寶山幼兒園

4eyesDad

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-9-21 00:54 發表
又不用咁大反應ge

其實很簡單，好像去Hermes 買Birkin bag 一樣，你要襯個brand profile才會賣個袋比你。其他人，比張紙仔你寫低個名咯。

學校也深明名牌知道，控制“產量”保持專貴。


只不過是物以類聚，預先filter了一班 ...

人哋賣商品，可算是有規有舉，盗亦有道，不用說什麼高尚使命，不用說什麼價值觀，明知你買唔到，又或者你唔係佢的客戶對象，佢都唔會賣個不存在的希望比你，叫你交$100「初步申請費」，然後白等。

反而….

Ryan_baba

寶山啲咁尊貴嘅kg，一般家庭嘅小朋友入到都未必係好事，無論小朋友定家長，都較難溶入＂他們＂嘅圈子。

淨係參加小朋友生日會買禮物，都可以令你好頭痛。

pandabonita

恕直言,我相信邊一間kg收form都一定要做到公平公正,不可以比人有有歧視的感覺,其實佢收得$100,而大多kg都係$30,咁會5會已代表佢同其他kg好5同,點解5做多d research先報,再講,如校長見到張form已覺得5係佢地杯茶,不如5好晒大家時間,如樓主咁緊張o個$100,咁慳返d車費都未必是壞事.不喜勿插

[ 本帖最後由 pandabonita 於 11-9-21 11:40 編輯 ]

kwansoyee

• 我遇見最過份的是woodland跑馬地,講明pg排waiting list,必要先交$1000報名費。幾時有位都唔知就要交$1000。講明報名費不可退回，同埋只係for報名，學費另計。

DucklingYau

Agree with pandabonita. I also paid $100 but never got an interview, if principal/admin already decided my child/family is not their cup of tea, then I also don't want to waste time to travel to Jardine's Lookout for an interview just for the sake of "fairness". Just think of $100 as an assessment fee. You would waste more than $100 on transportation if they grant interviews to everyone like other popular KG (i.e. SKH) anyway.

DucklingYau

On the flip side, I think it's also a big pain to attend KG interviews for some other popular schools, where you need to line up 3 hours in the street just to submit the application form, then line up again on various Saturdays to be "assessed" along with the other 1000+ applicants. On average the interviewer can only spend 1-2 mins on each child - apart from the fact that it's too short of a time to assess a child meaningfully, I also wonder if the interviewers will mix the children up post-interview! In these cases how does the application process differ from a random lottery?!? Both the schools and the parents waste time and resources in order to create the illusion of "fairness".

I've actually seen a popular pre-school in New York which has a lottery for its application form. All parents can submit their child's birth certificate number online to get a lottery number (no fee required to get a lottery number), then in a month they announce the "winners" and only those parents will receive an application form for the child's birth certificate number. At least the school can meaningfully assess the remaining children, as opposed to granting 1000+ interviews in one day like some famous KGs in HK!

login_mc

其實真係唔止寶山,香港仲有大把幼稚園要你交左報名費而唔OFFER interview, even 有得interview, 又有幾多間學校真正由校長親自選人? SPN又要你親身排隊交,又只得幾個鐘頭可以交表,又要你特別比生活照以作"評審",之後只得十分一人有機會interview, 咁呢D又叫FAIR咩?

hophopbunny 講得岩,大家你情我願,學校從來沒有sell過你

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-9-21 11:04 發表
講來講去你都係唔憤氣他們打著基督教的信仰和價值觀同收你100蚊。。。

點解你對學校唔了解又要硬比人地100蚊？你情我願，間學校從來沒有sell過你。 ...

4eyesDad

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-9-21 11:04 發表
講來講去你都係唔憤氣他們打著基督教的信仰和價值觀同收你100蚊。。。

點解你對學校唔了解又要硬比人地100蚊？你情我願，間學校從來沒有sell過你。 ...

約兩年前，港大醫學院的前院長吞捐款被囚。可以話 ，一個不誠實的人，就算如何專貴，類似港大醫學院院長，如果吞捐款，也是敗類一名。

所以，我希望我幼兒的學校，可以有能力去分辨及去教導，什麼是誠實，什麼是不誠實。

好多人話，明知唔會收人，明知唔係佢的客戶對象，但照派初步入學申請表，接受申請，屬於不誠實的行為。(你情我願? 忻福黨都話受害人係「自願」喎！)

教育不是一般商品或手袋的買賣，因為「賣方」對「買方」的影響太大，「賣方」任何不正確的觀念，會影響「買方」學童的一生。

cacanov06

好同意版主講, 宜家至開始搵幼稚園, 唔好咁緊張!
其實俾你入到寶山咁又點呀? 你個小朋友係咪又會讀得開心? 咁入到寶山係咪=入到spcc/dbs?  咁入到spcc/dbs係咪=入到hku? 入到hku係咪=成功人事.........
人生漫長, 不如意事/不公平事日日都會發生, 無謂咁執著!
如果我小朋友日日要同人比較有無司機? 住係邊? 有幾多工人? daddy係邊個? 生日會係邊個私人會所搞? 著邊個名牌衫/用品...........我會喜歡佢做一個平凡但開心有自信的小朋友呢!

DucklingYau

原帖由 cacanov06 於 11-9-22 12:21 發表
好同意版主講, 宜家至開始搵幼稚園, 唔好咁緊張!
其實俾你入到寶山咁又點呀? 你個小朋友係咪又會讀得開心? 咁入到寶山係咪=入到spcc/dbs?  咁入到spcc/dbs係咪=入到hku? 入到hku係咪=成功人事.........
人生漫長, 不 ...

Agree with you - I am sure 寶山 is a good school academically but it might not be the best-fit for your child/family. Just like even if you get into Harvard it doesn't guarantee success in life. Just relax!

4eyesDad

我已作出決定，以學校的誠信作為首要考慮因素，當中包括學校對使命追求的態度。在此，再次多謝各位寶貴的意見。

mister

Anyone know when would BHN usually release the details on admission interview？

Or any experience sharing from previous application？

Thank you！

tamtamchan

I heard from a friend that one of the criteria is that the mother needs to be a full-time housewife to look after the kid.  Working mom - sorry not their choice.

I got the application form from this KG last year ... but then I am a working mom, so I did not send in the application.

Also I know somebody's kid studying there.  The father works in investment bank, very smart guy graduated from famous overseas university.... The mother is fulltime hourse wife (she also worked in bank before).  They have a driver and most students in BHK have drivers ....

MissMusic

聽埋聽埋, 我諗我有錢都唔想自己小朋友晌入面讀書..............

Lilo

原帖由 tamtamchan 於 11-10-12 17:23 發表
I heard from a friend that one of the criteria is that the mother needs to be a full-time housewife to look after the kid.  Working mom - sorry not their choice.

I got the application form from this  ...

當然唔係啦！我舊同學個仔係到讀，佢自己係大律師，仲要係忙到嘔個隻，我覺得寶山係睇血統多d，我同學提過雖然佢地兩公婆都係大律師，不過係寶山家長中佢地係'中下階層"！