自行收生

thtb

早前去電教育局問及有關自行收生問題, 他們回覆是如學校自行處理的, 教育局會派人去監察, 保證公平公開公正.

xo883

原帖由 thtb 於 11-11-11 11:31 發表
早前去電教育局問及有關自行收生問題, 他們回覆是如學校自行處理的, 教育局會派人去監察, 保證公平公開公正.

講就梗係咁講, 但我唔覺得佢地會有足夠人手去監察

就好似借地址個情況一樣, 大把人過到骨

yinglongma

我相信我自行報的學校, 一,她們沒收其他資料,只對表格內的資料; 二,她們派通告,說明同分的處理。

個人認為如對學校不相信, 又何必選該校呢? 入讀了也不能與學校建立合作的關係。

joeyxlma

原帖由 yinglongma 於 11-11-11 18:35 發表
我相信我自行報的學校, 一,她們沒收其他資料,只對表格內的資料; 二,她們派通告,說明同分的處理。

個人認為如對學校不相信, 又何必選該校呢? 入讀了也不能與學校建立合作的關係。 ...

agree!

siden

In this forum sometime ago, some parents mentioned that the staff at the school asked which kindergarten the children attend when the parents hand in the form.

In the past, I trusted the system must be fair. However, after hearing the parents mentioning this phenomenon, I dont trust anymore.

If really random, why ask??

You may search the previous posts.

GoodGrief

在自行收生階段，每名學生可報全港任何一所學校，換言之，學生(即家長)擁有絕對的選擇權選擇那一所學校。若你明知或有證據顯示你所想報的學校會弄虛作假，為何仍然為兒女報讀該學校呢？我當年為我的小朋友所報的學校，明言不收portfolio和會將資料交給教育局抽籤，光明正大。

若學校的德行有問題，又如何教導我的小朋友分辨是非，黑白對錯！

MATTHAW

只要是您選擇的, 就要相信它, 否則何必選它呢?

3btsoi

一直有留意呢個post, 都有少少意見,不喜勿插...hehe
講真每個小朋友一生得一次參加派位,做父母唔緊張就假既(對津校/官校全無興趣人士除外)
早幾日我心裡都驚驚地"係咪真係公平架"?始終申請表係經人手收既,全港幾百間小學,可能有幾千個呢d學校既staff處理申請表,工作表現可能會有參差,可能會睇錯野,typo,miss左d資料....etc. 又或者staff無申報利益,間學校根本唔知發生左事.如果呢幾千人個個都公正嚴明,做事認真,甘香港真係唔駛有ICAC, 就算有EBD既人監察住,要做手腳真係唔難,始終學校staff既質素,EBD control 唔到.
之前見到d post 有父母去交表比人問小朋友讀邊間KG,又真係唔多正常,講真,交表時佢先問個甘既問題,真係黎唔切反應"立"野走唔報甘"英",多數都交左返屋企先覺唔對路
所以,我鼓勵呢d parents向EBD申報發生呢d事,備定案.不過政府d野...又未必受理:;pppp: :;pppp:

我睇完你地既post,都興幸自己果間應該ok,望就望佢d staff 精精靈靈!!

3btsoi

中間procedure係點,就真係唔知邊個做啦.

我只見到佢收form果時係全人手,你果間都好有notebook,我果間table得枝pen and a box 放申請表...無其他啦....真係好old school...

問KG果度,但係瓜田履下,響未收人已經問呢d問題,會令人誤會影響賽果......其實收左人地黎註冊先問先有意義,如果你都唔收我,知我邊間KG無用,我都唔係你既學生,對你教學計劃都無影響. 換個角度,佢想知邊間KG最like佢,但係自行,大抽獎佢又control唔到,知黎無意義,個學生好唔好都要收,最多,扣門位比晒呢間KG,但為呢d做多甘多野,唔值得亦唔合理.

siden

According to the EDB, they only "randomly" choose some schools to monitor their procedure. (read some of the post above)

Random!

Like the police "randomly" pick a driver in the highway to test for driving after alcohol. So many drivers who had drunk alcohol were driving on the road without police detecting.

However, what can we do? Maybe should really report to the EDB that the school was asking which kinder the children were attending.

SCKnight

唉，制定政策嘅都冇深思熟慮，學校有咁大灰色地帶做決定。好難怪家長冇疑慮。

lalalambb

原帖由 yinglongma 於 11-11-11 18:35 發表
我相信我自行報的學校, 一,她們沒收其他資料,只對表格內的資料; 二,她們派通告,說明同分的處理。

個人認為如對學校不相信, 又何必選該校呢? 入讀了也不能與學校建立合作的關係。 ...

同意,應信學校!

CandyTheMom

I honestly trust the school will not cheat.

What are the + points for them to do so? Get better students. But if they don't follow the rules of EDB, someone someday will leak out the info and will damage the school reputation hugely (you know how much gossips around!). What's the point? I totally trust the Principal and school management will enforce the policy and not allow anyone to do so (select students at discretionary stage).

That is why the principal put lots of focus to pick the best (academically and smart) students at 'knock door' stage because that is the only time they have control, and to lift up the average standard of students of the school.

Have some trust on people. That's very important value and we need to cultivate this to our children.

原帖由 3btsoi 於 11-11-12 01:53 發表
中間procedure係點,就真係唔知邊個做啦.

我只見到佢收form果時係全人手,你果間都好有notebook,我果間table得枝pen and a box 放申請表...無其他啦....真係好old school...

問KG果度,但係瓜田履下,響未收人已經問呢 ...

littleangelyy

原帖由 yinglongma 於 11-11-11 18:35 發表
我相信我自行報的學校, 一,她們沒收其他資料,只對表格內的資料; 二,她們派通告,說明同分的處理。

個人認為如對學校不相信, 又何必選該校呢? 入讀了也不能與學校建立合作的關係。 ...

絕對同意!
我報個間又係一模一樣咩都唔收, 派晒通告說明同分點處理, 連我個幼稚園校長都講明那小學係會交比教育暑抽的, 絕對公正.