2014年入小一，應否放棄GH去抽MCS?

Miss_ahso

你係咪mcs舊生？如果唔係純粹靠抽獎的話就，俾我就揀GH

Yanamami

GH都唔喺一條龍。而且升中學部要求高了。不過無理由放棄一d實在的而去追求一d無把握的。

karen55407

咁就揀GH啦！實在啲！

horwing

閣下當初點解選入德幼? 當然係想升德小. 如果唔take個offer, 之前的心機就枉費了.

greenlover

究竟是甚麼? 又話14年，又話35日後決定，要決定乜野呀? GH 連in 都未in 喎?
唔明...咁快出post 問XXX vs XXX?

ktgps

GH咁快就俾K2的德幼生知道有冇得直升？因為我姪女是今年的K3德幼生，也是今年才有個面試，雖是waiting ,但據知可以給全部人大抽獎，她有不少同學抽到第一志願後便放位了！為何今年改變了？

beatriceyung

Internal offer for its kinder students is announced earlier this year. Unlike last year, girls know earlier but cannot join ballot then.

greenlover

原帖由 beatriceyung 於 13-07-27 發表
Internal offer for its kinder students is announced earlier this year. Unlike last year, girls know  ...

咁你MCS在自行階段有幾多分?定純粹博大抽獎?有幾大把握?

MGPAPA

原帖由 beatriceyung 於 13-07-27 發表
Internal offer for its kinder students is announced earlier this year. Unlike last year, girls know  ...

GH 唔想自己D勁人走去對家。跟著又要唔知會收D乜料番黎。

Bengylum

不要搏大抽獎 la, 先拿了位在手，再等機會扣門。今年好多人都係0-0-0 扣到心儀小學！

iantsang

beatriceyung 發表於 13-7-27 22:09
That's the case. And that's why i am so ambivalent. if i take it, then i will have deprived my girl  ...

Certainly understand since when you choose GH, what you are expecting is to have better certainty for GH while you can still enter lucky draw and hope for the best to come.  Now this opportunity is being withheld and you are forced to choose early.

For your consideration, you can still do first round if you have 20+ points since GH will not be notified unless you get MCS seat thru first round and register.  I guess it is obvious you want MCS better than GH.  Otherwise there are no questions to ask.  As for lucky draw, what you can do is work hard on applying other private primary schools which don't have such restrictions and good enough for you to take the chance.  If there are no schools which can beat GH in your mind, then you better give up.

Good luck!

Ian

chanti

原帖由 MGPAPA 於 13-07-27 發表
GH 唔想自己D勁人走去對家。跟著又要唔知會收D乜料番黎。

因年年p1-p5 都走吾少去MCS

kittytse.ah

原帖由 iantsang 於 13-07-28 發表
Certainly understand since when you choose GH, what you are expecting is to have better certainty fo ...

Ian, 請容許在此處問一句, 1st round, 同是20分, A小朋友係首名+同宗教.同B小朋友係舊生(冇宗教), 抽籤條隊係咪唔一樣㗎？定係一齊抽, 純粹靠運？

CHP

回樓主，有妹妹跟尾+20分就考慮搏下MCS.

請問有沒有gh kg 朋友估計幾多%同學取了2014 P1 offer? 我想讓妹妹讀sc或kv(今年年尾報名), 這兩間kg比較適合我家。我的大女兒已在GH小學部，最終也只想讓妹妹升GH小學部，這又會否太搏？

iantsang

kittytse.ah 發表於 13-7-28 01:34
Ian, 請容許在此處問一句, 1st round, 同是20分, A小朋友係首名+同宗教.同B小朋友係舊生(冇宗教), 抽籤條隊 ...

一齊抽,純靠運  

beatriceyung

回復 iantsang 的帖子

Thanks for yr analysis. But according to my experience few years ago, i will have to collect the 自行form fr the kindergarten. By end of aug, if i do not tell GH i give up the place, the school will not pass me the form. In my case, i get 25 marks for the first round ballot. Therefore so headache.
BTW, thanks for all the positive views from the above. Maybe my former messages were a bit misleading.

karen55407

25分就唔同啦！放棄GH，揀MCS

easybring

民政處也可以取form.

http://www.edb.gov.hk/attachment/tc/edu-system/primary-secondary/spa-systems/primary-1-admission/2013_poaleaflet_c.pdf

gret

原帖由 beatriceyung 於 13-07-27 發表
請睇清楚先評論，係2014-2015年度！

Oh, sorry.