細仔細女既困難

mission

[quote]
OnHo 寫道:
Hi, Mission,

可唔可以講下邊間學校俾左 offer 俾你個囡囡呢?

Subsidized school:
St. Mary's Canossian School

Private school:
崇真 (offered a place last year)
真光 (waiting list, offered a place on 7/6)
德望 (waiting list, infmd of 2nd interview last week)
九龍塘宣道 (waiting list, offered a place on 29/6)

Blythemia

我女十二月出世.又生得細粒.幼稚園既時候,的確同大過佢既同學有D距離,好似D小肌肉發展遲過人,畫線畫得唔好,但係而家三年級,除左高度始終差D之外,冇乜野明顯比唔上.

唔好標簽佢地,每個人既天賦都唔同,開竅既時間都唔一樣.或者真係報私校會較唔著數,但係就算俾你一月一日出世,唔掂人地一樣唔會收.就算係細,一樣有好醒既小朋友.到得五六年級,所謂大細既差距已經冇乜大意義.

toffeeli

其實每個小朋友的發展都唔同，好難一概而論。

我自己仔仔係10月出世，而家K3，佢生得高大，但係全班年紀最細。雖然他的成績幾好，但有D嘢係會力有不逮，好多時同肌肉發展有關，K1時尤其明顯。

我個人意見係如果K1已明顯發現小朋友跟唔上就在K1 repeat，K3 repeat 可能會無咁好，因為小朋友卻已經懂事，或許祈待著升小一，就算repeat 都最好唔好在原校。

K1 repeat 有另一好處，就係襯機會轉去心儀的幼稚園!

Cherrymuima

Charolotte,

Think about it in another way. Kids born in September to December has more choices.
Your daughter has two chances of lucky draw. If she cannot get a good offer in the first year. Of course, most of the private school will not accept small kids.
Then, you can let your child to study K3 again and wait for another lucky draw next year.  In addition, she will be a big kids in another year and easily get an offer in private schools.

My daughter can get the offer from most the private school applied except DGS as a big girl and he was born in December.

toffeeli

Cherrymuima,

As far as I understand, each child is entitled for lucky draw of one school year only.

toffeeli

Cherrymuima

Toffeeli,

I remembered the TVB News last year after the announcement of P1 lucky draw result, the happy father replied to the media that he could not get an offer from YMT Catholic  in the first year but he tried again the other year and got the offer.
I can't find any problem with this arrangement.

晴晴晴

我好同意,感受得到

toffeeli 寫道:
其實每個小朋友的發展都唔同，好難一概而論。

我自己仔仔係10月出世，而家K3，佢生得高大，但係全班年紀最細。雖然他的成績幾好，但有D嘢係會力有不逮，好多時同肌肉發展有關，K1時尤其明顯。

我個人意見係如果K1已明顯發現小朋友跟唔上就在K1 repeat，K3 repeat 可能會無咁好，因為小朋友卻已經懂事，或許祈待著升小一，就算repeat 都最好唔好在原校。

K1 repeat 有另一好處，就係襯機會轉去心儀的幼稚園!

ICHUN

Hi Cherrymuima,

I agree with Toffeeli.  You better check with EMB before you make such decision.  Otherwise, it would be bad.

hot1234

Hi Cherrymuima,

The information of Toffeeli and ICHUN should be correct, each child can only entitle for ONE lucky draw in his/her life.  I'm not sure the case your mentioned of YMT Catholic, which may be through "knock door" but also not sure whether those subsidized school will accept students without the P.1 registration form.   

Besides, I would not suggest for repeat unless you find the kid is really cannot catch up with others.  Yes, it's true that younger kid may not be perform so good but I think it is only on physical side.  On academic side, I don't see very much difference as I daughter is born in September and her school result is quite good.

ICHUN 寫道:
Hi Cherrymuima,

I agree with Toffeeli.  You better check with EMB before you make such decision.  Otherwise, it would be bad.

yinyin

如果不是2000年, 我也打算做大女,細女真是很吃力的, 不過要REPEAT 我認為K2 好, K2成績好重要去見學校,可以再讀多一次考好的成績及K2 成熟了很多有好的課外活動成績, 可以羅多D 獎狀証書去見學校.

mission
我個女重細你個女一個月, 但我就冇你咁大膽, 我怕個女是細女到時間間學校都唔收咪好hurt 佢, 因此我一間私校都冇考, 諗住派完位先算.

聽sindy 咁講我地係咪明年重可以去考下DGJS.

我地7/23 家長日不知是否有機會見到

晴晴晴

YINYIN,

你囡囡係唔係99年細女呀.已在今年讀P1呀?

晴

yinyin

晴

係呀, 佢升P.1,

不過我比佢學SWIMMING 佢體能明顯係不同了, 又高大了很多, 都有115CM, 學校去年的運動會同今年運動會, 見佢是進步了

佢學會了自由式, 蛙式, 背式, 不過學習過程都好辛苦

而寫字方面, 我比佢學了硬筆書法, 因此K3下學期寫字已進步了很多, 但學習過程又係好辛苦

這都都為了亞女小一的預備

反而我認為亞女領導才能弱D.

你小朋友呢?

晴晴晴 寫道:
YINYIN,

你囡囡係唔係99年細女呀.已在今年讀P1呀?

晴

晴晴晴

YINYIN,

我小朋友都係細女,又係今年P1,在K1時好想佢再讀K1做大女,但老師唔比,今年考私小就唔係好好.自己運氣又唔好,所以都好煩,你打算讀邊間呀?

晴

hot1234

I think it isn't good to the kids to repeat in any years as they will know even in K1.  The kids are nowadays more smart and will question why other classmates are promoted to upper class and he/she has to repeat.  I think why not decide before the kids are going to enter kindergarten.  Of course, if the kids are really not catching up with others, there is no choice to repeat.     

yinyin

晴

我好好彩派了第1志願, 為了佢可以適應小學生涯, 因此都做了好多功夫, 我個女都幾成熟, 每日放學回來, 吃完午飯便自已完成當天的功課及溫書, 因學校逢2,4都要小測,佢都可以好輕鬆處理, 我唔同佢考私校, 不是對佢沒有信心,只是不想學校認為佢是細女, 不收佢, 如果今次真是派不好, 而現在佢都有5.5YRS 大個女了很多相信對答都會好好多, 你想下一個4YRS 幾的小朋友去INTERVIEW 都好辛苦的, 差1年真是差很遠的.

晴晴晴

你真係好彩派了第1志願      我都認同差1年真是差很遠的.

mission

mission
我個女重細你個女一個月, 但我就冇你咁大膽, 我怕個女是細女到時間間學校都唔收咪好hurt 佢, 因此我一間私校都冇考, 諗住派完位先算.

聽sindy 咁講我地係咪明年重可以去考下DGJS.

我地7/23 家長日不知是否有機會見到

yinyin

I think you are bold enough not to prepare any alternative for your daughter before the central allocation. I applied to quite a no. of private primary schools for my daughter just as back up in case if the central allocation result cannot meet my wishes. (Actually I have a wish that my daughter can enter St. Mary long before she entered K1)

My daughter has applied DGJS but failed this year and I don't intend to let her try again next year, since I believe DGJS don't suits her.

By the way, I have not yet received the 2nd registration letter from St. Mary, have you?
:wink:

Cherrymuima

Onho,

The private prefer to accept big child, even some famous private school refuse to accept any application form for small child. I had the decision to let my chilld to repeat K2 as she was born in Dec, in case she cannot get a good offer in the 1st round lucky draw. To the worse scenario, we will have a better chance to successfully "knock door" or to select the best private school for her as she was much mature and got more useful certificates.
  
Think about, if you are the principal of the school, you will select the smaller one or the bigger one, of course some small child can catch up in later stage. As he has to upgrade the school average standard, why should he take the risk,

yinyin

mission

張註冊証寫明6月有信通知, 如果不出席便會取消學位, 我見都重未收到咪打去問下,個職員好有禮, 佢話這2天會寄出, 及同我講記住7/23家長會.

我中學會考都已好鐘意此校, 日日返工都會經過此校, 重搬埋屋, 操fit個女去迎合此校, 夢想成真的感覺真係好開心.