york vs sc

hangyodon

成七百人一年; 好難講得到"Which primary schools that most of SC students go"

學校冇post results; 冇人係度可以答到你; 答你嗰個都係靠估, 你會唔會信一個靠估既答案?
如果靠估都信.....
咁我答你啦: SC入小學成績好過York
:)

behappydad

原帖由 bbflashcard 於 11-12-5 23:23 發表
Thanks so much for all your valuable commet, really appreciate.

It's well known that SC's English is super. How about it's Chinese and Maths for English/Cantonese class?

Which primary schools that m ...

Q It's well known that SC's English is super. How about it's Chinese and Maths for English/Cantonese class?

A. Average


Q. Which primary schools that most of SC students go? Thanks again for the valuable comment from all smart mamas and papas.

A. Think there is no formal statistics. Just heard they are all doing well (the defn. of "doing well" is above average).


Remarks:
i. Guess SC students quality are quite good. 8000 applicants apply for 700 seats.
ii. my kid will not join either York or SC. (declare no conflict of interest)

[ 本帖最後由 behappydad 於 11-12-6 00:02 編輯 ]

veronica-bbgirl

I guess it is difficult to judge between SC and York or even others. All schools have their strengths and weaknesses. It all depends on what you like to provide to your child. Some prefers reputation; some prefer English with Mandarin environment; some prefer other things ........also whether the child and you likes the campus and teachers during the interview.

I agree that the difficulties of being admitted is one of the few reasons. Frankly speaking, if the selection criteria depends on the difficulties to be admitted, but why not many parents choose Creative Kln Tong (one dragon to their primary school) with only 1 (am) and 1 (pm) class. Only 54 places out of few thousand of application. So, it is very  difficult to fight for the places. Some parents' reason is their interactive teaching environment that does not match with their expectations. (for sharing only)

s966034

我會選YORK,佢近年來好進取, 派位成績好好, 好多入到男女拔, 喇沙等. 我識的朋友都話, 佢地TRAIN得小朋友的英文真係好好, 中文同數學, 都唔錯, 相反ST CAT 的中文數學其實一般, 而且ST CAT 由佢女兒接棒後, 教學方針已慢慢妀變, 收費多多, 教學方面反而無大妀進.

CKBCHU

慕道班事件之後，我同個女報都無報 York。因為我覺得誠信是很重要的。個人選擇，不喜歡勿插。

s966034

我會選YORK,佢近年來好進取, 派位成績好好, 好多入到男女拔, 喇沙等. 我識的朋友都話, 佢地TRAIN得小朋友的英文真係好好, 中文同數學, 都唔錯, 相反ST CAT 的中文數學其實一般, 而且ST CAT 由佢女兒接棒後, 教學方針已慢慢妀變, 收費多多, 教學方面反而無大妀進.

behappydad

diff divisions

behappydad

兩間有一段距離
必選Sc

2Fats

York強項好似係幫小朋友以超低齡去考certs, train小朋友去扣門咋喎, 至於派位派去邊, 並唔係佢地功勞啦.

但喺呢個年代/環境下, 喇沙or其他津校仲有幾多門比人扣呢

原帖由 s966034 於 11-12-6 22:33 發表
我會選YORK,佢近年來好進取, 派位成績好好, 好多入到男女拔, 喇沙等. 我識的朋友都話, 佢地TRAIN得小朋友的英文真係好好, 中文同數學, 都唔錯, 相反ST CAT 的中文數學其實一般, 而且ST CAT 由佢女兒接棒後, 教學方針 ...

ronniedad

原帖由 behappydad 於 11-12-7 13:57 發表
兩間有一段距離
必選Sc

可否講解埋係邊方面呀?等待你的分析.

Christi

以收生率計,SC並不算好難入.好多出名的細校的收生率(vs報名人數)應該比SC仲細.

behappydad

原帖由 ronniedad 於 11-12-7 14:21 發表
可否講解埋係邊方面呀?等待你的分析.

有時唔需要畫公仔畫出腸。
以收生要求為例， 要取得sc 的offer 比取得york offer 難好多。
如果offer 可以交換， sc offer 交换york offer ， 你肯我唔肯啦。放上天砰輕重立見。 又何需在呢會話題執着呢?

我只係品砰兩校級數， 名顯sc 優性。

ronniedad

原帖由 behappydad 於 11-12-7 17:43 發表


有時唔需要畫公仔畫出腸。
以收生要求為例， 要取得sc 的offer 比取得york offer 難好多。
如果offer 可以交換， sc offer 交换york offer ， 你肯我唔肯啦。放上天砰輕重立見。 又何需在呢會話題執着呢?

我只係品砰兩 ...

.............咁即係點架? 唔講得出黎分享的嗎? 真係想知你點解會對呢兩間學校評價會差咁遠. 能否舉些例子嗎? 因為如純講名氣, 咁就梗係SC羸哂啦.

[ 本帖最後由 ronniedad 於 11-12-7 19:30 編輯 ]

behappydad

我信名氣

名氣大
多高質學生
雪球效應
越滚越大

越紅頂白
簡單任務

ronniedad

原帖由 behappydad 於 11-12-7 20:13 發表
我信名氣

名氣大
多高質學生
雪球效應
越滚越大

越紅頂白
簡單任務

明白了, 謝謝你的意見!

beagoodman

一間缺德地搞慕道班,一間一直保持到名聲,自己揀啦

LL222

原帖由 beagoodman 於 11-12-5 00:33 發表
兩者我一定選sc，york的慕道班事件令我連報都無報

比$30蚊當面試練習都好吖

behappydad

小姐， 你對呢單野好激動.
我感覺到

beagoodman

唔激動呀,根本都無報York,不過唔介意的，可go ahead

ronniedad

除左名氣同運作模式(sc呢幾年咪又係不斷商業化中, 呢個係我睇到o既事實.不喜勿插!)有別外, 其實學生出來的質素包括語文能力, 自信, 禮貌, 自主學習能力.....等有什麼分別, 我諗先係討論要點吧. 我見讀sc的朋友子女中, 他們具良好的英文能力外, 都比較自信同淡定. york就英文都好, 個性就會比較活潑好動d. 以上只係我有限的觀察所得.