名牌幼稚園對入好小學係咪真係咁重要?

Charlotte_mom

YES, 有D幼稚園, 已經包升小學, 仲可以同時大抽獎, 你話咁有無分別?

原帖由 ecec 於 10-6-11 10:32 AM 發表
某程度上係好重要架, 尤其係有接龍既名校, 有d你入唔到佢既幼稚園, 應該已經唔駛諗上到佢間小學.

twinsstar

one-dragon is another concern...

原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 10-6-11 11:14 發表
YES, 有D幼稚園, 已經包升小學, 仲可以同時大抽獎, 你話咁有無分別?

twinsstar

may be should say it this way....

Let's try to make some factors constant. Assume that the level of the KG is similar but one is the so-called famous KG the other are not so famous. Will the name of the KG matters?

原帖由 monkey05 於 10-6-11 10:29 發表
我一路都覺得係 " important".  無論你打算比小朋友讀 dss, or lucky draw.  經常見 bk 的comment, 如打算lucky draw 就讀咩幼稚園都無所謂, 不一定要讀什麼名氣幼稚園, 你可以咁講, 但背後, 有無考慮過, 比你好luck ...

twinsstar

I think it is not the no. of interest class / the cert recieved that makes the kids different. May be it is the exposure that matters. That's why people find that the kids from famous KG are more "smart"...

Sth that i would like to add is ... I think the English standard of those famous KG is high cos many students also join extra English lessons / having great support from parents / they speak English at home.  As I said b4, the school plays some part, but parents play a more important role.

原帖由 gym 於 10-6-11 10:11 發表
I think interest classes are helpful nowadays because:
- family size is small and such classes give opportunities for social activities
- working parents may not have a lot of time to play / teach the ...

magiccandy

If it's the case that both students are of similar level, then the name of the KG will also matter because it shows how much (money+effort) the parents are willing to pay. In Hong Kong, background and image are important. It's part of the culture and norm. IT 's Just my personal opinion and observation.

原帖由 twinsstar 於 10-6-11 11:32 發表
may be should say it this way....

Let's try to make some factors constant. Assume that the level of the KG is similar but one is the so-called famous KG the other are not so famous. Will the name of ...

smartmatt

原帖由 magiccandy 於 10-6-11 13:18 發表
If it's the case that both students are of similar level, then the name of the KG will also matter because it shows how much (money+effort) the parents are willing to pay. In Hong Kong, background and ...

If that is the case then students at York, which probably charges the most fee and do most outside activities, should do very well.

traeh

No. The most expensive one is Braemar Hill Nursery. Their students usually can get into very good DSS and private schools, but I agree with twinsstar, parents probably play a more crucial role than the school.

Parents who can and willing to pay so much money for education, must be very concern of the kids' development. They would not solely rely on the school. And they are usually famous/influential/well-connected, or at least well educated, which are welcome by many primary schools, no matter which kg their kids attend.

原帖由 smartmatt 於 10-6-11 14:31 發表
If that is the case then students at York, which probably charges the most fee and do most outside activities, should do very well.

[ 本帖最後由 traeh 於 10-6-11 14:56 編輯 ]

overview

你咁稔法都岩, 盡量搵間好d既幼稚園, 程度有番咁上下, 到時升任何一間小學都唔洗咁辛苦, otherwise家長肯定教到嘔血

原帖由 monkey05 於 10-6-11 10:29 發表
我一路都覺得係 " important".  無論你打算比小朋友讀 dss, or lucky draw.  經常見 bk 的comment, 如打算lucky draw 就讀咩幼稚園都無所謂, 不一定要讀什麼名氣幼稚園, 你可以咁講, 但背後, 有無考慮過, 比你好luck ...

overview

我當初都唔信, 但小一時, 亞仔英文多過2個英文字母都串唔掂, 數學只識數數目字, 做功課又比別人慢, 因以前係幼稚園主要係玩.....而其他同學在幼稚園期間已串sentence, 學加減數, 要做好多功課, 所以佢地好輕鬆, 而我就教到嘔晒血 !

原帖由 cincin_ko 於 10-6-11 19:49 發表


原來三年幼稚園學的東西真係咁多//?? 咁大分別??

dora媽

所以經濟ok話,就唔可以返玩學劵幼稚園!教育局唔俾太早學寫字 ,揸筆,等返小學时,死補爛補, 想死!

原帖由 roseblingbling 於 10-6-12 11:30 發表
同意,太遲學寫字真系跟得辛苦啲. 朋友個仔因為寫字太慢,小一考試時永遠不夠時間作答,成績當然不好,結果由DSS名校轉往一般律校.

林嬌嬌

慎重選擇一間有聯繫小學的，（有些會學卷），師資及資源都充足，中英數全打好基礎（未必指用谷深的方法)，重視品德教育的幼稚園，其實比起去讀所謂名牌幼稚園更實際。我是過來人，好肯定咁講。
名私校幼稚園，樣樣講付錢，但用在小朋友身上的資源可以好貧乏。

CFaHB

其實都有, 不過唔多 lor ~

原帖由 cincin_ko 於 10-6-13 00:06 發表


名私校幼稚園，樣樣講付錢-> i agree, 但係真係唔知邊d唔d唔係講錢的學校但係又好le..

慎重選擇一間有聯繫小學的，（有些會學卷）-> 呢個選擇真係好少好少, 唔知係咪我識得少, 我只識一,2間.仲要上到小學係c校le. ...

[ 本帖最後由 CFaHB 於 10-6-17 11:45 編輯 ]

anteater

我是新手媽咪,請問例如有什麼學校呢?

原帖由 林嬌嬌 於 10-6-12 23:08 發表
慎重選擇一間有聯繫小學的，（有些會學卷），師資及資源都充足，中英數全打好基礎（未必指用谷深的方法)，重視品德教育的幼稚園，其實比起去讀所謂名牌幼稚園更實際。我是過來人，好肯定咁講。
名私校幼稚園，樣樣講付錢，但用在小朋友身上 ...

sandymama99

原帖由 monkey05 於 10-6-11 10:29 發表
我一路都覺得係 " important".  無論你打算比小朋友讀 dss, or lucky draw.  經常見 bk 的comment, 如打算lucky draw 就讀咩幼稚園都無所謂, 不一定要讀什麼名氣幼稚園, 你可以咁講, 但背後, 有無考慮過, 比你好luck ...

I Agree your comment. So KV and St. Cat more children to apply the seats.