九龍城網

BillyM

freddy 寫道:
Billy M,

那麼丘佐榮 vs csk(La Salle), 你有甚麼高見?

哈哈，這兩間都很似，共通點是：

1. Band1/2(甚至3) EMI：Band1生都不會以其作首選，只用作包底之用。
2. Band2生入EMI的希望：本區Band2生，要入EMI就一定係這兩間，CSK易入些，因為係男校。
3. 水準平平的EMI：受制於收生質素，又要用英文書，唯有調淺程度去就學生。
4. 有一部份學生不喜歡用英文學習：很多入到這兩間學校的學生都不是很標青，當年很有可能都是呀媽想呀仔呀女入EMI，而因為是Band2，唯一可搏的就是這兩間。本身英文根底差，仲要用英文學習，自然無興趣。這情況在區內其餘EMI都有見過，但比例上這兩間見得最多。

總結是，如果係Band1，就等到排完華英開平黃笏南迦密銀禧，再排完沙田及其他區Band1學校，就可以考慮填這兩間。

如果係Band2，就考慮係咪一定要讀EMI，相對於區內其他好的CMI（如何官、培道等)，這兩間我覺得其實唔多吸引。如果係要EMI，就可以搏。如果唔係咁堅持，我會考慮其他CMI先。

如要在二者擇其一，我揀丘佐榮，CSK始終係男校，學生比較頑皮。

東京mewmew

Dear BillyM,

純粹八卦(兼無知), 做得英中, 物唔係間間都會收band 1學生既咩   

請恕小女子愚昧

Dogyps

BillyM 寫道:

Neither.

What is the banding of the boy?  Pang is Band3. CSK is Band 2 on average.

BillyM,

Thanks for your reply. My boy is now in band one but I'm afraid he is in between band one or two after all three 呈分試.

My cousin's son was allocated to Pang and I just want to know in case my son is in band two, should I rank Pang before CSK.  But My cousin told me Pang is OK and she was rank Pang before CSK last year.  Any other comments on Pang ?

Dogyps

freddy

Pang is 中中, CSK is 英中

小彬彬

好多都唔係.......

東京mewmew 寫道:
Dear BillyM,

純粹八卦(兼無知), 做得英中, 物唔係間間都會收band 1學生既咩   

請恕小女子愚昧

BillyM

Dogyps 寫道:
BillyM 寫道:
[quote]

Neither.

What is the banding of the boy?  Pang is Band3. CSK is Band 2 on average.

BillyM,

Thanks for your reply. My boy is now in band one but I'm afraid he is in between band one or two after all three 呈分試.

My cousin's son was allocated to Pang and I just want to know in case my son is in band two, should I rank Pang before CSK.  But My cousin told me Pang is OK and she was rank Pang before CSK last year.  Any other comments on Pang ?

Dogyps [/quote]

If I were you, I would make my son work ultra hard this coming year and make sure that he is in Band 1. There's nothing worse than being a border-line Band1/2 student.

I would rank CSK higher than Pang for the following reasons:
1. Note what's inside the bracket in CSK's full name.  The La Salle Brothers are better school managers.
2. CSK is an EMI school.
3. Pang has Band 3 students.  Im not sure if CSK has them this year (05-06).  CSK's principal admitted that they had Band 3 the year before (04-05).

BillyM

東京mewmew 寫道:
Dear BillyM,

純粹八卦(兼無知), 做得英中, 物唔係間間都會收band 1學生既咩   

請恕小女子愚昧

係架，不過唔係好多間可以收100%BAND1麻。

Fannyayms

Dear BillyM,

可否詳盡介紹吓各band 1 & band 2 校的優點,缺點? thanks a lot !!!

BillyM

Fannyayms 寫道:
Dear BillyM,

可否詳盡介紹吓各band 1 & band 2 校的優點,缺點? thanks a lot !!!

貪心D喎，間間我都差不多寫過晒，你有特別問題就再問啦，我好樂意回答。

BillyM

Fatherofdaughter 寫道:
Billy Sir,

After reading your essay, I know much more school. Would you pls suggest me which net is better for girl?

Many Thanks!

I'm only familiar with the Kln City net (know some Yau Tsim Mong net too).  I can't really compare net by net.  All I can say is, for Kln City, if the girl is a Band 1, she can definitely get into an EMI school with the appropriate selection strategy.  The same can't be said for many other nets.

Band 2 girls in the Kln City net is lucky because of 九真and 培道。Nothing much can go wrong if a Band2 girl pick these 2 as the top choices unless you are extremely unlucky.  For Yau Tsim Mong net, I really don't know what you can put for a Band2 girl.

Which net is your daughter now in?  Usually I won't suggest students to change nets if they're in Band 1.  Nobody knows what will happen after switching nets.

Fannyayms

Billy M,

那麼保良局顏寶鈴書院, 中華基督教會基道中學, 九龍塘學校(中學部), 余振強紀念中學,Banding, 校風如何? 教師熱誠關心學生你有嗎? 甚麼高見?

BillyM

Fannyayms 寫道:
Billy M,

那麼保良局顏寶鈴書院, 中華基督教會基道中學, 九龍塘學校(中學部), 余振強紀念中學,Banding, 校風如何? 教師熱誠關心學生你有嗎? 甚麼高見?

顏寶鈴
一年比一年好，前兩年新校，中一收生質素較差，又有一班質素極差的中四，所以各街坊對此校的印象麻麻。但兩年過後，中一的質素算幾好，應該有BAND2頭。如果唔介意比學費，又想讀英中的BAND2生可考慮。

基道
都係上位中，但普遍質素參差，都大約係BAND3。不過不失，BAND3生可考慮。校舍新，都係賣點之一。

九龍塘學校
不須考慮。

余振強
都係不須考慮。

BillyM

elsa2005 寫道:
Hi,BillyM,

拜讀過閣下好多篇評論和建議，非常佩服閣下在中學教育這方面的見解，意見十分中肯，對學校情況也把握得準確，希望你繼續多發表此方面的內容，我和其他家長就可以得到許多有用的訊息。

萬分感謝！

不要客氣，我都是上來這裡收集資訊，我亦不介意把我所知的公開，最緊要是令資訊流通，因為官方公佈的資料實在少得可憐。

小彬彬

elsa2005 寫道:
請問有冇人知MCS會有幾多位提供出來大抽獎呢？

因為MCS有自己直屬小學校，加之有40個自行收生位，唔知仲會唔會有位剩來作為大抽獎？

多謝各位能提供資料！

MCS 係邊間學校??

fatbabymother

Maryknoll今年有18個位剩來作為大抽獎。