急請教：大抽獎表格甲部，填一間係米好 D 會快D 抽乙部

ngwong2

舊年阿仔跨區甲部揀一間(41網), 結果都中左

邊間呀?

mission2011

eocyiu 發表於 12-1-9 14:36
各位, 我去過這個網, 解釋得幾好, 睇完可能明白d 個玩法, fyi

http://www.myschool.hk/education-2-1.php

唔錯。

pandabonita

as long as the seat pool of a and b are separate and everyone follows the sequence of a then b, does it really matter?

橫風王道

咁如果甲一填本區心儀學校 A， 甲二填本區心儀學校 B (都係區內二三熱，唔易抽中，然後甲三填區外第三心儀學校 (都係果區熱門，但為叩門)，然後乙部照填區內心儀排列 A 、B、D、E...咁樣 make 唔 make sense 呢？

yiptszman10

只想問甲二及三都填熱門小學 for 外區 (只為叩門用),其實有冇用.....

mission2011

yiptszman10 發表於 12-1-10 13:51
只想問甲二及三都填熱門小學 for 外區 (只為叩門用),其實有冇用.....

機會近乎零，講誠意又冇，應該冇勿用.

pandabonita

橫風王道 發表於 12-1-10 13:19
咁如果甲一填本區心儀學校 A， 甲二填本區心儀學校 B (都係區內二三熱，唔易抽中，然後甲三填區外第三心儀 ...

但如抽中甲3,就冇機會抽乙部,如好心e甲乙一,甲部應只填甲一.

橫風王道

回復 pandabonita 的帖子

我睇完上面個 link 都係咁講，所以如果心儀區內一間小學，例如 D & G 小學，咁應該填：

甲部：1. D & G 小學  2. 漏空不填  3. 漏空不填
乙部：1. D & G 小學 2. B 小學 ...........L 小學 (按自己心目中排位或斷估，根據子女性別，抽除男校或女校，然後排滿所有區內學校。)

應該係咁？   

AndersonMama

回復 TheWiseMom 的帖子

Hi TheWise Mom,

I have the situation with you, so do you think this strategy is correct???

yiptszman10

回復 mission2011 的帖子

但填左冇蝕底者.........

marcuscyrus

yiptszman10 發表於 12-1-11 11:29
回復 mission2011 的帖子

但填左冇蝕底者.........

咁你要比較下
你會想入甲2/甲3多d，定係乙1多d
如果答案是乙1，你就應該不填甲2/3，否則比左甲2/3你，就冇機會去乙

mission2011

橫風王道 發表於 12-1-11 09:13
回復 pandabonita 的帖子

我睇完上面個 link 都係咁講，所以如果心儀區內一間小學，例如 D & G 小學，咁應 ...

正路係咁排。要補充乙部第二一定唔可以係揀同乙一同級數多人爭嘅學校，例如31網放兩間油天係乙一同乙二，乙一抽唔到嘅話，乙二都一定抽唔到。

TheWiseMom

回復 AndersonMama 的帖子

After discussing w/my husband, now I'll place my ultimate first choice, XX school, in the second choice position of the section A. And I'll place my second choice, YY school, in the first choice position of the sections A & B. The reasons are 1. I'll have a better chance to secure my second choice, YY school, and 2. XX school is extremely popular in the Kowloon side, and I put it there for knocking door's sake w/o expecting anything.

TheWiseMom

回復 mission2011 的帖子

It's strategic to put a less popular school in 2nd or 3rd choice position of the section B. But that's not the school I want. So even though I'm allocated w/that, I won't be happy & take it. So I'll still put my desirable schools on top of the list, even though they are hot. I've decided that if I'm not allocated w/either one of the top three choices in the section B, I'll knock doors. If I still fail, I'll go ahead to study at a private school already registered.

mission2011

yiptszman10 發表於 12-1-11 11:29
回復 mission2011 的帖子

但填左冇蝕底者.........

叩門成功因素有唔少，包括同學校有冇關係，同學校有冇相同宗教信仰，小朋友實力，自行同統一派位時有冇選該校為第一志願等....如果有留意應該聽過現任/前任油天校長講過, 學校會優先考慮自行同統一派位都選該校為第一志願的學生，其他學校大概也相近.....因此不少家長明知15分不足以在自行分配時入本區心儀學校，仍然照樣申請，到統一派位時仍將相同的本區心儀學校填甲一及乙一，增加叩門機會（當大抽獎唔中）.....你話揀心儀學校放甲2/甲3有幾多誠意呢?

mission2011

TheWiseMom 發表於 12-1-11 15:46
回復 mission2011 的帖子

It's strategic to put a less popular school in 2nd or 3rd choice position o ...

當然, 有私校back up 就冇問魌。

koller

想問, 咁如果我甲1,2,3 等如乙1,2,3 咁係咪都填晒甲部好呢?  請指教！