean they can do anything in a whole day.

Eg my son can write and read all Chinese and English name of MTR & KCRC stations.  Because he likes it!

Tommy

大家好！我兩位兒子都是在香港靈糧堂幼稚園上午班畢業，大仔現讀小三，細仔讀小一。大家討論得興高采烈，我也要加入跟你們分享我的實際經驗。

首先要回答本話題的基本問題，若果單單考慮「目標是港島區私小/直資」這個因素，雖然我對其餘三間學校不太認識，但我都可以好肯定說靈糧堂是包尾，即使和Victoria比較，都要給比下去。

坊間有一些似是而非的傳說，話靈糧堂的學生容易入名校，其實現時入讀官津校只能計分，跟就讀那一間幼稚園是沒有關係的，入名校率高其實是因為很多靈糧堂家長本身就是名校舊生，又或者他們很有「辦法」。

至於入讀私小/直資又如何呢？其實真係見仁見智，有說靈糧堂學生受歡迎，但亦有人說「靈糧堂」這個招牌是一個負累，何解？因為外間有很多校長和教師都覺得靈糧堂學生程度低又太活躍，他們見到靈糧堂這三個字便用有色眼鏡去看我們。正所謂「有辣有唔辣」。

又有傳說話港島某新派直資喜歡收靈糧堂學生，到今日依然有人相信這個誤傳，仍有所盼望。但這個只是該校創校第一年的現象，當年該校剛剛創立，萬事待興，收生時教統局仍未批准她的直資辦學模式申請，於是她只能跟其他官津校一樣，透過自行收生由政府派位，報了這學校的學生便不能在第一輪再申請其他官津校。因此首年只錄得大約三倍（四百多人）的超額申請，而當年這間新校曾經到靈糧堂推介，有大量靈糧堂家長甘願放棄入讀其他官津名校的機會，向這間新校孤注一擲，因為當年沒有太多人報考，結果亦順理成章地有很多靈糧堂學生被取錄。

然而，翌年這間學校已經躍登龍門，可以不受限制地接受任何申請，結果獲得十倍超額（一千二百多人），因為學校有大量選擇和其他種種因素，所謂靈糧堂的優勢，從第二年起，已經完全消失。

又有人說曾校長好有辦法介紹學生入讀一些學校。誠然，曾校長在教育界有頭有面，當學生派不到好學校，家長向校長提出介紹學校的要求時，她是會盡力介紹一些好學校給她的學生，但這些好學校卻不一定是你們心目中所認為的「名校」。若你們對曾校長有不切實際的期望，只怕到時會令你們有更大的失望。

最後奉勸一句，若果單單考慮入讀名校這個選校因素，靈糧堂必然是最後的選擇。


Tommy