St.Paul Co Ed and DGJS

jomum

DSS. There are many grammatical mistakes in your writing. You should improve your English or your son will not attain a high English standard that SPCC is maintaining.   

Msma

人地上來分享經驗, 唔係交英文 test paper! 唔好感去話人地!

父母英文好, 唔一定會教得仔女英文好 !

我姨甥父母英文會考係F添, 但大仔留學英國,超級大學內全個系考第二, 細仔仲係超好會考成積入讀醫科添 !

英文乃我地第二語言, 有錯並不出奇, 況且要教初小學生, 中三程度就得啦 !

唔曉教仔, 比你係英文系博士又點?  

DSS

Thanks for your support, Msma.

Actually I don't mind people criticisng my English as this is only my second language.  This is also one of my reasons to send my son to SPCC as this is a Chinese primary.  I always believe it would be more effective for a young kid to use their mother language in learning.  Besides, I have my role to play and I don't want to take over the full responsiblity of the teachers.

    

Ted

This place is for parents to share thought so there is no point to criticize other's language ability.  

".... You should improve your English or your son will not attain a high English standard that SPCC is maintaining."

should be more grammatically correct to write:
" ... your English or your son WOULD not attain high English standard that SPCC REQUIRES TO maintain."

So please do not use your stanard to measure others !!!



:-x  :-x  :-x

勞媽媽

乜你真以為 另一間唔谷 ？　人地小二 21個生詞，每個五次，聽日交，重有明天有第二科默書，仲有其他家課　。咁你話使唔使work hard 呢 ？

請放心, 我發夢都冇諗過另外一間唔谷,只不過我好少聽到另外一間有這類的adverse comments.  我提及個ＳＰＣＣcase 對我來說很shocking.  唔通人地攞８０＋就係冇work hard咩?  其實重點唔係邊間谷邊間唔谷咁簡單既問題，當然更加唔係有人話其中一間谷就以為人地話另外一間唔谷咁膚淺啦！我覺得個問題如果ＳＰＣＣ真係咁會令到個小朋友冇哂自信．但聽聞另外個間出嚟ｄ女仔就好有自信喎！不過呢ｄ全部都係以訛傳訛聽番嚟，我地d局外人都係憑自已感覺同有限的資料發表吓感想啫，兩間學校真正既情況係點，等ｄ真正知情人士報料啦！

gogochurch

My daughter received offers from both school and we chose SPCC.  I cannot deny that the DGJS offer is very attractive, so that despite there are many reasons to support our decision, we still want to hear your opinion.  In fact, we did not tell this to many people as we know most of them would tell us to go for the more reputable DGJS.  But it is my child's choice also, she likes SPCC and the teachers at first sight.

Here are some reasons that we chose SPCC:-

1. Although both schools are of Christian origin, SPCC upholds the Christian faith in its daily in the school life.

2. We feel that teachers of SPCC are very caring and supportive, and we have the same feeling even now.  You feel that they treasure your kid and is a partner in developing your child.

3. SPCC offers a lot of extra-circular activities so that the child can learn everything in school and take school bus home (e.g arts, computer, mandarin, swimming, table tennis, drama, gymnastics, chess, Maths Olympia, etc.).  They also have a one-hour home work session after lunch for the child to do homework.  It relieves a lot of trouble of parents.

4.  The co-ed environment is not so competitive for girls.  The child also learns how to make friends with both sex.

Of course DGJS has tonnes of advantages too, not to mention the outstanding English standard.  Their students receive more respect too.

How would you comment on our choice and anaylsis  ?

dclkwok

To be fair, you are also using your standard to measure others. May be jomum's kids are not studying in DGJS/SPCC that why her English is not as good as you. Ha ha!! Although jomum may not be writing politely, I agree that if the parents do not have a high English standard, it is hard for both of them (parents and kids) to study in these demanding schools.

Ted 寫道:
This place is for parents to share thought so there is no point to criticize other's language ability.  

".... You should improve your English or your son will not attain a high English standard that SPCC is maintaining."

should be more grammatically correct to write:
" ... your English or your son WOULD not attain high English standard that SPCC REQUIRES TO maintain."

So please do not use your stanard to measure others !!!



:-x  :-x  :-x

HuiTung

gogochurch,

Congratulations to your girl!

Point 3 sounds fantastic to me.  The arrangement is so good that children learn to be independent by doing homework on their own while they still have time to do ECAs.  Would there be any teacher to assist them doing the homework?

Gisele

我係St. Paul Co-ed的超級Fan士，假若要我放棄必收的女拔，去waitlist Co-ed，我都制!!

女校計，DGJS係好top，但不是個個叻女仔都

Msma

勞媽媽

另一間 低過90 分，先生亦會唔太高興，低過 80 亦要見先生 !唔好以為低過80 分見先生好大件事先得架，好多地區著名街坊小學都一樣 !

唔好咁膚淺啦!

咁我又唔覺另一間d小朋友咁就會無自信啦 ! 亦唔覺 spcc d學生無自信!

唔一定上得報紙多的學校學生先有自信架係嗎 ？

我並唔係局外人! 相反至親係兩間都有 讀僅!

唔通你係 真正知情人士？

   

TWMa

I agree that if the parents do not have a high English standard, it is hard for both of them (parents and kids) to study in these demanding schools.

不管是否讀 demanding schools, 孩子能否成材、像個人, 父母 English standard 高不高不重要, 人格比較重要.

ElizabethLAI

TWMa 寫道:

不管是否讀 demanding schools, 孩子能否成材、像個人, 父母 English standard 高不高不重要, 人格比較重要.

Cannot agree anymore !     

dclkwok

TWMa 寫道:
[quote]
I agree that if the parents do not have a high English standard, it is hard for both of them (parents and kids) to study in these demanding schools.

不管是否讀 demanding schools, 孩子能否成材、像個人, 父母 English standard 高不高不重要, 人格比較重要. [/quote]

Agreed but I've never said that "人格" is not important. You are talking about different things.

Wnnieng

Gogochurch,

Are you a Christian?  
I am quite regret that I have not applied the SPCC for my girl this year.  I have filled in the form but I have not submitted  - I think it's in HK side and the chance is extremely......... slim.  Too many competitors.  The most important point  is - It's too far away and take a long time to travel to school.  We are  Catholic not Christian (not the same religion of the school, I won't mind but I think this will also reduce the chance to get acceptance).   Anyway, I have a little bit regret.....

judy

gogochurch,

咁快就收到两間通知。

TWMa,

你 in 佐未？

TWMa

Judy:
以我所知, 兩間都仲未通知幾時 in, DGJS 既 Result 每年都係聖誕節前先會收到. 我諗 gogochurch 既囡囡應該讀緊 SPCC 小一了.
昨晚同我家老爺傾過, 收唔收都咁開心, 收左, 當俾個女去武林闖盪, 我地壓力好大, 唔收, 我地兩個輕鬆 d 囉  

anxiousparent

Both schools are Christian (Anglican) schools but the outlook is rather different.

St Paul's places more emphasis on moral and religiouis education.  Teachers give a lot of personal attention to the kids.  Girls tend to be more mellow.  The secondary section used to be rather "inward looking" in that apart from music festivals it did not take part in any inter-school activities, and it gave the impression that its students "kept to themselves".

DGJS stresses English a lot, and also trains girls to be "tougher".  There is less emphasis on religious education.  The secondary section is v. active in inter-school extra-curricular activities.  In this way they learn about dealing with students/people from outside their own background/surroundings.  

V difficult to say which is better than which.  There is  more "hype" about DGJS but traditionally St. Paul's does not like too much publicity.  A lot depends on your outlook, own background, expectation, etc.  I know many people who have been accepted by both, and who chose one over the other, for very different reasons.  

ki33221100

最近我自己去聽talk, 去報考, 親身"接觸"過d staff, 俾我感受好深, 一間咁出名既學校, 職員完全無果種"狗眼看人低"既氣焰, 我去聽talk, 已經遲大到, 自己都唔好意思再周圍搵位, 是但企埋一邊就算, 反而係有個staff幫我搵位, 叫我埋去坐, 仲幫我整開個curtain等我望得清楚d
去交form, d校工, 門口老師, 對我呢個三九唔識七既人, 一樣好有禮貌, 有問必答, 笑住同我點頭, 我真係好impressed
比起其他"名校", 我只不過打電話去問小小資料, 都唔想答之餘仲幾乎即刻"給"線, 真唔明佢地點樣教化下一代(我唔係指拔萃, 我無接觸過佢地)[/quote]

agree !!!

我好後悔升小一時没有替我個囡報考，上學期尾先至去報插班生，可惜只考到waitlist，但期間所遇到啲職員，無論校工、教師，或是主任級，個個好nice，俾人感覺好好，更加想個囡考入去，所以出年一定會再考過。