大家都華仁的comment？vs. SJC, SPC, DBS, YW

KikiDaddy

回覆 ok3 的帖子

WYHK's problem may be caused by: -
1. quality of the students of its feeder primary school (i.e. proportion of band 1 students); and
2. the number of band 1 students of feeder primary school "jump ship" and go to other band 1 secondary schools

papapabababa81

給你參考，剛剛完咗D1 學界游水，總成績已公佈。

18-10-28 08:54 上傳

下載附件 (287.04 KB)

papapabababa81

chelsea_ying 發表於 18-10-27 00:12
想請教下大家點睇華仁？

compare St. Jo College, SPC, DBS, YW

學術成績計4間都應該好過兩間華仁。

manmonster

回覆 KikiDaddy 的帖子

Students spending six years at WYHK should not be put as scapegoats for deteriorating school academic performance.
The core issue, I think, lies in the quality of teaching.

KikiDaddy

回覆 manmonster 的帖子

agreed WYHK should reflect on its own curriculum and teaching quality instead of just blaming its feeder school..
however, the mediocre DSE results of WYHK in recent years already discourage some band 1 students of its feeder school to put it as a first at discretionary stage of SSPA - this is a vicious cycle to further deteriorate the DSE results of WYHK.

christy2011

港華俾灣仔1C 聖鄧成績仲有一段距離。
所以港華一定晤會係1A~B中學

mcl203

papapabababa81 發表於 18-10-28 08:54
給你參考，剛剛完咗D1 學界游水，總成績已公佈。

WYHK 要降落D2～～～

magtam0520

KikiDaddy 發表於 18-10-28 09:30
回覆 manmonster 的帖子

agreed WYHK should reflect on its own curriculum and teaching quality instea ...

其實港華想轉直資，是否想copy SPC翻身的做法？

KikiDaddy

回覆 magtam0520 的帖子

we should give credit to the new principal and his teaching staff for the recent success of SPC.
schools like DBS, SPC and WYK show obvious improvement in their public exam results after their new principals are on board. i don't think it is just a coincidence. they must have done something right to put the school back on track.

chelsea_ying

yuenkw 發表於 18-10-27 21:37
如你兒呈1係Band1A，自行比我會揀SJC+某間Band1B津校、直資我揀DBS同SPC就算！
...

Thanks for the good advice. Thinking in the same way.

sunflower2000

如果計DSE，港華衹係B2A

dearmm

唔好意思，我想問大抽獎時，港華今年是band  1 or band 2 呀？

奇奇媽媽

曾經有RC人分享過，如果(emoji)港華倒不如留返係RC

christy2011

回覆 奇奇媽媽 的帖子

RC 有公佈dse level 4 成績，進步中

73662710

WYHK 校方完全唔反醒，用30年前那套，讓學生自由學習， 30年前盡收band1A 就是自由自主學習， 今時今日收了很多band1C band 2A，等於24-44 percentile 的學生，屬於5個band 時代的band 2 生。自由放任等於自生自滅。

happykidz

mcl203 發表於 18-10-28 09:43
WYHK 要降落D2～～～

港華呢幾年喺學界D1游泳都係做升降機, 11年同16年都試過跌落D2。

王家爸爸

Sophie0804 發表於 18-10-27 12:48
港華淪落到1C, 真的嗎？

是真也是假，真係因為港華真係跌到B1C，假係因為其實最差時連B1C都無。不過，我反而覺得邊緣人值得讀，我估學校既小班教育應該有一定既幫助。

王家爸爸

dearmm 發表於 18-10-27 20:50
點解咁差？

三年前見前副校長係天橋絕食抗議學校既政策；前校長係法庭上話自己唔識英文。不過換咗新校長之後，有唔少改變，應該會慢慢好返。