九龍華仁中學

Mimi_Ma

MomMom 寫道:
Agreed with BillyM's comment.  It is true!

------------------------------------------------------

對不起，不能同意。

升中機制就是這樣，區內同是BAND1的學生就會一起派，無分學校。不出名學校最渣的BAND1生有機會派得好過油天全級第一。我說的是BAND1生，不是所有學生，小朋友要在校成為BAND1生才會有均等的機會。

那為何油天德信會有那麼多人入九華？關鍵是BAND1生的數目，油天每年約有100名BAND1生，當然多人中九華，其他成績較遜色的小學可能只有20名BAND1生，入九華的數目便少。

還有，油天之所以受歡迎，是因為BAND1比率高，但相對校內競爭也大，一個小朋友在油天考BAND2第一，可能在其他學校可成為BAND1生。這樣一來，後者入九華的機會便遠高於前者。

派位只是選學校其中一個因素，不要純為派位好壞而揀某間學校，小朋友要在那裡度過人生重要的6年，如果學校不適合小朋友，這6年也很難捱的。

[/quote]

我都同意她們的論點,  而德信小派入華仁較多是兩校是有...聯繫,  我曾於早前睇過德信某個topic, 德信家長說華仁每年會預留某數額學生給德信學生入讀.  所以華仁收德信學生較多.  
而我朋友小女早年讀舊油天的,  是band 1 前列,  但選校策略出問題,  派得差,  後經校長寫推薦信去了一間英中.  聽我朋友講,  除了她還有幾位都是同樣情形入到英中.

學校列出的入英中學位, 未必是大抽獎中獎的, 很多都是學校與中學關係及校長實力,  而舊油天校長是很有實力及叫學生選校較進取(我朋友講的).   另一方面很多小學教師都很務實,  不會推薦學生去抽華仁這些一級名校,  他們很保守, 祗會叫學生去選D英中學位較多及略次小小的英中,  我覺得單看學校報告是否太表面呢.  

yinyin

會不會係油天是男女校, 因此有好多女仔都好叻, 派了d 好的學校, 而叻的男仔派了去男校.

因此男生數目德信會好似是派得好d

virgokaren

yinyin 寫道:
聽人講亞哥收, 細佬都未必收
有個朋友亞哥讀緊華仁了, 細佬成績又好, 彈琴又有8級, 華仁都不收, 倪都倪不到
不知佢地喜歡邊種學生

我估佢地都係以學術成績為主，但油天是天主教小學，入華仁會比協和有利。

細表弟成績都好好架！數學經常拿獎，都有d 機會的！

yinyin

細表弟一定冇問題la


我都要叫我個仔努力讀書         

DoReMi媽媽

Mimi_Ma 寫道:
我都同意她們的論點,  而德信小派入華仁較多是兩校是有...聯繫,  我曾於早前睇過德信某個topic, 德信家長說華仁每年會預留某數額學生給德信學生入讀.  所以華仁收德信學生較多.  
而我朋友小女早年讀舊油天的,  是band 1 前列,  但選校策略出問題,  派得差,  後經校長寫推薦信去了一間英中.  聽我朋友講,  除了她還有幾位都是同樣情形入到英中.

學校列出的入英中學位, 未必是大抽獎中獎的, 很多都是學校與中學關係及校長實力,  而舊油天校長是很有實力及叫學生選校較進取(我朋友講的).   另一方面很多小學教師都很務實,  不會推薦學生去抽華仁這些一級名校,  他們很保守, 祗會叫學生去選D英中學位較多及略次小小的英中,  我覺得單看學校報告是否太表面呢.  

絶對認同學校列出的入英中學位, 唔一定係大抽奬, 當中係有學問, 除咗有聯繫關係o既影響, 校長o既實力同關係亦不容忽視. 至於每間小學多數派啲咩中學, 係會受到選校o既進取態度影響. 所以若只睇學校報告, 而唔去了解學校o既背景, 只會以偏蓋全.

catcatmom

1.SORRY， 我UNDERESTIMATE左宣小，唔好意思！
BAND 1生係OVER80％，我知佢95％入英中，SCHOOL
NET好！academic RESULT又好好，但個人上唔鍾意佢，學校要求學生玩兩種樂器MUST，某程度上幫學生第日考名中，其實小朋友係咪鍾意？甘家長要BESIDE比學費外仲要比多一千幾百學樂器。


2.嘩!這位家長好似係九華INTERNAL做，O甘都比你估到？？？係就放多D料啦！
��Wah Yan release 30 admissions in the first round, I guess SFA get 5-10 seats,  德信,two 油天, two Heep Who, 陳守仁 and others share the rest, no schools has the higher chance to get into Wah Yan in first round (may be SFA has the highest chance). ��

andrew 寫道:
Wah Yan release 30 admissions in the first round, I guess SFA get 5-10 seats,  德信,two 油天, two Heep Who, 陳守仁 and others share the rest, no schools has the higher chance to get into Wah Yan in first round (may be SFA has the highest chance).

If you want your son get into Wah Yan, 1st, let your son study in a good primary school, 2nd, in the lucky draw period, put Wah Yan in first position.

[quote]唔好搬埋成堆私小ＳＦＡ，ＡＰＳ出來同人比較。宣道係要比２千幾３千蚊學費，學校要求每個學生一生兩藝，ＢＡＮＤ1生係70％。

I agree with catcatmom this time, SFA and APS is much better than油天, the % of band1 students is more than 80% (not 70%), so third, if you can afford the school fee, apply top primary schools, there are about 95% students enter to English school and 50% of them are very famous one.
[/quote]

catcatmom

TO : Mimi_Ma
//我曾於早前睇過德信某個topic, 德信家長說華仁每年會預留某數額學生給德信學生入讀. 所以華仁收德信學生較多.//

o果個德信家長無o甘講過，唔好屈人地。個topic 我有睇過, Topic係想問德信小學考入九龍華仁的機會率
德信家長話：
德信會每年有30個德信仔推薦去九龍華仁interview，張FORM係學校比埋，唔係自己去九華

andrew

2.嘩!這位家長好似係九華INTERNAL做，O甘都比你估到？？？係就放多D料啦！

Does Wah Yan has any feeder linked primary school, or any nominated Primary School? Is Wah Yan a Through Train School? If the answer is not, then, Wah Yan must release 80% of places for lucky draw.

Wah Yan will admit 200 F1 students, 20% for first stage, so 40 seats (I make a mistake before) in this stage, all students  from HK can apply the 40 seats, the students come from APS, SFA,  德信, two 油天, two Heep Who, 陳守仁 ... will fight these 40 seats. How many students in 油天 win the seats? I can guess that must be less than five. I am not tend to look down on 油天, but honesly, there are many smart boys in Hong Kong.

On the other hand, I will ask: How about the girls in 油天, are the standard of girls  much lower than  the standard of boys , how many girls in 油天?  are most of them boys?  if the answer is not, then, you will find that not many girls can enter the top schools, Why?  Simply because less seats for lucky draw!

So, If you want your son can enter to Wah Yan,

1. Choose a better school,
2. in lucky draw stage, put Wah Yan in first place, that's all.

N.B. I heard that almost boys (band1) in 油天 chose Wah Yan in lucky draw period.

catcatmom

對唔住，有疑問？
點解九華自行收生果40位會比例如APS, SFA, 德信, two 油天, two Heep Who, 陳守仁去FIGHT，All the HK students can go to fight ??  聽聞要學校推薦，(否則可能無得面試),仲要有聯繫關係，CHANCE會大D，好似32NET既SFA同Heep Who，兩間各有10位以上入九華，EVEN 係唔同區。這位家長再三提到APS，我記得以前睇過APS既WEBSITE，佢真係幾乎同九華絕緣，一來唔同SCHOOL NET，前幾年一個都派唔到，02－04兩年先至派1個。雖然APS有95％英中，BAND1生有8X％，唔係玩針對，對這間一生兩藝私小，升中派位唔係想像中甘OUTSTANDING，佢SCHOOL NET真係好好，睇佢WEBDATA睇到一舊雲，拔萃男書院99－01兩年有7位，最多o果兩年02－04係22個，即一年11個?
但拔萃男書院係03年11月開始自行收生，日後APS再入拔萃男書DATA，有待相確，另外喇沙書院最多o果年一年派2

holoto

Could anyone helps me?  My son is going to P1 this year.  I am not sure which one is better, APS or SFA?  I really want to let him study at Wah Yan.

馬利

catcatmom

更正APS只 學一種樂器咋???學2種樂器太誇張呵!!!

holoto

比著我會入SFA，5係咁 Easy 入到，學費又平好多，不過你都諗下細路程度適5適合

catcatmom

朋友2個仔讀宣道,我問佢好唔好?佢話宣道要COMPULSORY
學 A　ＭＵＳＩＣＡＬ　ＩＮＳＴＲＵＭＥＮＴ　&
ＰＩＡＮＯ唔計,　所以佢２個仔ＢＥＳＩＤＥ學ＰＩＡＮＯ仲學埋??　"拷擊"　?我問:甘你個仔鍾唔鍾意學"拷擊"?朋友答:唔鍾意都要學啦!
所以一生兩藝都無ＭＵＤ錯!!

yinyin

學琴D 學校根本就不計算你學樂器的一種



hotolo

SFA 當然好好多．

ChiChiPaPa

如果Optional都計，好多宣小生不只一生兩藝喎。當然，又有些只加入合唱團，一樣樂器都不用學。

宣小學生是可以另選樂器，不過，家長就要主動向學校提出。

catcatmom 寫道:
朋友2個仔讀宣道,我問佢好唔好?佢話宣道要COMPULSORY
學 A　ＭＵＳＩＣＡＬ　ＩＮＳＴＲＵＭＥＮＴ　&
ＰＩＡＮＯ唔計,　所以佢２個仔ＢＥＳＩＤＥ學ＰＩＡＮＯ仲學埋??　"拷擊"　?我問:甘你個仔鍾唔鍾意學"拷擊"?朋友答:唔鍾意都要學啦!
所以一生兩藝都無ＭＵＤ錯!!

馬利

catcatmom 寫道:
朋友2個仔讀宣道,我問佢好唔好?佢話宣道要COMPULSORY
學 A　ＭＵＳＩＣＡＬ　ＩＮＳＴＲＵＭＥＮＴ　&
ＰＩＡＮＯ唔計,　所以佢２個仔ＢＥＳＩＤＥ學ＰＩＡＮＯ仲學埋??　"拷擊"　?我問:甘你個仔鍾唔鍾意學"拷擊"?朋友答:唔鍾意都要學啦!
所以一生兩藝都無ＭＵＤ錯!!

OIC, 咁即係宣小要求學一種姐，你朋友自己加多一樣
好多名校音樂科要考樂器啦，我女間中學都係硬性要學。

holoto

Thank all of you.

But I still cannot make up my mind.  I son study in APS' kindergarten.  He really likes this school and some of his classmates would go APS.  Therefore he may feel happy.  However, he seems a little bit impatient.  Before I let him study musical theory in Tom Lee when he was 4.  He moved a lot and was complained by the other parents.  So the teacher not let him come out and sing with the other kids.  Then, I withdrew and dare not to join again.  So I am not sure whether my son is suitable for APS or not.  On the other hand, I am quite busy.  I usually leave home at 7 a.m. and back at about 8p.m.  I heard students of SFA have a lot of homework to do.  If my time is insufficient, is it good for him.

andrew

Could anyone helps me? My son is going to P1 this year. I am not sure which one is better, APS or SFA? I really want to let him study at Wah Yan.

In stage 1, Wah Yan release 40 seats, in this period, all students in HK can apply, and Wah Yan has right to choose the smartest students in this period, APS and SFA are both very good school, if your son is smart, I think he will win the seat in this period.

In lucky draw period, Wah Yan release 10 seats to Shamshuipo district and 5 seats to Kowloon city district, so if you insist to choose Wah Yan, in this case, SFA maybe better.

andrew

佢SCHOOL NET真係好好，睇佢WEBDATA睇到一舊雲，拔萃男書院99－01兩年有7位，最多o果兩年02－04係22個，即一年11個。

In the EMB website, you can find the term such as “Secondary School List 2003/2005”. Why is not “Secondary School List 2004/2005”, it is because every school must report the students result from Primary 5 last term and Primary 6 first 2 term.

So, if a Mama睇WEBDATA睇到一舊雲, no doubt, that Mama herself is 一舊雲.

In Secondary School allocation 2002/2004:


拔萃男書院 22          
拎萃女書院 2          
協恩中學        16          
瑪利諾修院學校(中學部) 1          
九龍華仁書院 1          
喇沙書院        5          
英華書院        4          
伊利沙伯中學 2          
total        53         

There are total 118 students, 53 of them entered to famous English Secondary School.

If APS still call 升中派位唔係想像中甘OUTSTANDING, I don't know what is "勁！"

andrew

其實油天女仔最慘，31NET無MUD女校，ST MARY有兩間直屬小學一齊爭去，越區去上智去，機會又好微，所以只能派23個同區聽聞唔錯既英中真光。

Yes, 油天女仔最慘, as you have mentioned, it is because no famous schools seats for lucky draw. Unlike the boys, there are many seats for lucky draw.

就算係BAND 1，都要睇邊間學校既BAND生。唔係針對字眼，我相信如果是band1又是同NET，讀油天或讀德信又或是XX街坊會//都有機會去抽九龍華仁//，但機會唔一樣，機會率有Ｄ好高，有Ｄ抽中機會率就低啦！因教处內部都有學校ＢＡＮＤＩＮＧ。如果一間ＢＡＮＤ３小學裹ＢＡＮＤ１學生同ＢＡＮＤ１小學裹ＢＡＮＤ１學生都有一樣機會入心儀中學，o甘Ｄ媽咪就唔冼爭崩頭入名津小。

You make me laugh, you are a very funny person.

catcatmom

朋友唔係想個仔學甘多才藝＋！佢亞仔細細個開始學ＰＩＡＮＯ，林住考間心儀小學，點知考ＳＦＡ，禮賢，陳守仁，通通唔收，得一間宣道向揮手，甘入左宣道，又話ＰＩＡＮＯ唔ＣＯＵＮＴ，甘亞仔學到某個級數，５想放棄，係人之常情喎！甘就敲擊，大提琴，小提琴，大喇叭，小喇叭，口琴，非洲鼓，都要學來向學校交差＋啦！其實係小學雜談裡，好多家長都回應左，５冼我再多講，好多小學係鼓勵小朋友去學樂器，取得一個ＢＡＬＡＮＣＥ　ＤＥＶＥＬＯＰＭＥＮＴ，隨小朋友佢地喜好同意向去學習，５唔ＣＯＭＰＵＬＳＯＲＹ，聽聞小男女拔，無一定要學！自已要去學或ＳＣＨＯＯＬ　ＣＵＬＴＵＲＥ個個同學仔都去學，係另一回事喎！

馬利 寫道:
[quote]
catcatmom 寫道:
朋友2個仔讀宣道,我問佢好唔好?佢話宣道要COMPULSORY
學 A　ＭＵＳＩＣＡＬ　ＩＮＳＴＲＵＭＥＮＴ　&
ＰＩＡＮＯ唔計,　所以佢２個仔ＢＥＳＩＤＥ學ＰＩＡＮＯ仲學埋??　"拷擊"　?我問:甘你個仔鍾唔鍾意學"拷擊"?朋友答:唔鍾意都要學啦!
所以一生兩藝都無ＭＵＤ錯!!

OIC, 咁即係宣小要求學一種姐，你朋友自己加多一樣
好多名校音樂科要考樂器啦，我女間中學都係硬性要學。[/quote]